Cicis Pizza

1931 Auburn Ave Suite 100, Columbus
(706) 569-9096

Recent Reviews

Dennis J.

Return to previous comments . Don't try to use coupons here. They won't work. I had previously called the company that printed these coupons the valley saver and he told me. Oh yes, Mr.? The new owner I know him and he is the one who told me to do the coupons. The only confusion with these coupons is the new owner does not communicate with his managers what he has done. I think his name was Steve at the valley saver coupons he spoke with the owner that had placed the ads and gave him my number and Steve told me the owner was going to call me, and he never did. The only reason I am Foolin with this as I told my grandson it's the principle of the matter. There has been several times that I would loved to have went to cc pizza as I have done in the past, but I said I will not return here anymore because the owner seems not to have enough concern to prioritize his business. My only regret, is I did not post these comments on all other sites. On the Internet. If the owner had of reached out I would not be reposting this. You had my number shame on you for not caring.

Madeline S.

the place is nasty the employees are extremely rude the owner especially they pay you 8 dollars an hour to act like a manger the mangers keep calling out and there's never a manager on shift i doubt it's up to the standard health codes

Shuntia Williams

Even though this is a buffet, the pizza is mediocre at best. Plain water was in the tea containers. The staff didn’t seem eager to work so customer service lacked. The dough was flavorless.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Paulette M.

They were suppose to open at 11:00 We got there at 11:30. The 1st clue that we should have left, was the signs stating NO REFUNDS. The staff was not anywhere near being ready to serve anyone. The restaurant was filthy. Food spatters on the tables, pizza counters and trash everywhere. The salad bar looked like it had not been removed the previous night. No serving utensils and only 3 things on the bar. The workers were not friendly at all and did not apologize for the filth. The pizza dough was not anywhere near being done. Very soggy and not appealing at the very least. Trash all around and on the beverage bar. There was also a very bad odor coming from the bathroom.I saved my receipt so I could provide the information. Johanna F was the cashier. She was also making pizzas and taking orders our to cars in the parking lot. C18039001 was the code by her name. My granddaughter and I were shocked to say the least. We usually eat at the one on Whittsley. But we were close to this one and thought we would try it. SO SORRY THAT WE DID. WHAT A WASTE OF TIME MONEY. This store needs to be closed until it is ready for a full state and city inspection. Small Kids should not be allowed to help themselves to the buffet alone either.

Jamie Gregory

Not a good experience from entering to eating my pizza at home. I will not be back

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Meagan Whitaker

Everything was just fine fresh pizza fresh dessert until the Mexican lady walked up to us trying to take our cups and tell us it was supposed to be water when we added our own flavor to our water automatically assuming we didn’t get water when that’s what we asked from my mom and her friend are 80 years old and she took there cups from them demanding they get water without asking us if we had gotten water so my mom pulled her flavor out and showed her and she didn’t apologize or anything she just walked away. We know there are rules but that is above and beyond pass respectful the disrespect is unreal.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Garlic Cheesy Bread, Cheese Pizza, Cinnamon Rolls, Salad Bar

Lashanta Valentine

I went in and was told they don’t have Amy cinnamon rolls to sale. I ask could they cook fresh I’ll wait. Advised we don’t have to go boxes. Drove to whittlesey hopefully they have

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ebony Beamon

This is my favorite place to eat on a budget. They make whatever pizza you like and the cinnamon rolls are my favorite.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Garlic Cheesy Bread, Mac Cheese Pizza, Spinach Alfredo Flatbread, Cheese Pizza, Cinnamon Rolls, Brownies, Zesty Ham & Cheddar Pizza, Pepperoni Poppers, Salads, Pepperoni Pizza, Salad Bar, Classic Chicken Pizza

Tee Maddox

My visit at this location was terrible they had no pizza on the bar and when they did make some it was the same kind of pizza over and over and what make it so bad it wasn’t even that packed inside and they just couldn’t keep up and I like to order my own kind of pizza but I couldn’t this night cause it took forever to just get pizza on the bar. People were waiting on the cinnamon rolls and waiting on the breadsticks hell they were waiting on everything .. they need to get a better management or something in that store.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dave Williams

Food was good. Men's restroom was filthy.

Amelia Armstead (Brooke)

Only came to give cicis another shot because of my kids. Left yet again irritated. The only good things I can say it the 2 girls working in the back (one had 2 poof/buns and the other had long braids in a bunch on her head) were working their butts offend very nice despite the circumstances. They were doing their best to keep thing coming but it was very clear that management is slacking. The gentleman who cleans the tables was very polite and on top of things. The manager appears to be very frazzled and scatter brained. Upon arrival they were having card machines issues and didn't have lids for cups. Then, they were out of salad but eventually someone brought some bags of Publix brand salad out. Salad bar was minimally stocked. Im guessing there was and ordering/truck issue. There wasn't much on the bar and it was dinner rush so as soon as the girls got a pizza out it was swarmed and gone. Overheard the manager telling one girl to add water to the marinara and alfredo... gross. I ordered a 5pc wing and was told it would take 30 mins...why?? Cashier told my daughter they could only give her $1 in quarters even though they have an arcade. Most of the aracade machines were broken or messed up anyways so she dodged that bullet. Bathrooms were repulsive. Dinner took over 2 hours between waiting for food and all. Definitely won't be back unless some changes are made.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

J Schmeling

Horrible food (possibly because there was none), ordered a pizza, got it wrong, dirty, one girl (tall and light skinned) working really hard and one not helping much and could barely tell if she worked there since she had no bit of any kind of uniform on and wasn’t doing much. Then pops in out of nowhere supermeth the supreme dishwashing machine meth headed looking lady in to save the day i guess.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Cathy Devorce

Pizza was ok. They had just opened so they didn't have all the food prepared.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Leann LaFleur

Nasty. The lady at the register didn't say one word to us. They had no food when we got there so we waited but didnt sit where we could see into the kitchen area. The lady making the food kept pulling her pants up with the gloves on then touching the food. After we seen that we stopped eating and left.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lonnie Jackson

Seems to be under new management, I've seen a lot of improvements over the last few months. Instead of being full of teenagers who don't want to work, they have a very helpful and attentive staff. The pizza is great again.Kid-friendliness: There's a small video game arcade in the back of the restaurant.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Cinnamon Rolls, Pepperoni Pizza, Salad Bar, Create Your Own Pizza

Load More