The atmosphere was dimly lit, a real nice quiet place to take a Date. Very pricey but worth the time. Validated parking. The food was very good, service was excellent. The Bathroom was very clean. The waiter was very professional. Had a wonderful time !
Kaylah -
I have a sneaking feeling they purposefully over book their reservations with the hopes that another reservation might be a no-show. I shouldn't be waiting half an hour to be sat if I have a RESERVATION. Also, never seen so many incompetent people working in management in my life. Hosts didn't really seem to know what they were doing or at least weren't trained in problem solving, and management didn't seem to be any help either. Server was sweet but seemed distracted - our table was not his priority. This is a poorly run restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Fred Kalombo
I had the pleasure of interacting with Zobi, the manager, during my visit to this restaurant. Zobi, if I may have misspelled your name, please accept my apologies. Let me start by saying that you are undoubtedly one of the finest professionals I've encountered in the hospitality industry. While the quality of food and experience can vary from person to person, Zobi’s exceptional kindness and outstanding service are undeniable which made my dining experience truly memorable.Regardless of personal preferences or tastes, kindness is a universal language that Zibo exemplified effortlessly.I urge patrons at times to look paste the minor mistake caused by the tremendous challenges restaurants face to serve us good food, and focus on their intents as I believe most of them would correct any mistake they acknowledge.Therefore, take the time to drop a honest review accounting for more than just food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amith Ganesan
Very expensive but excellent service. No menu for whiskies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
rush jolly
Best steakhouse in Atlanta. I’ve been to all of them. Also worth noting. $125 tomahawk is the best price in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Familyof5
Steaks cooked exactly as they should be, charred on the outside and rare on the inside, absolutely delicious! The bone-in ribeye was the best I've ever eaten and the filet of ribeye was excellent as well. Big portions for sides as well. We were tucked inside the side room where the ambience was perfect and could hold a conversation. Service was excellent. Extensive wine list.
I'm a ribeye connoisseur. I've had all of them in Atlanta. This is by far the best and most consistent. Also our server Ryanne (spelling?) was incredible and I want to marry her.
DedicatedCarnivore
What a great classic NY steakhouse! Had a birthday celebration there last night and couldn't be happier with the choice. Spectacular service coupled with delicious steak, seafood, wines and an an over-the-top giant chocolate cake added up to a memorable experience for all of us. Will be back to NYP again and again!
Andrew F.
This was my first time at NY Prime Minister the staff was friendly. Cracking jokes and making everyone feel comfortable. I am usually hesitant to take suggestions when it comes to the menu, but the waiter hit it out of the park with the stone crabs to start and the tomahawk to share.
LeCanta D.
Party of 8 visited last weekend. This was my second time coming to New York Prime and the food was good but not as good as my previous visit. The service was top tier even with the large crowd.
Been to New York Prime several times and this time will probably be my last unfortunately.Service was slow, the bartender (Caucasian) didn’t get her name, made a smart comment after I requested more simple syrup for my drink that I specifically asked to be made on the sweeter side...it was almost as if I wasn't paying $17 for my drink! The manager Jacob who is Caucasian was very almost dismissive of my feelings of being offended saying the bartender didn't mean what she said in an offensive way. The broccolini which is usually one of my favorite sides came out tasting subpar almost had a burnt taste, the manager took that off my bill, but after my experience with the bartender I would have appreciated him taking the drink off over the broccolini honestly.....even the walnut apple pie which is usually one of my favorite desserts did not taste the same as it did the several times myself and my husband have been there. This might have been an off night for them, but after the way my feeling were dismissed about that bartender let’s just say I won't be returning, it’s way too expensive to have subpar service, food and drinks!
Re Re
We went for Valentine’s Day. It was great, wait was not that long. Romantic ambiance, food was bursting with flavor and they gave out chocolate covered strawberries. I thought that was nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Redfish Amandine
Brandi Kennedy
My husband and I had our 6th anniversary dinner here. What a wonderful experience. Hands down this is one of the best meals I’ve ever had. The bone in fillet was delicious. We also enjoyed the baked potato that melts in your mouth along with mushrooms, Brussel sprouts, oysters and lump crab. Our server was the best and the atmosphere was very romantic and elegant! Definitely a 5 star experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
Michael Smallwood
My wife and I dined here with our kids for her birthday. The place was very nice and the atmosphere was nice and cozy. The waiters were very friendly and knowledgeable of the menu. And the food was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Destiny H.
My visit started off rocky. I was seated and wasn't greeted for a while. Harr noticed me and immediately took care of me. Jason as well who is the operations manager. I did not expect it, but they took care of my drink, as well as my appetizers and gave me a dessert. This place is phenomenal and the people will go above and beyond to rectify it situation. the food was amazing. Try the crab cake if you go! 10/10
The atmosphere was dimly lit, a real nice quiet place to take a Date. Very pricey but worth the time. Validated parking. The food was very good, service was excellent. The Bathroom was very clean. The waiter was very professional. Had a wonderful time !
I have a sneaking feeling they purposefully over book their reservations with the hopes that another reservation might be a no-show. I shouldn't be waiting half an hour to be sat if I have a RESERVATION. Also, never seen so many incompetent people working in management in my life. Hosts didn't really seem to know what they were doing or at least weren't trained in problem solving, and management didn't seem to be any help either. Server was sweet but seemed distracted - our table was not his priority. This is a poorly run restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
I had the pleasure of interacting with Zobi, the manager, during my visit to this restaurant. Zobi, if I may have misspelled your name, please accept my apologies. Let me start by saying that you are undoubtedly one of the finest professionals I've encountered in the hospitality industry. While the quality of food and experience can vary from person to person, Zobi’s exceptional kindness and outstanding service are undeniable which made my dining experience truly memorable.Regardless of personal preferences or tastes, kindness is a universal language that Zibo exemplified effortlessly.I urge patrons at times to look paste the minor mistake caused by the tremendous challenges restaurants face to serve us good food, and focus on their intents as I believe most of them would correct any mistake they acknowledge.Therefore, take the time to drop a honest review accounting for more than just food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very expensive but excellent service. No menu for whiskies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best steakhouse in Atlanta. I’ve been to all of them. Also worth noting. $125 tomahawk is the best price in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steaks cooked exactly as they should be, charred on the outside and rare on the inside, absolutely delicious! The bone-in ribeye was the best I've ever eaten and the filet of ribeye was excellent as well. Big portions for sides as well. We were tucked inside the side room where the ambience was perfect and could hold a conversation. Service was excellent. Extensive wine list.
I'm a ribeye connoisseur. I've had all of them in Atlanta. This is by far the best and most consistent. Also our server Ryanne (spelling?) was incredible and I want to marry her.
What a great classic NY steakhouse! Had a birthday celebration there last night and couldn't be happier with the choice. Spectacular service coupled with delicious steak, seafood, wines and an an over-the-top giant chocolate cake added up to a memorable experience for all of us. Will be back to NYP again and again!
This was my first time at NY Prime Minister the staff was friendly. Cracking jokes and making everyone feel comfortable. I am usually hesitant to take suggestions when it comes to the menu, but the waiter hit it out of the park with the stone crabs to start and the tomahawk to share.
Party of 8 visited last weekend. This was my second time coming to New York Prime and the food was good but not as good as my previous visit. The service was top tier even with the large crowd.
Restaurantji Recommends
Been to New York Prime several times and this time will probably be my last unfortunately.Service was slow, the bartender (Caucasian) didn’t get her name, made a smart comment after I requested more simple syrup for my drink that I specifically asked to be made on the sweeter side...it was almost as if I wasn't paying $17 for my drink! The manager Jacob who is Caucasian was very almost dismissive of my feelings of being offended saying the bartender didn't mean what she said in an offensive way. The broccolini which is usually one of my favorite sides came out tasting subpar almost had a burnt taste, the manager took that off my bill, but after my experience with the bartender I would have appreciated him taking the drink off over the broccolini honestly.....even the walnut apple pie which is usually one of my favorite desserts did not taste the same as it did the several times myself and my husband have been there. This might have been an off night for them, but after the way my feeling were dismissed about that bartender let’s just say I won't be returning, it’s way too expensive to have subpar service, food and drinks!
We went for Valentine’s Day. It was great, wait was not that long. Romantic ambiance, food was bursting with flavor and they gave out chocolate covered strawberries. I thought that was nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Redfish Amandine
My husband and I had our 6th anniversary dinner here. What a wonderful experience. Hands down this is one of the best meals I’ve ever had. The bone in fillet was delicious. We also enjoyed the baked potato that melts in your mouth along with mushrooms, Brussel sprouts, oysters and lump crab. Our server was the best and the atmosphere was very romantic and elegant! Definitely a 5 star experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
My wife and I dined here with our kids for her birthday. The place was very nice and the atmosphere was nice and cozy. The waiters were very friendly and knowledgeable of the menu. And the food was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My visit started off rocky. I was seated and wasn't greeted for a while. Harr noticed me and immediately took care of me. Jason as well who is the operations manager. I did not expect it, but they took care of my drink, as well as my appetizers and gave me a dessert. This place is phenomenal and the people will go above and beyond to rectify it situation. the food was amazing. Try the crab cake if you go! 10/10