Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!! My husband went here on a work trip about 3 years ago and since then has been wanting to take me here, we’re from Texas. It was definitely worth the wait!! Will be returning soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dick G.
Great food, especially the Omnivore pizza! Very friendly staff, very relaxed atmosphere. Dine inside or outside.
Terre Alexander
I was looking for some Neapolitan style pizza in the area and found this place on a Saturday evening and order it to go around 7:00 p.m. it was mostly empty with a few patients in the back or family with children I ordered cheese pizza and I will give this a 8.5 on the Dave Portnoy scale.Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza and saladKid-friendliness: There's a lot of memorabilia and kids sittingWheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp in the back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Neapolitan Pizza
WMB
Really good food and a great place overall. I got a meatball sub and a calzone and both were excellent.Only critique is on the pasta salad. Its very basic (just balsamic, red onions, olives and feta from what I got) which is fine but it was really bland, definitely needs more salt in the pasta and the dressing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone
Dr. Jenevieve Goss
My family and I found this place five years ago when we moved to Roswell. It is our go to Friday night pizza spot. The pizza is delicious. Flavorful crispy and super consistent. You always know you’ll get a delicious pizza when you come here. Mike is the hardest working guy and he’s always in the kitchen or waiting tables making everything runs smoothly! We always order to 14 inch pizzas well done and they are perfect every time! My kids crave this place! Don’t wait, just go!!
They have a nice patio outside, but the service was slow - they seem a bit understaffed. The pizza was pretty good though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Keegan Donegan
I’m giving only 3 stars because a big portion of my large $40 pizza was black and extra crispy(burnt). The small part that wasn’t burned tasted good though. It’s a nice little place and the folks that work here are friendly. I’m sure the food is usually fine, but my experience really turned me off. Don’t not come here due to this review; it’s a popular place so I guess I was just unlucky and threw $40 out the window.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Kelly Rullan
The best NYC pizza we've had in a long time! Once you pick up and fold and get all the wonderful cheese, sauce and pepperoni, it's like heaven in one bite. Thank you Mike for providing such a great experience with a pie! Will definitely be back real soon for more!
Danylle LeBlanc
This is a cute little pizza place. Great for families or just to grab a drink with a friend. Very cozy and the pizza was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
TAK T
What a huge surprise… just some of the most unique pizza! Highly rec the goat cheese and prosciutto pizza! Was wondering why all his pizza pans are bent?? great selection of local ice cold brews & lots of outdoor seating… but they also have indoor air conditioned bar area… convenient & free parking in backyard.
Can never catch them when they are open have driven twice across town and they are not open as stated on website. pizza is amazing ?
Rob Huey
Excellent pizza in a cool venue. We had dinner here the other night but it’s the second I’ve had their pizza. I’m not a huge fan of thin crust pizza but this is really good - nice mix of crispy crust and just enough toppings.I’d recommend to-go versus dining in until the labor shortage is figured out. There was only one person for the whole restaurant and even though she was super efficient it was too much for one person.
Mrs. Monestime
My kids & I love this place. We visit after school to get pizza slices for just 3 bucks. The pizza is great one of the best tasting here and reminds me of visiting NY. The staff is friendly, kind and enduring (these kids can be a handful). Great place, great food, great service. I highly recommend them.
Kellie Dolan
This place is homey, welcoming, delicious and nothing less than wonderful. First of all, the owner, Mike, remembered me after my first brief visit, which in my opinion, says a lot about someone, especially a restaurant owner who sees many different faces frequently! He's very personable, laid back, friendly, and just an all around good human! 2nd, being a NJ born gal, I do get picky with my Italian food, specifically my pizza. Let's just say, their pies pass the test with flying colors! Fresh ingredients and clearly homemade recipes, you really can't go wrong. Also, make sure to try their meatballs! Bonus = you can have Carlisles delivered on UberEats! ?? (And maybe other food delivery apps but I'm not 100% sure about that).
K. T.
What a huge surprise… just some of the most unique pizza! Highly rec the goat cheese and prosciutto pizza! Was wondering why all his pizza pans are bent?? great selection of local ice cold brews & lots of outdoor seating… but they also have indoor air conditioned bar area… convenient & free parking in backyard.
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!! My husband went here on a work trip about 3 years ago and since then has been wanting to take me here, we’re from Texas. It was definitely worth the wait!! Will be returning soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, especially the Omnivore pizza! Very friendly staff, very relaxed atmosphere. Dine inside or outside.
I was looking for some Neapolitan style pizza in the area and found this place on a Saturday evening and order it to go around 7:00 p.m. it was mostly empty with a few patients in the back or family with children I ordered cheese pizza and I will give this a 8.5 on the Dave Portnoy scale.Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza and saladKid-friendliness: There's a lot of memorabilia and kids sittingWheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp in the back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Neapolitan Pizza
Really good food and a great place overall. I got a meatball sub and a calzone and both were excellent.Only critique is on the pasta salad. Its very basic (just balsamic, red onions, olives and feta from what I got) which is fine but it was really bland, definitely needs more salt in the pasta and the dressing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone
My family and I found this place five years ago when we moved to Roswell. It is our go to Friday night pizza spot. The pizza is delicious. Flavorful crispy and super consistent. You always know you’ll get a delicious pizza when you come here. Mike is the hardest working guy and he’s always in the kitchen or waiting tables making everything runs smoothly! We always order to 14 inch pizzas well done and they are perfect every time! My kids crave this place! Don’t wait, just go!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone, Pepperoni Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Caprese Salad
They have a nice patio outside, but the service was slow - they seem a bit understaffed. The pizza was pretty good though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I’m giving only 3 stars because a big portion of my large $40 pizza was black and extra crispy(burnt). The small part that wasn’t burned tasted good though. It’s a nice little place and the folks that work here are friendly. I’m sure the food is usually fine, but my experience really turned me off. Don’t not come here due to this review; it’s a popular place so I guess I was just unlucky and threw $40 out the window.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
The best NYC pizza we've had in a long time! Once you pick up and fold and get all the wonderful cheese, sauce and pepperoni, it's like heaven in one bite. Thank you Mike for providing such a great experience with a pie! Will definitely be back real soon for more!
This is a cute little pizza place. Great for families or just to grab a drink with a friend. Very cozy and the pizza was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a huge surprise… just some of the most unique pizza! Highly rec the goat cheese and prosciutto pizza! Was wondering why all his pizza pans are bent?? great selection of local ice cold brews & lots of outdoor seating… but they also have indoor air conditioned bar area… convenient & free parking in backyard.
Restaurantji Recommends
Can never catch them when they are open have driven twice across town and they are not open as stated on website. pizza is amazing ?
Excellent pizza in a cool venue. We had dinner here the other night but it’s the second I’ve had their pizza. I’m not a huge fan of thin crust pizza but this is really good - nice mix of crispy crust and just enough toppings.I’d recommend to-go versus dining in until the labor shortage is figured out. There was only one person for the whole restaurant and even though she was super efficient it was too much for one person.
My kids & I love this place. We visit after school to get pizza slices for just 3 bucks. The pizza is great one of the best tasting here and reminds me of visiting NY. The staff is friendly, kind and enduring (these kids can be a handful). Great place, great food, great service. I highly recommend them.
This place is homey, welcoming, delicious and nothing less than wonderful. First of all, the owner, Mike, remembered me after my first brief visit, which in my opinion, says a lot about someone, especially a restaurant owner who sees many different faces frequently! He's very personable, laid back, friendly, and just an all around good human! 2nd, being a NJ born gal, I do get picky with my Italian food, specifically my pizza. Let's just say, their pies pass the test with flying colors! Fresh ingredients and clearly homemade recipes, you really can't go wrong. Also, make sure to try their meatballs! Bonus = you can have Carlisles delivered on UberEats! ?? (And maybe other food delivery apps but I'm not 100% sure about that).
What a huge surprise… just some of the most unique pizza! Highly rec the goat cheese and prosciutto pizza! Was wondering why all his pizza pans are bent?? great selection of local ice cold brews & lots of outdoor seating… but they also have indoor air conditioned bar area… convenient & free parking in backyard.