McCray's Tavern Midtown

1163 W Peachtree St NE, Atlanta
(404) 937-6444

Recent Reviews

Courtney Potee

I loved the service here. Maya was an amazing server. I would really recommend the chicken and waffles, they were absolute amazing!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cheryl Evans

We were in town for work and stopped in for dinner. They were busy. We (2 in our party ) got seated pretty quick but it took forever for our server to come over. But they were busy so take that into account and try to be patient. We ordered beers and 1 appetizer (Reuben Eggrolls). Whew those were awful. They weren’t cooked all of the way through and the taste was just mushy and bad. We each literally took one bite and couldn’t eat the rest. We tried to talk to our server but he never came back. Finally we were frustrated and asked another server to have our server bring our bill. All in all we were there over an hour, didn’t end of eating and had to go somewhere else after paying a $40+ bill. Maybe try them out when they aren’t busy and you will have a better experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

jacob m

They wouldn't let me mix taco meats (Ex, one chicken taco and one pork) because it wasn't taco Tuesday. Seems like more of a stick than a carrot.

Jimmy Gregerson

Great staff! Excellent food! Ariel recommended the tavern chips and they are absolutely fire.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adrien Hello

Solid place to have a group lunch if you work in the area.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Smash Burger

Curtis Brown

Jacob and ace was amazing 10/10

Service: 5

Yellow Wolley

Loved everything about

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Across the Pond Fish N' Chips

Sheron Cyrus

Chicken Wings half price on Monday ❤️

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grouper Sandwich, Jumbo Wings, Salmon Chop Salad

Lindsey Norris-Garcia

Keke was an amazing server. She was really knowledgeable about the menu and really helped us make some great selections. The service was great, quick, and everything came out perfectly. Will definitely be back next time my husband and I are in midtown.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Big a Pretzel, 6th Street Nachos

K Gill

Absolutely awful! We arrived here and it was a complete waste of time and a Lyft ride. No one greeted us. I asked for help regarding how to place an order and the employee that I talked to completely brushed me off. Don’t have a sign that says “please wait to be seated” and after 10-15 mins of waiting no one ever shows up. Customers should not have to to try to find workers for assistance. Do better. If you want to stop serving at a certain time, then stop serving and simply say that. Very unprofessional and I certainly will not be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Waiter accused one of my associates of having the card she lost personally, went through all of the arguing and even the manager swearing up and down that they may have accidentally gave someone at our table 2 cards , we finally cancelled the card and blocked it because they had obviously misplaced the card. 15 minutes after we left and were outside waiting for everyone's Uber the Manager comes up to me not an apology or anything hands the card saying they found it and I explained to him that she had already locked the card and his response was “tell her to unlock it “ SAD I had previously bragged on this place before hence to why I chose it to celebrate my birthday however this was a terrible experience and it was quite embarrassing.

Senaca Williams

Bar Crawl #5

Jerry Parker

1st time and was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Smash Burger

Susan S.

Was looking for a good bloody Mary and pub food for lunch. Found the good bloody Mary here and some items of the food were great and some not so great. service started slow. We sat there for over five minutes waiting for someone to show up to a knowledge us, when she did, she was pleasant. we ordered two bloody Mary's, a salmon BLT, a Reuben and split a Cobb salad. The bloody Mary's were excellent. The Cobb salad was fresh but nothing extraordinary for $12. The salmon BLT was OK but the Reuben was awful. Ruben lacked sauerkraut & thousand island dressing. It was just pieces of turkey with a little bit of mayonnaise on it if I was not in a hurry, I would've complained because I only eat half of it and did not take the other half home because it was so bad surprisingly, the french fries were some of the best we've ever had, crisp, and hot and delicious. If we were to ever return, we would order a salad with french fries and forget the sandwiches. But for $86, including tip for lunch for two people where are the french fries were the highlight of the meal, It was ridiculously expensive.

Matthew Ruppert

Mariah was fantastic. We were one of her last customers during her. She was the most attentive and personable server. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More