Papa Johns Pizza

76 W 2nd S Ste A, Rexburg
(208) 356-7070

Recent Reviews

Terry Kayser

Bought two pizzas, a vegetarian and a Hawaiian, and they were very good! Am going to do it again in a couple weeks!

Caroline Muhlestein

Really fast delivery! Delivery driver super nice! Don’t get the boneless wings, they are soggy & disgusting. I’m so sad. I’m still hungry and $10 poorer. :(

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Peter Moore

I love you food here! The crew is nice, relaxed, and friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Supreme Pizza

Jay

Awful customer service. Rude & non communicative. Then would go over to the employee at pick me up to talk trash about the consequences of their awful service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

William S.

I arrived at 9:00 on 9/12/2023 to get a pizza. The staff told me they had been closed for a while even though Its common knowledge that they closed at 9:30. Shame

Dale Tackett

Employees are very friendly and proficient. Order was prepared properly and quickly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

MDD

Good pizza, just expensive. Nice break from horrible little squeezers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Helena Clowsley

I just want barbeque sauce....Everytime I come, I get garlic knots with a side of barbeque sauce instead of the marinara/pizza sauce. It is written on the box, and a few times I did get barbeque. But now I keep getting marinara each time I order even though the box specifically says bbq. I know it's not a big deal, but the sauce kind of completes the meal you know? So my dissappointment when I keep opening the box to marinara sauce is great. And my second order didn't even receive sauce at all. I've learned its either wrong sauce or no sauce at this point lol.

Faith Conlin

The pizza, breadsticks, and Oreo thing were AMAZING. The worker just forgot to include the cream cheese cup for the Oreo dessert. I can work with that though and will be coming back for more in the future!

Phillip Bosco

You do not deserve one star they forget change money so they can have 10 dollars or more on purpose always late delivering wrong order every time they're thiefs I get hairs in my pizza and it's cold never fresh

Spencer Richter

The pizza is literally all burnt, I'm surprised they even served it and let it out the

Food: 1

Chelsea Nerdin

The Hawaiian BBQ is amazing! We get two every time we go! They have fast service even when you order at the counter.

Kelsey Kohler

Came in and asked what their soy free options were. She simply said she didn’t know. I asked if she had an allergen menu and she said they didn’t have one. This is incredibly problematic considering that allergies can be a life threatening issue. I ended up leaving with the complete lack of awareness. Very disappointing as I love Papa Johns but my husband has a soy allergy.

Amy Zapalac

I like Papa Johns in general and this one's pizza is fine but just a heads up to anyone that cares, no contact is a lie. If you order delivery and select no contact they'll ignore it and if you don't answer the door they'll just...take your pizza back. Whether or not I'll get my money back is still pending.

Gwen Borzoni

It was really good! Although it did take 30 minutes for 1 order of garlic knots. It’s an excellent place to eat, just know you might be there for a while.

Load More