I was an on going customer of Johnny's and now not only was the pizza dry and not made appropriately but when I called back to get it remaid they only offered to give me 4 slices back instead of remaking the whole pizza. I was so upset and now I can't suggest this restaurant as a referred restaurant. The pizza tasted burnt on the bottom and I will not be eating there again!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Anisia Petrov
Pizza Crust was severely undercooked. Have been sick all night from it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Raymond Riker
Great Pizza. Dough is the most important part of New York Pizza and their dough meets the mark. Garlic Knots with Cheese is an absolute.Great service. Super Friendly.Highly Recommend@Uncle_Bonez#UncleBonez
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza
Sabera Williams
Me and my family visited Jonny's yesterday with all our kids. Food was excellent! The freshness was refreshing! And pricing is just right. The server was great! We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chef Salad, Johnny's New York Style Pizza, Wings
Tracy
We had a great meal. Caesar and Mediterranean salads were fresh and delicious. Caesar salad had great parmesan and Caesar dressing. The Mediterranean had lots of great vegetables and cold cuts. Pizza was delicious with generous toppings, tasty cheese fresh mushrooms and spicy pepperoni. Mild wings were delicious. Service was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Safran
Crystal is the most professional, courteous, and respectful manager. She is the only one that is worried about the cleanliness of herself and her kitchen. I am from the north and we are critical of our pizza and she has come the closest to “back home pizza” that I’ve had since I’ve lived in GA. No one can get crust to come out like she can. If you are looking for a pizza out of this world get one from Crystal at Johnnie’s at eagles landing !!!!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza
T Carter
Man, I lucked up on this place after passing it for years. Now you cannot get me out of here. The convenience of ordering because they look up your number and it has your last order on file... convenience, great tasting pizza loaded with toppings... you will love it here too!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darlene Major
My husband and I finally agree on a great tasting pizza. Our order was called in and ready when promised. All ingredients tasted fresh and delicious. My one wish is that all toppings would extend to the edge of the crust. The sauce was there, just wish the cheese, sausage and pepperoni were there as well. Minor, can’t wait to order again and also try additional menu items. Our tummies were happy.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza
Roger Jones
It was my first time eating at this location, and I was a little hesitant due to visiting other locations. However, this was a better experience overall. The ingredients were fresh, and the dough was baked just right. I don't like pizza dough that is too hard to chew or crunchy; however, this location did not disappoint me. The pizza even tasted good the next day. I will say that the wings were a little too bready for my liking, but the overall taste was fine. Also, the lasagna was a little too cheesy and thick on top, but overall, it was okay. Another good thing is that they offer coupons on the pizza box, so don't throw your box away before detaching the coupon. As far as the atmosphere, this restaurant was a little dull. However, I kind of expected it due to the location. Either way, I'll be back just on the pizza alone.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza, Wings
Andrew Duncan
The food was up to standards, however the pizza slices they served my dining companion were extremely small. The server explained that the size of the slices depended on who was making the pizza. As someone who dines at a Johnny's Pizza on a weekly basis for many years I know the acceptable range of sizes for a slice, and this was laughably small. If it had been a fish we'd have been required to throw it back ?. I look forward to talking about this experience with the staff at my regular Johnny's, to see if they can shed some light on why this could have happened. Again, the food was fine. Just make sure to make them show you how large of a slice they plan to serve you.
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza, Mini Garlic Knots
K P
I have seen the New York name used to sell a lot of things but most of the time they are not authentic. While I definitely enjoyed the fresh ingredients on the pizza ? Johnny’s is definitely not making New York style pizza. If you look at the picture of the pizza it's so small that it doesn't fill the entire box. Not worth $25+.Born and raised Brooklyn girl who has been eating NYC pizza my whole life. The pies are too small and the slices are not large enough to fold and they are using basic all purpose flour to make the dough. Good but not New York style. Recently found a place where the pizza is closer to what an authentic NYC pizza should be. Try Fellini’s....their stingy with the toppings but it appears that they are using the right type of flour (Italian semolina 00) to make the dough and this makes all the difference in the finished pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
ChaMiya H (Maya)
8 dollars for a few nuggets is absurd. The picture online showed chicken and french
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
tamara holbrock
I'm new to the area and to the State of Georgia, and I was online looking for a great place that make an awesome pizza. I didn't want any of those everyday commercialized spots that advertise pizza. So I found Johnny's New York Pizza online. I ordered the "Johnny's Italian Special Pizza," size large, and some "Cheesy garlic bread." Let's just say, for my first time visiting this establishment, the food was delicious. The pizza had a nice crust, the vegetables were fresh, and the sauce was very tasty. You have to also try the cheesy garlic bread as well. I wish it came a little larger (The cheesy garlic bread), but I will definitely order both again, and I will go back to try again. I guess I've found my new place for authentic pizza and cheesy garlic bread.?I was very pleased with the meal, and the customer service was very nice and welcoming, which is also important.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza, Cheese Bread
Kelsey Summers
We love this place, and have for years and years. Everytime we come here to eat it's perfect. Never get anything wrong, never tastes bad. Staff is helpful. It's our go to pizza place.Vegetarian options: Have plenty of vegetarian salads and pizza options to choose from!
I was an on going customer of Johnny's and now not only was the pizza dry and not made appropriately but when I called back to get it remaid they only offered to give me 4 slices back instead of remaking the whole pizza. I was so upset and now I can't suggest this restaurant as a referred restaurant. The pizza tasted burnt on the bottom and I will not be eating there again!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Pizza Crust was severely undercooked. Have been sick all night from it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Great Pizza. Dough is the most important part of New York Pizza and their dough meets the mark. Garlic Knots with Cheese is an absolute.Great service. Super Friendly.Highly Recommend@Uncle_Bonez#UncleBonez
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza
Me and my family visited Jonny's yesterday with all our kids. Food was excellent! The freshness was refreshing! And pricing is just right. The server was great! We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chef Salad, Johnny's New York Style Pizza, Wings
We had a great meal. Caesar and Mediterranean salads were fresh and delicious. Caesar salad had great parmesan and Caesar dressing. The Mediterranean had lots of great vegetables and cold cuts. Pizza was delicious with generous toppings, tasty cheese fresh mushrooms and spicy pepperoni. Mild wings were delicious. Service was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crystal is the most professional, courteous, and respectful manager. She is the only one that is worried about the cleanliness of herself and her kitchen. I am from the north and we are critical of our pizza and she has come the closest to “back home pizza” that I’ve had since I’ve lived in GA. No one can get crust to come out like she can. If you are looking for a pizza out of this world get one from Crystal at Johnnie’s at eagles landing !!!!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza
Man, I lucked up on this place after passing it for years. Now you cannot get me out of here. The convenience of ordering because they look up your number and it has your last order on file... convenience, great tasting pizza loaded with toppings... you will love it here too!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I finally agree on a great tasting pizza. Our order was called in and ready when promised. All ingredients tasted fresh and delicious. My one wish is that all toppings would extend to the edge of the crust. The sauce was there, just wish the cheese, sausage and pepperoni were there as well. Minor, can’t wait to order again and also try additional menu items. Our tummies were happy.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza
It was my first time eating at this location, and I was a little hesitant due to visiting other locations. However, this was a better experience overall. The ingredients were fresh, and the dough was baked just right. I don't like pizza dough that is too hard to chew or crunchy; however, this location did not disappoint me. The pizza even tasted good the next day. I will say that the wings were a little too bready for my liking, but the overall taste was fine. Also, the lasagna was a little too cheesy and thick on top, but overall, it was okay. Another good thing is that they offer coupons on the pizza box, so don't throw your box away before detaching the coupon. As far as the atmosphere, this restaurant was a little dull. However, I kind of expected it due to the location. Either way, I'll be back just on the pizza alone.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza, Wings
The food was up to standards, however the pizza slices they served my dining companion were extremely small. The server explained that the size of the slices depended on who was making the pizza. As someone who dines at a Johnny's Pizza on a weekly basis for many years I know the acceptable range of sizes for a slice, and this was laughably small. If it had been a fish we'd have been required to throw it back ?. I look forward to talking about this experience with the staff at my regular Johnny's, to see if they can shed some light on why this could have happened. Again, the food was fine. Just make sure to make them show you how large of a slice they plan to serve you.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Love their calmness and garlic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza, Mini Garlic Knots
I have seen the New York name used to sell a lot of things but most of the time they are not authentic. While I definitely enjoyed the fresh ingredients on the pizza ? Johnny’s is definitely not making New York style pizza. If you look at the picture of the pizza it's so small that it doesn't fill the entire box. Not worth $25+.Born and raised Brooklyn girl who has been eating NYC pizza my whole life. The pies are too small and the slices are not large enough to fold and they are using basic all purpose flour to make the dough. Good but not New York style. Recently found a place where the pizza is closer to what an authentic NYC pizza should be. Try Fellini’s....their stingy with the toppings but it appears that they are using the right type of flour (Italian semolina 00) to make the dough and this makes all the difference in the finished pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
8 dollars for a few nuggets is absurd. The picture online showed chicken and french
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
I'm new to the area and to the State of Georgia, and I was online looking for a great place that make an awesome pizza. I didn't want any of those everyday commercialized spots that advertise pizza. So I found Johnny's New York Pizza online. I ordered the "Johnny's Italian Special Pizza," size large, and some "Cheesy garlic bread." Let's just say, for my first time visiting this establishment, the food was delicious. The pizza had a nice crust, the vegetables were fresh, and the sauce was very tasty. You have to also try the cheesy garlic bread as well. I wish it came a little larger (The cheesy garlic bread), but I will definitely order both again, and I will go back to try again. I guess I've found my new place for authentic pizza and cheesy garlic bread.?I was very pleased with the meal, and the customer service was very nice and welcoming, which is also important.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza, Cheese Bread
We love this place, and have for years and years. Everytime we come here to eat it's perfect. Never get anything wrong, never tastes bad. Staff is helpful. It's our go to pizza place.Vegetarian options: Have plenty of vegetarian salads and pizza options to choose from!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza