Gertie's Brick Oven Cookery

602 2nd Ave S, Twin Falls
(208) 736-9110

Recent Reviews

Angel M. Adams

Best pizza ever. The Loft in Eden was great too.

Kaden Stout

This has been a family favorite for eleven years. We keep coming back for their amazing pizzas such as the ranch chicken cashew and the English toffee. The salad bar is great and the service is amazing. The waiters are very nice and accomadating.

Alisa Kay

It's our favorite place to go out to eat as a family. The pizza is great and they have an awesome salad bar!

Brent B

The pizza was just as good as it always has been, when it was available. Apparently the owner let their alcohol license expire... Don't know if/when it will be renewed. No music over the speakers. All and all I was disappointed in how much the environment changed in the past few months. I used to love this place and taking kids there, now it doesn't have the same sprit it once did. Hopefully it was just an off night and Murphy's Law was in effect. I'll have to give it a little bit, but I'll give it another shot someday not too far away.

Claire Thomas

The Salad bar was good. The noodles and cheese were good. The pizza was ok. The dessert pizza was really good.The crew bringing around pizza were Great too.

Brian C Linge

Awsome pizza joint. If you're in twin you need to check this place out. Desert pizzas specialty pizzas salad bar beer. Arcade for the kids at a fair prise.

Anne Lorentz

I don’t understand how this restaurant hasn’t gone out of business yet, but if you’re looking for an utterly depressing dining experience this is the place to go.The exterior greets you with sad, dead plants and a handwritten note taped to the door announcing no credit cards. Inside, the atmosphere is even worse. No music playing, dirty floors, dirty tables, dirty everything, visibly miserable staff. Another handwritten sign is taped to the cash register stating “No Alcohol.” (Serving beer and wine would probably be the only thing that could possibly make this place tolerable.) Half of the kids arcade machines are broken.The salad bar was out of lettuce (you read that right), and everything else on it looked like it had been sitting out for a very, very long time. I wouldn’t risk it.The buffet area was completely out of pizza the majority of time that we were there, and the staff walking around serving pizzas were few and far between. They would get cleaned out by large parties before they got to the rest of the tables.Hope you like hot ranch dressing because that’s what was on almost every pizza they brought out. We began to suspect they had run out of traditional pizza sauce. All of this occurred before the dinner rush had even begun.I hate to write a bad review about a local business that is obviously struggling, but I couldn’t in good conscience recommend this place if it was the only restaurant in town.

Billy Barnes

The only reason it got 2 stars is because of the 1 gentleman that was doing all the running around serving. Paid $30 for my mom, my daughter, and myself. No straws, no parmesan cheese. Only one pizza coming around at a time in a 10 minute period. Saw at least 2 girls just standing around chatting instead of helping get food out. Definitely wont be back with how far this place has gone downhill.

Austin Johnson

TRASH do not eat this place is gross? we were ignored and we were there for like 1 and a half and got like 10 slices total. bathrooms looked like they came out of a horror movie??. the pizza was burnt and the waiter dropped my pizza and didn’t pick it up and ignored it like nothing happened. THIS PLACE IS SO BAD DO NOT RECOMMEND!!!!

Mel Craven

I can't imagine they'll be in business much longer. No TP, paper towels or soap in the bathrooms. How do the employees wash their hands? When brought to the attention of managers, they said they had no control over it. Mediocre food but a wide variety. Staff was not happy. Lost liquor license a month ago.

Darlene Craven Hanks

Absolutely not! pizza and salad bar were sub par, no ice, no beer. ALSO no toilet paper, soap, or paper towels in the bathroom. when something was said to the 'manager' he said I know, we're out of all of that and it's beyond my control, they should be closed until there are facilities for staff to wash their hands when they leave the bathroom.

Robert Mack

if it wasn't for the Salad bar I have left hungry, I could had Uber or door dash pizza too me faster then they was bring it out, very disappointed

Angie

Should have listened to the other reviews this place is almost the worst restaurant I’ve ever been. They force you to buy the disgusting pizza bar as that is the only eat in option. Everything was dirty and disgusting definitely not following COVID sanitation suggestions. Save your money and grief don’t go.

James Allen

The manager Charles and the Gertie's crew treated us great, even when we came in right before closing. Fun variety of pizza.

Ronald L.

This place has taken a turn for the worse! Walked in to get my to go order noticed a sign on the door that said cash only. Paid my bill with cash and they didn't have enough change to pay me back and rather than giving me the benefit of .07 cents they found it more acceptable to short me .33 cents. It's not the money but very poor business to force cash payment and not have proper change for their customers.

Load More