I was completely delighted by my experience with Evelyn's Ultimate Pecan Pies and More! I ordered two sets of pies and needed them rushed because my friends and I were running the Tough Mudder the weekend of the 24 of April. It was a last minute order and we were able to coordinate a delivery for the morning when the bakers had finished their fresh pies. They had started at 11:00 the night before and brought our pies to us because the destination was very close to the bakery and given that we had to leave for a race at 6:30 in the morning, the went above and beyond to help support my friends and I for the Tough Mudder Classic. It's 10 miles. The pies were racing fuel and they were a huge hit with me and my Mudder Friends. People were absolutely tickled to receive a delicious pecan or chocolate pecan pie FRESH at the race course... instead of mud pies! (Incidentally we might have gotten mud on some fo the pies... but this was one of the top 5 muddiest Tough Mudders according to other racers... mud pie joke.) These pies really brought surprise and smiles from everyone who received one.THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK to Evelyn and her bakers to help make the first Tough Mudder of the 2021 season such a blast.
Bronx R.
I ordered the sweet potato pecan pie from Evelyn last Thanksgiving. There was a slight mix-up on the delivery date, but Evelyn made it right by overnighting me my order and included and additional pie at no charge. Now that's what I call customer service. The pie was great and enjoyed by my family. I wanted to order it again, but was interested in a less sweet version. I reached out to Evelyn and asked her if she could do a customer order. She worked with me to see what I was looking for in a level of sweetness and came up with a revised pie that was even better than the previous one I ordered. This time my family and I enjoyed it over Christmas. It was delicious. Thanks for your willingness to work with me Evelyn! I will definitely order again.
Erin H.
Terrible they deserve 0 stars. Ordered pies on July 29th and it was supposed to be delivered today 08/12. Their website states pies will be shipped within 2-3 days and you will be sent an email. I never got an email. I called 3 times today, left 3 messages and wrote two emails and yep you guessed it NOTHING. so I'm disputing the charge with my bank and I would suggest never ordering a pie from Evelyn's because number 1 you wont get your pie and then number 2 you wont get your money back because there is no one to talk to or to call you back. Period dont do it.
I was completely delighted by my experience with Evelyn's Ultimate Pecan Pies and More! I ordered two sets of pies and needed them rushed because my friends and I were running the Tough Mudder the weekend of the 24 of April. It was a last minute order and we were able to coordinate a delivery for the morning when the bakers had finished their fresh pies. They had started at 11:00 the night before and brought our pies to us because the destination was very close to the bakery and given that we had to leave for a race at 6:30 in the morning, the went above and beyond to help support my friends and I for the Tough Mudder Classic. It's 10 miles. The pies were racing fuel and they were a huge hit with me and my Mudder Friends. People were absolutely tickled to receive a delicious pecan or chocolate pecan pie FRESH at the race course... instead of mud pies! (Incidentally we might have gotten mud on some fo the pies... but this was one of the top 5 muddiest Tough Mudders according to other racers... mud pie joke.) These pies really brought surprise and smiles from everyone who received one.THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK to Evelyn and her bakers to help make the first Tough Mudder of the 2021 season such a blast.
I ordered the sweet potato pecan pie from Evelyn last Thanksgiving. There was a slight mix-up on the delivery date, but Evelyn made it right by overnighting me my order and included and additional pie at no charge. Now that's what I call customer service. The pie was great and enjoyed by my family. I wanted to order it again, but was interested in a less sweet version. I reached out to Evelyn and asked her if she could do a customer order. She worked with me to see what I was looking for in a level of sweetness and came up with a revised pie that was even better than the previous one I ordered. This time my family and I enjoyed it over Christmas. It was delicious. Thanks for your willingness to work with me Evelyn! I will definitely order again.
Terrible they deserve 0 stars. Ordered pies on July 29th and it was supposed to be delivered today 08/12. Their website states pies will be shipped within 2-3 days and you will be sent an email. I never got an email. I called 3 times today, left 3 messages and wrote two emails and yep you guessed it NOTHING. so I'm disputing the charge with my bank and I would suggest never ordering a pie from Evelyn's because number 1 you wont get your pie and then number 2 you wont get your money back because there is no one to talk to or to call you back. Period dont do it.
Alright
Restaurantji Recommends