Custom Cakes in Athens, GA

Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Shop • $
105 College Ave, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Scoop of Coffee Coffee Buzzbuzzbuzz
Stephen Colbert's Americone Dream
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Custom Milkshake 20oz
Waffle Cone Sundae
Chocolate Brownie
Late Night Snack
Brownie Special
Large 3 Scoops

“Forgot how expensive this ice cream is. $42 for 3 waffle cones and a cup. They’ve got their own versions of some fan favorites and some original flavors too. They have a couple of non dairy options. Tried the oatmeal cookie ice cream. Wasn’t a fan. Their sweet cream and Oreos was good.“

4.9 Superb235 Reviews
Sweetie Pie by Savie Bakery • $
150 Whitehall Rd, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Green Tea Croissant
Red Bean Croissant
Specialty Cake

“An adorable little shop that you must experience if you live in Athens! Their bakery selection has plenty of the “classics” as well as unique fun flavors that you won’t be able to get anywhere else in town (Thai tea cupcakes, red bean croissants, kimchi scones). Their cakes are on another level as well! And I’m always surprised at how low my total is (they’ve got great prices). Bonus: they normally have a few gluten free options!Vegetarian options: Most of the pastries are sweet rather than savory. So by default, most are vegetarianDietary restrictions: Gluten free and vegetarian options!Parking: Free parking on either side of the building“

4.9 Superb31 Reviews
Bee's Knees Bakery Bakery • $
1850 Epps Bridge Pkwy, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Smores Cupcake
Gooey Bars
Cupcakes

“I am getting ready to order my 5th birthday cake from Bee's Knees and decided to go on-line to look at what others have ordered to get ideas. I noticed that on Yelp they had less than a five star review and decided to investigate. I was surprised at what I found....2 didn't like their phone etiquette, 1 received a sample from next door "okay, one man from CT gave 1 star because they didn't serve coffee and one said something about the taste of the cake being a little dry but loved the icing! Seriously, this is why you give a 1 or 2 star review to a small business!?! First, they are really busy at lunch with their sandwiches, bakery items, preparing for catering and baking cakes and cupcakes!!! I find them to be direct and to the point when they answer the phone but not rude. It's lunch and this isn't Publix or Kroger, it is a small, independent business. Give them a little understanding. Be happy they answer the phone in these times! I'm glad to have a human and not please select a number or leave a message. To the man that gave one star for not having coffee....seriously!? Well go to Starbucks, enjoy their service and whatever you can find worth eating. Does that really qualify a one star review??? All I am saying is think before you leave one star. Give some grace....at least sometimes. Oh and one woman raved about the cupcakes but didn't like ONE of their flavors (she gave 2 stars)!!!! My experience has been wonderful. My husband absolutely LOVES their cakes as does everyone we have celebrated with. They are most accommodating in helping with a budget, short time in creating a masterpiece, helping decide on decorations, size and flavors. I'm always overjoyed with my cakes. I am going to post a picture of the last cake I ordered. It was perfect and tasted delicious!“

4.6 Superb24 Reviews
Careaway Cakes Custom Cakes • $$
Village at Cedar Shoals Shopping Center, 1055 Gaines School Rd, Athens

“The best experience with the owner of CareAway! For my son’s birthday he went shopping to get exactly what my DS would like and added it to the UGA cooler. Just to have someone care that much to make it as special as he could, with me being 5 hours away. meant the world to me. I will definitely use @CareAway Cakes & Gifts again!“

4.4 Superb7 Reviews
Loading...

Discover More Cuisines In Athens

map Map