Pizza was very plain. No cheese. Cheap ingredients and definitely no flavor. If you're into eating crust with a touch of melted mozzarella cheese then the pizza is for you. The fettuccini is decent and spaghetti is decent. Overall this is a good place to grab and snack until you find good food.
Xavier F.
Order take out so didn't get a chance to see the service but I will say their pizzas are good. Got the margarita, burrata, and casertana and they were delicious I recommend this place big time
Chase M.
By far the best pizza on the island! The pizza was glossed with a nice mozzarella glaise but wasn't too overwhelming for the palate. A perfect balancing act if I do say myself. I have ventured into many establishments through years that have claimed to "perfect the pizza". However, Pizza Pie is truly unrivaled in their culinary skills. Compliments to chef! I was also amazed by the hospitality on display. The staff was phenomenonal! My server, Blake, went above and beyond. He was constantly checking in and made sure I felt welcomed. Pizza Pie is second to none!
Jhonny R.
You couldn't ask for a better pizza. Went during peak hours, so the weight was short and the pizza was extra fresh highly recommend.
Marco Schmat
I have waited 30 minutes to get a table. After 10 minutes the waiter came for order. After another 30 minutes waiting for food, I went to another restaurant, because I still didn’t receive my order. I never had such a bad experience in a restaurant like that!Wish I could give 0 stars… It was terrible…
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Victor Matlashevky
Pizza was great, but it was cold and you could tell it was just sitting for a while before they gave me it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
James Best
They are definitely short of staff. Our waiter was very nice but he couldn’t keep up. We ordered one glass of wine when we arrived at 5:00 o’clock. It came promptly but shortly after that a lot of people started to arrive. Our dinner order arrived about 25 minutes after we ordered it. I was half thru my pizza and we didn’t see the waiter again to order more wine. Other customers around us were upset also. The food was ok but not the best ever as other reviews stated.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Meleny Fors
This place is a hidden gem! We got the mozzarella sticks and the bulgogi pizza and finished both in record time. The mozzarella sticks have a different batter that I would say is closer to a beer batter and was so different and good. However, the beef bulgogi pizza here was the star! The amount of toppings, a nice crispy crust, and the most delicious sauce on top. We will be coming back here!*took off one star as one of our water cups did not taste right…almost like there was still soap in it?
Food tasted great. We came in at about 7 on a Wednesday night. I counted and there were 4 other tables and it took about an hour to get out food!!! All of the staff was friendly. We ordered 4 pizzas and our waiter told us the pizzas would come out a little staggered and I was the second to get my pizza. I finished my entire pizza before the third pizza came out. Just the wait time was terrible.
Theresa V.
Server Blake was awesome. Very attentive. The food shocked me. I had the Alfredo with chicken and it was delicious. Hubby had the bolognese. We were both very pleased. Great portion size. Sat outside overlooking traffic on Kalia road. Fun people watching.
Dexter is amazing so friendly and engaging to his customers highly suggest having drinks at the bar he’s the bartender or even dining in with the family GREAT SERVICE makes anyplace a great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eddie Tajima
I love Pizza Pie! I was so excited when they opened because it's a two minute walk from home but, more importantly, their pizzas are great, the service is friendly, and both indoor/outdoor seating is nice.Both times I've dined in, there seemed to be just one person working the front - meaning they were working the bar, seating guests, taking orders, serving the food, etc. - but they were friendly and efficient.I've tried five different kinds of pizza and they've all been solid - but I keep going back to the Margherita because it's simple and delicious. I'm sure there are bound to be NYers who'll correct me and say, "That ain't no pizza!" but speaking as an average American pizza consumer, the pizzas are good!The one thing I'll say is one pizza probably won't cut it if you've got a healthy appetite. Because all their pies are thin, I can easily eat two/force down a third. Pizza Pie is definitely worth a visit - it's in my rotation when family/friends are in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob P.
Great burgers and Parmesan fries new to menu. Awesome friendly service. Super clean and modern at affordable prices.
Diane M.
Nice place and the peeps are nice but they are not yet consistent. Been twice now and each time the experience was different when we ordered the same. It's pizza and it's good when the crust is done proper. The cocktail thing is a crisis! Menu says $14.99 for a vodka soda. Just Wow! This is a well vodka (Sky) but their high end Tito's is $12.99 and Pau $10.99 so basically I'm being charged for the mixers and then they are not all that! It's soda water and a lemon! When I asked about the prices and why the up charge for the mixers I was told "it's what's in the system" but they're working on it! Like they can't manually enter anything! Hubby says we won't go back till it improves. We can go to two other pizza places in the hood and all cocktails are under $10. Just sayin!
Ryan Jeffords
This Pizza is in my Top 5 all time. It was absolutely delicious.
Pizza was very plain. No cheese. Cheap ingredients and definitely no flavor. If you're into eating crust with a touch of melted mozzarella cheese then the pizza is for you. The fettuccini is decent and spaghetti is decent. Overall this is a good place to grab and snack until you find good food.
Order take out so didn't get a chance to see the service but I will say their pizzas are good. Got the margarita, burrata, and casertana and they were delicious I recommend this place big time
By far the best pizza on the island! The pizza was glossed with a nice mozzarella glaise but wasn't too overwhelming for the palate. A perfect balancing act if I do say myself. I have ventured into many establishments through years that have claimed to "perfect the pizza". However, Pizza Pie is truly unrivaled in their culinary skills. Compliments to chef! I was also amazed by the hospitality on display. The staff was phenomenonal! My server, Blake, went above and beyond. He was constantly checking in and made sure I felt welcomed. Pizza Pie is second to none!
You couldn't ask for a better pizza. Went during peak hours, so the weight was short and the pizza was extra fresh highly recommend.
I have waited 30 minutes to get a table. After 10 minutes the waiter came for order. After another 30 minutes waiting for food, I went to another restaurant, because I still didn’t receive my order. I never had such a bad experience in a restaurant like that!Wish I could give 0 stars… It was terrible…
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Pizza was great, but it was cold and you could tell it was just sitting for a while before they gave me it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
They are definitely short of staff. Our waiter was very nice but he couldn’t keep up. We ordered one glass of wine when we arrived at 5:00 o’clock. It came promptly but shortly after that a lot of people started to arrive. Our dinner order arrived about 25 minutes after we ordered it. I was half thru my pizza and we didn’t see the waiter again to order more wine. Other customers around us were upset also. The food was ok but not the best ever as other reviews stated.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
This place is a hidden gem! We got the mozzarella sticks and the bulgogi pizza and finished both in record time. The mozzarella sticks have a different batter that I would say is closer to a beer batter and was so different and good. However, the beef bulgogi pizza here was the star! The amount of toppings, a nice crispy crust, and the most delicious sauce on top. We will be coming back here!*took off one star as one of our water cups did not taste right…almost like there was still soap in it?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesy Mozzarella Sticks, Beef Bulgogi
Food tasted great. We came in at about 7 on a Wednesday night. I counted and there were 4 other tables and it took about an hour to get out food!!! All of the staff was friendly. We ordered 4 pizzas and our waiter told us the pizzas would come out a little staggered and I was the second to get my pizza. I finished my entire pizza before the third pizza came out. Just the wait time was terrible.
Server Blake was awesome. Very attentive. The food shocked me. I had the Alfredo with chicken and it was delicious. Hubby had the bolognese. We were both very pleased. Great portion size. Sat outside overlooking traffic on Kalia road. Fun people watching.
Restaurantji Recommends
Dexter is amazing so friendly and engaging to his customers highly suggest having drinks at the bar he’s the bartender or even dining in with the family GREAT SERVICE makes anyplace a great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love Pizza Pie! I was so excited when they opened because it's a two minute walk from home but, more importantly, their pizzas are great, the service is friendly, and both indoor/outdoor seating is nice.Both times I've dined in, there seemed to be just one person working the front - meaning they were working the bar, seating guests, taking orders, serving the food, etc. - but they were friendly and efficient.I've tried five different kinds of pizza and they've all been solid - but I keep going back to the Margherita because it's simple and delicious. I'm sure there are bound to be NYers who'll correct me and say, "That ain't no pizza!" but speaking as an average American pizza consumer, the pizzas are good!The one thing I'll say is one pizza probably won't cut it if you've got a healthy appetite. Because all their pies are thin, I can easily eat two/force down a third. Pizza Pie is definitely worth a visit - it's in my rotation when family/friends are in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great burgers and Parmesan fries new to menu. Awesome friendly service. Super clean and modern at affordable prices.
Nice place and the peeps are nice but they are not yet consistent. Been twice now and each time the experience was different when we ordered the same. It's pizza and it's good when the crust is done proper. The cocktail thing is a crisis! Menu says $14.99 for a vodka soda. Just Wow! This is a well vodka (Sky) but their high end Tito's is $12.99 and Pau $10.99 so basically I'm being charged for the mixers and then they are not all that! It's soda water and a lemon! When I asked about the prices and why the up charge for the mixers I was told "it's what's in the system" but they're working on it! Like they can't manually enter anything! Hubby says we won't go back till it improves. We can go to two other pizza places in the hood and all cocktails are under $10. Just sayin!
This Pizza is in my Top 5 all time. It was absolutely delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5