Moonlight Pizza

422 Seminole Ave NE, Atlanta
(404) 968-9003

Recent Reviews

Forrest Briese

It this place ever open?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Isaiah Wilson

I ate at the old spot and remember it being decent, but after reading the reviews, I cannot return here out of principal. I'd like to thank the honest reviewers because the pictures of the pizza do indeed look like garbage. I'm not sure what's going on here but if the owner is reading this, these reviews are going to wreck you all. I skipped you all because of them, and everyone else should do the same unless things change for the better.

MegsnCheese

I've held off my review because there are hiccups when starting a restaurant. It doesn't live up to it's predessor at all. Over priced salads and hotdog buns with garlic butter and no cheese for $10.Just walk the block to Savage Pizza. I was really hoping for a slice place but if you can't do garlic bread right, we have a problem.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Garlic Bread

Lorel G.

Milo was just a gem, got the pesto pizza and it was SO GOOD!! Gave us complimentary drinks

Duhshaad

Ordered one thing, got something totally different, my first and last time EVER eating there!

Food: 1

Brandon Greenberg

Stopped in for a slice each for my kiddo and I last week during a road trip to ATL, Lil 5 Pts neighborhood was popping with soulful vibes, and the Moonlit fellas were exceptionally kind and generous to us. We ended up being gifted a whole pie due to a kitchen mixup and the pizza was on point !! Hot and crispy, gooey cheese, excellent sauce, just the right amount. As a native yankee I can recognize a fine slice. As Ferris might say, Moonlit is so choice; if you have the means I strongly recommend it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Natalie Oder

Definitely do not reccomed this place I placed an order online to pickup dinner on my break at work. When I arrived they did not have my order and I was told "Oh, sometime our receipt printer doesn't send online orders through" also apparently some of the items from my order they do not serve anymore. I had to spend my entire break waiting on my food and couldn't eat it on time. Other people who ordered after me got their pizzas first and mine was just garlic bread and a salad. Speaking of the garlic bread it is HOT DOG BUNS. THEY ARE USING HOT DOG BUNS FOR GARLIC BREAD.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Alicia Moody

Today was my first time ordering from this establishment. Connor was the young man that took my order. He had wonderful customer service and a sweet disposition. I enjoyed the pizza and will definitely be returning.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephen Corbin

Walked in for a slice. Excited to try it for the first time as we live in the neighborhood. The girl working tonight was arguing with the customer in front of us as we were trying to decide what slice we wanted. She looked at us and said "no slices were about to close". I said you close at 4 and she said "we're slow". She didn't seem to want to sell any food tonight.. I hope you have other customer service facing employees that are nice because this girl isn't it.

Service: 1

Gini G.

I'm so disappointed to write this post. We live in the neighborhood and we're excited to try it for the first time. Walked in tonight and the employee was sitting in a booth and walked over to handle the person infront of us which she started arguing with because they didn't have his order in they're system. We were talking to ourselves about what slice we were going to order and she interrupted us to say "no slices.. we're about to close". We mentioned it says they're open until four and she replied "we're slow" with nothing else to add. we left hungry and bummed about the service.

Rohan B.

They aren't open when they say they are. Big waste of time trying to order here. The food also looks terrible.

Ralph Onu

Ignore the fake reviews for this place that claim that it's so great. You are going to be very disappointed when you actually go there and find out the truth- the food is horrible, the prices are laughable and the cooks wouldn't even be allowed to cook for any of the local fast food chains. If I could rate this restaurant zero stars, I would do it- IT REALLY IS THAT BAD.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jeannette M.

Great service . Great Pizza, Opened Late. The ambience was nice and chill. You can write on the walls too.

Alexis S.

When a pizza place puts crunchy bitter bay leafs on a margarita pizza!! Instead of basil ,You for sure know dis place ain't it smh . There are even better pizza places across the street lyk.

ThePapaDook PoetEmcee

Absolutely terrible service. Its very clear that yall underpay yall staff because they do not care at all about your food, what you ask for, or have a good attitude about it.We al have had jobs that we don't like and none of your people like working for yall. Check it fr. I buy late night food from all over and folx be happy to service you with food. This aint it. In real life.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Load More