This place is too cool! Loved it for every reason!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Victoria D.
Such a fun night. You need a reservation to get the password for entrance. The concept is amazing. We had a blast enjoying the fun evening. The drinks are pricy but delicious and creative. I was sad that the Elvis inspired cocktail is no longer available. It sounded amazing.
Steve Belliveau
Terrible wait even with reservations. Could not get anyone to respond. Save your time, money and energy and go somewhere
Service: 1
Nikki Wesselman
Always so much fun at The Gatsby! The drinks never disappoint!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Jean Hossfeld
Konor and Piper provided exceptional customer service. We enjoyed everything about our
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
olivia pellegrini
absolutely loved my experience. came for valentine’s day and was truly treated like family. already have my next trip planned!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert A.
It has a great warm vibe inside and is in a perfect spot in the alley off 8th Street. Really nice staff. Highly recommended.
Kate M.
My new favorite place!!! The vibes are amazing and the drinks are even better! I already have a reservation to come back and I cannot wait! 10/10 highly recommend!
Jayme M.
Great atmosphere, innovative drinks, be patient with service as the drinks take time. Food was great, drinks were on the pricy side... Not sure if we would need to come back.
Super cool Speakeasy and just the right touch of secrecy and difficulty "getting in" - reservations are required (or plan on potentially missing out - especially on a weekend night). In our case, we made reservations about a week in advance. Day of, you have to go online or call and get the "passcode" (which they'll only provide if you have reservations). Like others have said, you can only access via the alley and then once let in, you're in a small "room" with bookcases and mirrors (not going to ruin the surprise). Once inside, fabulous drinks (be patient - well worth the wait!). Ellie Shaw was performing when we were there Saturday evening, and dressed in era appropriate attire and the music was definitely era appropriate, too. Overall, absolutely great experience and a lot of fun! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!
Bridgette Ward
Super unfortunate experience, we had reservations for 3 weeks for a friends birthday party and came to realize we were 1 number off on our count and they turned us away despite paying a reservation fee. they threatened charging us 25$ per person for “no showing” even though we all were there. we had one extra person. we are 22 year old girls who take up hardly any space and called early to see if the reservation could be changed. I am extremely disappointed about this experience while i do understand the terms, i just wish they could’ve tried harder to accommodate us. will not be returning and will be trying other speakeasies. wish i could leave 0 stars
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Clarissa H.
I'm absolutely disgusted with the treatment we received tonight standing outside in the FREEZING COLD no less. We had booked a reservation for 6, about 3 weeks ago and needed to add just one more person. The birthday girl was disappointed to hear they would be charging her 25 dollars PER PERSON for us "no showing" the reservation as we were standing outside the hideous graffitied entrance. They refused to work with us, or even attempt to accommodate ONE more tiny little 20 yr old girl. It was rude and frankly just terrible customer service. I will not be returning nor would I EVER recommend this establishment to anyone. 1 star is an over statement, I wish them the worst :)
Eric Ostyn
Loved our time here! Stellar presentation on all the drinks we tried and a fantastic atmosphere. Definitely felt appreciated for coming. A worthwhile experience all-around!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nick S.
Finally got a night away to try out the Gaysby! Fun experience. The rules make me laugh sound very similar to a strip club rules . Can't wait to do another night there.
This place is too cool! Loved it for every reason!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Such a fun night. You need a reservation to get the password for entrance. The concept is amazing. We had a blast enjoying the fun evening. The drinks are pricy but delicious and creative. I was sad that the Elvis inspired cocktail is no longer available. It sounded amazing.
Terrible wait even with reservations. Could not get anyone to respond. Save your time, money and energy and go somewhere
Service: 1
Always so much fun at The Gatsby! The drinks never disappoint!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Konor and Piper provided exceptional customer service. We enjoyed everything about our
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
absolutely loved my experience. came for valentine’s day and was truly treated like family. already have my next trip planned!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It has a great warm vibe inside and is in a perfect spot in the alley off 8th Street. Really nice staff. Highly recommended.
My new favorite place!!! The vibes are amazing and the drinks are even better! I already have a reservation to come back and I cannot wait! 10/10 highly recommend!
Great atmosphere, innovative drinks, be patient with service as the drinks take time. Food was great, drinks were on the pricy side... Not sure if we would need to come back.
Overpriced, overpriced, overpriced.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Super cool Speakeasy and just the right touch of secrecy and difficulty "getting in" - reservations are required (or plan on potentially missing out - especially on a weekend night). In our case, we made reservations about a week in advance. Day of, you have to go online or call and get the "passcode" (which they'll only provide if you have reservations). Like others have said, you can only access via the alley and then once let in, you're in a small "room" with bookcases and mirrors (not going to ruin the surprise). Once inside, fabulous drinks (be patient - well worth the wait!). Ellie Shaw was performing when we were there Saturday evening, and dressed in era appropriate attire and the music was definitely era appropriate, too. Overall, absolutely great experience and a lot of fun! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!
Super unfortunate experience, we had reservations for 3 weeks for a friends birthday party and came to realize we were 1 number off on our count and they turned us away despite paying a reservation fee. they threatened charging us 25$ per person for “no showing” even though we all were there. we had one extra person. we are 22 year old girls who take up hardly any space and called early to see if the reservation could be changed. I am extremely disappointed about this experience while i do understand the terms, i just wish they could’ve tried harder to accommodate us. will not be returning and will be trying other speakeasies. wish i could leave 0 stars
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I'm absolutely disgusted with the treatment we received tonight standing outside in the FREEZING COLD no less. We had booked a reservation for 6, about 3 weeks ago and needed to add just one more person. The birthday girl was disappointed to hear they would be charging her 25 dollars PER PERSON for us "no showing" the reservation as we were standing outside the hideous graffitied entrance. They refused to work with us, or even attempt to accommodate ONE more tiny little 20 yr old girl. It was rude and frankly just terrible customer service. I will not be returning nor would I EVER recommend this establishment to anyone. 1 star is an over statement, I wish them the worst :)
Loved our time here! Stellar presentation on all the drinks we tried and a fantastic atmosphere. Definitely felt appreciated for coming. A worthwhile experience all-around!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Finally got a night away to try out the Gaysby! Fun experience. The rules make me laugh sound very similar to a strip club rules . Can't wait to do another night there.