Papa Kelsey's of Hagerman

$ • Pizza

Hours:
130 S State St, Hagerman
(208) 837-6680

Customers' Favorites

Papa Kelsey's of Hagerman Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.3 (41)
Restaurantji Rating

I’m a celiac. It is really hard for me to find pizza where I don’t get cross contamination. The pizza was delicious! It was only a $2 up charge for the gf crust (I’ve paid more). It was really great to be able to enjoy a pizza without anxiety.

Restaurantji Rating

Traveling across the country, I stopped in Hagerman, Papa Kelley's was open and had a moderate crowd so I checked it out.. the service was a little slow but with 3 people holding it down they did a great job and the food was great, with a reasonable price.

Restaurantji Rating

Nice little place, plenty of indoor seating and a small patio area out front with 4 or 5 small tables. Big menu with pizza, sandwiches, wings, and some other things, and priced reasonably for the current inflation. Took about 40 min to get 2 large and 1 mini pizza, but they were very good, would go again.

More Reviews(130)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 11AM - 8PM
Tuesday 11AM - 8PM
Wednesday 11AM - 8PM
Thursday 11AM - 8PM
Friday 11AM - 9PM
Saturday 11AM - 8PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: