Very sweet woman working the front. Had available what I wanted and it was so so good! Fast and easy dinner every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pot Pies, Macadamia Nut Pie
Lauren Swanson
Visited today 5/4/24 around 4:30pm. We ordered a banana cream baby pie and were shocked when we heard the total - $33.51! There’s no prices listed but we didn’t expect it to be that much. We bought it because we like to support local and figured it must be THAT good. We got back to our condo and put it in the fridge for dessert. I don’t know if it was an off day or what but the pie wasn’t good at all! I am so disappointed that we spent so much money on it. The crust was thin and too salty. The pie itself had some bananas inside but the pudding part was pretty flavorless, worse than store bought. I have had other banana cream pies on the island and on Maui that were 5/5. Sadly, The Right Slice won’t be joining that list.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Calanit Kamala
This is a must stop for anyone driving to Waimea Canyon. Do yourself a favor and get some Lilikoi Mango pie. Everything else is amazingly good too. We took the frozen savory pies back home and they were so good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pot Pies, Macadamia Nut Pie
Helena Murray
Delicious quick stop on the way back to town! We had the island lemon and lilikoi cheesecake, both amazing
Rahul D
Lillikoi cheesecake goes hard
Food: 5
Angela Myers
The pie crust tasted old, couldn't cut it with a fork. This was not a fresh piece of pie. Four people in our group each with a different kind with the same response... low quality.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Alexis Austin
Amazing!!!Loved the blueberry pina colada and cheesecake!
Visiting from California and stopped here for a treat. I got a slice of the blueberry pina colada pie and it was sooooo yummy!! Expensive, it’s $7 for a slice of pie, but it was a delicious special treat. My family also got the cheesecake and snickerdoodle cookie dough and they loved those as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
david alexander
I bought 2 mini pies at a farmers market, the lemon and chocolate coconut macaroon. Both pies were excellent, and the crust is amazing. What ever recipe they have for that crust is amazing. Best pie crust I've ever had.
Ekhi Arzac
Amazing rotating selection of pies by the slice, both sweet and savory. I was visiting for only two weeks, but kept coming back here. Some of the best pie crust I’ve ever had!Hard to pick my favorite since they were all so great. But probably the blueberry coconut; The juicy blueberries went perfectly with the toasted coconut in the crumble topping.
Perfect place to stop on Pi Day. Apple was the only fruit pie.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Cheri Thurgood
Based going here on reviews, but this is NOT good pie. Yuck, had coconut pie and passion fruit cheesecake and both were sadly a waste of money and calories. Friend got chocolate and gag, not real ingredients, too many shortcuts. Tastes processed instead of fresh and delish.
Pat Gray
I thoroughly enjoyed my gluten free pot pie! Call ahead if you plan to dine in.
Food: 5
Olena V.
These pies are to die for! We tried a slice of blueberry/pinna collard and a mango/lilikoi one and they were both equally fantastic! I think we destroyed both in like 90 seconds or less.
Sam Goldon
Would give it 10 stars if I could! Went there with my wife to split a few things and had to come back the next day to get our own slices of the lilikoi cheesecake because it was just too good to fathom splitting again! Wish we had time in the area to try everything they make including the savory pies cause I already know they’re fantastic.
Very sweet woman working the front. Had available what I wanted and it was so so good! Fast and easy dinner every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pot Pies, Macadamia Nut Pie
Visited today 5/4/24 around 4:30pm. We ordered a banana cream baby pie and were shocked when we heard the total - $33.51! There’s no prices listed but we didn’t expect it to be that much. We bought it because we like to support local and figured it must be THAT good. We got back to our condo and put it in the fridge for dessert. I don’t know if it was an off day or what but the pie wasn’t good at all! I am so disappointed that we spent so much money on it. The crust was thin and too salty. The pie itself had some bananas inside but the pudding part was pretty flavorless, worse than store bought. I have had other banana cream pies on the island and on Maui that were 5/5. Sadly, The Right Slice won’t be joining that list.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
This is a must stop for anyone driving to Waimea Canyon. Do yourself a favor and get some Lilikoi Mango pie. Everything else is amazingly good too. We took the frozen savory pies back home and they were so good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pot Pies, Macadamia Nut Pie
Delicious quick stop on the way back to town! We had the island lemon and lilikoi cheesecake, both amazing
Lillikoi cheesecake goes hard
Food: 5
The pie crust tasted old, couldn't cut it with a fork. This was not a fresh piece of pie. Four people in our group each with a different kind with the same response... low quality.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Amazing!!!Loved the blueberry pina colada and cheesecake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blueberry Pina Colada Pie, Mango Pie & Lilikoi Cheesecake
Visiting from California and stopped here for a treat. I got a slice of the blueberry pina colada pie and it was sooooo yummy!! Expensive, it’s $7 for a slice of pie, but it was a delicious special treat. My family also got the cheesecake and snickerdoodle cookie dough and they loved those as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I bought 2 mini pies at a farmers market, the lemon and chocolate coconut macaroon. Both pies were excellent, and the crust is amazing. What ever recipe they have for that crust is amazing. Best pie crust I've ever had.
Amazing rotating selection of pies by the slice, both sweet and savory. I was visiting for only two weeks, but kept coming back here. Some of the best pie crust I’ve ever had!Hard to pick my favorite since they were all so great. But probably the blueberry coconut; The juicy blueberries went perfectly with the toasted coconut in the crumble topping.
Restaurantji Recommends
Perfect place to stop on Pi Day. Apple was the only fruit pie.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Based going here on reviews, but this is NOT good pie. Yuck, had coconut pie and passion fruit cheesecake and both were sadly a waste of money and calories. Friend got chocolate and gag, not real ingredients, too many shortcuts. Tastes processed instead of fresh and delish.
I thoroughly enjoyed my gluten free pot pie! Call ahead if you plan to dine in.
Food: 5
These pies are to die for! We tried a slice of blueberry/pinna collard and a mango/lilikoi one and they were both equally fantastic! I think we destroyed both in like 90 seconds or less.
Would give it 10 stars if I could! Went there with my wife to split a few things and had to come back the next day to get our own slices of the lilikoi cheesecake because it was just too good to fathom splitting again! Wish we had time in the area to try everything they make including the savory pies cause I already know they’re fantastic.