Frank and Antonella rececently sold the pizzeria to another party. We have been regular cuatomers since they opened. We wenyt there tonight and it was the worst experience we have had in an Orlando restautant in 20 years. Why? The orders were screwed up. There was no more than 15 people in the restaurant and it took 45 minutes to get the food. Most importantlu
Karen B.
Hands down my favorite pizza in Orlando. It's a good chewy crust with a mild sweetness to it that is perfection. The garlic knots are phenomenal as well. Love this place!
Christine M.
Gotta try the chicken parm garlic knot sliders. It comes with 2 huge sliders. Pizza is great, and Caesar salad is good too.
Matt Bitar
This is one of the best NY style pizzeria in central Florida!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Antonella's Pie
Brandon D.
We missed our order on accident! But Antonella's made it right and hooked us up! That's just part of the reason why they're the best pizza place around; delicious too. Thanks guys! Mary and Frankie are the best thanks a ton!
Rob Green
Extra cheese pizza ? always hit right from here .Best pizza around by far .staff all cool and friendly. Won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Antonella's Pie
Karen Fuenmayor
My bf and I went here last Friday as we were exploring Winter Park area. We got here and it smells good. Saw some people that seemed to be enjoying their food and also seemed that they might frequent the pizzeria but i might be wrong. Anyways we order some chicken tenders and those were OK but the pizza “Margherita” was tasteless. I had to add some salt on top of it. The price was ok i wish my food would have been more tasty. I would not be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Kevin Morfis
Antonella's is a solid 10/10 when it comes to the quality, freshness and flavor of their food. You can conclude that the standards are high and accounted for here, which overall makes for a fantastic experience.Service is always quick, professional and courteous as well. Their recipe is truly phenomenal - and true pizza lovers will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Antonella's Pie
Sheila E.
I have been to this location many times as it is continently close to home. I love that you can run in and grab a slice or two to go. I have high standards for pizza after living in New Jersey, this place is alright, if you're looking for a kinda sweet, flavorful sauce definitely grab a slice of the Grandmas, easily their best pie. I have had mixed service here since they've opened, both fantastic/friendly experiences and mid. I like it, they've also spruced up their outdoor seating situation which is nice when the weather is amenable.
Diana Maria Stark
The food just blew us away! I had not had a Stromboli in years, and theirs was definitely delicious! The service was not the fastest, but it was worth the wait! I cannot wait to go back.
Got a student of the week coupon for two slices and a cannoli for my daughter. The pizza was so fresh and tasty, service was great. Thanks for being great AND supporting the community!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ellen C.
Delicious food, amazing service! They offered me a glass of wine while I waited for the rest of my party to get there and wiped off an outside chair from the rain for me! It's the little things and Antonella's gets that :) I loooooved the Garlic Knot Sliders and the Eggplant Rollatini. Cannot express enough how much this place rocks! Only recommendation is be strategic with your timing because the Winter Park location is kinda small. But they allow dogs on the outdoor patio and if I'm remembering correctly they do take reservations :)
Zoriemy Rivera
They are awesome and everything as always the best ⭐️???? also ask for the Grandma’s pizza!!!
Best NY style pizza on this side of town. The spinach tomato pie is my favorite. The price is high, but you pay for the quality and attention to detail. If I just wanted a cheese pie, I'd probably do Paradiso on Semoran, as it's a bit cheaper and they do 18" pies, which is my preference, but if you want the best Antonella's is it.
Frank and Antonella rececently sold the pizzeria to another party. We have been regular cuatomers since they opened. We wenyt there tonight and it was the worst experience we have had in an Orlando restautant in 20 years. Why? The orders were screwed up. There was no more than 15 people in the restaurant and it took 45 minutes to get the food. Most importantlu
Hands down my favorite pizza in Orlando. It's a good chewy crust with a mild sweetness to it that is perfection. The garlic knots are phenomenal as well. Love this place!
Gotta try the chicken parm garlic knot sliders. It comes with 2 huge sliders. Pizza is great, and Caesar salad is good too.
This is one of the best NY style pizzeria in central Florida!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Antonella's Pie
We missed our order on accident! But Antonella's made it right and hooked us up! That's just part of the reason why they're the best pizza place around; delicious too. Thanks guys! Mary and Frankie are the best thanks a ton!
Extra cheese pizza ? always hit right from here .Best pizza around by far .staff all cool and friendly. Won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Antonella's Pie
My bf and I went here last Friday as we were exploring Winter Park area. We got here and it smells good. Saw some people that seemed to be enjoying their food and also seemed that they might frequent the pizzeria but i might be wrong. Anyways we order some chicken tenders and those were OK but the pizza “Margherita” was tasteless. I had to add some salt on top of it. The price was ok i wish my food would have been more tasty. I would not be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Antonella's is a solid 10/10 when it comes to the quality, freshness and flavor of their food. You can conclude that the standards are high and accounted for here, which overall makes for a fantastic experience.Service is always quick, professional and courteous as well. Their recipe is truly phenomenal - and true pizza lovers will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Antonella's Pie
I have been to this location many times as it is continently close to home. I love that you can run in and grab a slice or two to go. I have high standards for pizza after living in New Jersey, this place is alright, if you're looking for a kinda sweet, flavorful sauce definitely grab a slice of the Grandmas, easily their best pie. I have had mixed service here since they've opened, both fantastic/friendly experiences and mid. I like it, they've also spruced up their outdoor seating situation which is nice when the weather is amenable.
The food just blew us away! I had not had a Stromboli in years, and theirs was definitely delicious! The service was not the fastest, but it was worth the wait! I cannot wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Vodka Sauce, Antonella's Calzone
Restaurantji Recommends
best pizza in Central Florida -- maybe all of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad
Got a student of the week coupon for two slices and a cannoli for my daughter. The pizza was so fresh and tasty, service was great. Thanks for being great AND supporting the community!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food, amazing service! They offered me a glass of wine while I waited for the rest of my party to get there and wiped off an outside chair from the rain for me! It's the little things and Antonella's gets that :) I loooooved the Garlic Knot Sliders and the Eggplant Rollatini. Cannot express enough how much this place rocks! Only recommendation is be strategic with your timing because the Winter Park location is kinda small. But they allow dogs on the outdoor patio and if I'm remembering correctly they do take reservations :)
They are awesome and everything as always the best ⭐️???? also ask for the Grandma’s pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Antonella's Calzone, Sicilian Pizza, Gluten Free Pizza, Eggplant Parmigiana
Best NY style pizza on this side of town. The spinach tomato pie is my favorite. The price is high, but you pay for the quality and attention to detail. If I just wanted a cheese pie, I'd probably do Paradiso on Semoran, as it's a bit cheaper and they do 18" pies, which is my preference, but if you want the best Antonella's is it.