Horse Thief impressed me with its outstanding service and flavorful chicken salad. From warm greetings to attentive staff, every moment was enjoyable. The chicken salad was perfectly cooked and paired with fresh ingredients. A must-visit for anyone in the area! Beverly staple! Best in the neighborhood.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaye Lehman
Do yourself a favor and get Old Man Tom's Gumbo, best gumbo around. We've actually never ordered anything here we didn't like. Favorite beer is Space Face. Fun atmosphere and friendly staff, it's our go-to spot when we're in the Beverly area.
The food is great the menu is small but quality over quantity is a good thing. All servers and tender have been awesome every time. Love the vibe it covers the neighborhood well and the premade old fashion hits the spot after several homemade brews fill you up! Price is the only reason the last star is missing.
D J.
Excellent food and service...I haven't had one bad meal from this establishment. The menu is different but good!
Quite enjoyable and would recommend. Try it you might like it . I definitely have and you will too
Andrew D.
Not good. Very disappointing. Quality of food was mediocre. The place lacked ambience.
Jess Kenyon
We loved the vibes. Jack our bartender was so chill and knowledgeable. We tried all the beers on tap and love the Cheval duex, the Squeezebox, and the sour. We tried the combo bbq platter. The sides were perfection. The beans and cornbread especially good. The gumbo was rich and spicy but missing a spoonful of rice. The meats were all underseasoned. Everything needed salt. The meats should stand on their own without a sauce and these did not. Fall off the bone smokey ribs but lacking vital salt. Smokey spicy sausage, these were great, and pulled pork I would not have eaten had I not slathered it in sauce. The Carolina was our favorite but to each their own. Would definitely come back for the beer and the vibes but hope the pit master has a heavier hand in the seasoning department in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tim N.
Servers are disrespectful and the food is overcooked. Buy the canned beer to go and stop by Open Outcry for food. You won't be treated like a child.
David R.
Great place - menu was incredible. Food choices are great. Most items have a little southern kick to them . Beers - wow - soooo good. And best of all is the atmosphere there . Wide open and laid back. Great spot!
Great food and drink in a pleasant atmosphere. Good choices on the menu to keep everybody happy.
Keith O.
Good beer. Food prices have gone up while the portions have gone down. I'd say it's still a good brewery nonetheless
Brian
Out of the gate Colleen was a 5-star server start to finish. Her enthusiasm was genuine and welcoming, so informative about beers / menu. With one dinner in town, landing halfway from DC to AZ, Horse Thief Hallow was our #1 choice. A choice we did not regret.Solid beers, Began with the Soul Train (Sour). 5-stars again. Don’t let the color fool you, it is a pucker sour as intended. Annexation and Squeeze box also delicious, in that order. Restaurant SUPER clean.Pulled pork lean, not too spicy, the Mac n’ cheese is incredible, with panko crumbs under a broiler – perfectly crispy and served in cool miniature cast iron.Grass fed burger, wonderful.Half rack of baby backs, meat fell off the bone, prepared wonderfully. When returning to this area, Horse Thief Hallow Brewing will be my go-to, thank you guys & gals.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Laurain
Great tasting food, excellent service! Had the Dunkel stein of the house brewed beer & the Sicilianaire with a side salad. The other party had the pulled pork sandwich. & the cheese pierogi was amazing! (Didn't get a pic of that, it disappeared so fast)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich
Kenya G.
I enjoy supporting locally owned establishments, especially when the food is good. I had the burger that was made with beef from the local High School was flavorful, the atmosphere lively, and staff attentive.
Horse Thief impressed me with its outstanding service and flavorful chicken salad. From warm greetings to attentive staff, every moment was enjoyable. The chicken salad was perfectly cooked and paired with fresh ingredients. A must-visit for anyone in the area! Beverly staple! Best in the neighborhood.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Do yourself a favor and get Old Man Tom's Gumbo, best gumbo around. We've actually never ordered anything here we didn't like. Favorite beer is Space Face. Fun atmosphere and friendly staff, it's our go-to spot when we're in the Beverly area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Adult Grilled Cheese, Crab Rangoon, Beer Flight
The food is great the menu is small but quality over quantity is a good thing. All servers and tender have been awesome every time. Love the vibe it covers the neighborhood well and the premade old fashion hits the spot after several homemade brews fill you up! Price is the only reason the last star is missing.
Excellent food and service...I haven't had one bad meal from this establishment. The menu is different but good!
Parking: Lots
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Southwest Egg Rolls, Adult Grilled Cheese, Chicken Wings, Lieutenant Dan
Quite enjoyable and would recommend. Try it you might like it . I definitely have and you will too
Not good. Very disappointing. Quality of food was mediocre. The place lacked ambience.
We loved the vibes. Jack our bartender was so chill and knowledgeable. We tried all the beers on tap and love the Cheval duex, the Squeezebox, and the sour. We tried the combo bbq platter. The sides were perfection. The beans and cornbread especially good. The gumbo was rich and spicy but missing a spoonful of rice. The meats were all underseasoned. Everything needed salt. The meats should stand on their own without a sauce and these did not. Fall off the bone smokey ribs but lacking vital salt. Smokey spicy sausage, these were great, and pulled pork I would not have eaten had I not slathered it in sauce. The Carolina was our favorite but to each their own. Would definitely come back for the beer and the vibes but hope the pit master has a heavier hand in the seasoning department in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Servers are disrespectful and the food is overcooked. Buy the canned beer to go and stop by Open Outcry for food. You won't be treated like a child.
Great place - menu was incredible. Food choices are great. Most items have a little southern kick to them . Beers - wow - soooo good. And best of all is the atmosphere there . Wide open and laid back. Great spot!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and drink in a pleasant atmosphere. Good choices on the menu to keep everybody happy.
Good beer. Food prices have gone up while the portions have gone down. I'd say it's still a good brewery nonetheless
Out of the gate Colleen was a 5-star server start to finish. Her enthusiasm was genuine and welcoming, so informative about beers / menu. With one dinner in town, landing halfway from DC to AZ, Horse Thief Hallow was our #1 choice. A choice we did not regret.Solid beers, Began with the Soul Train (Sour). 5-stars again. Don’t let the color fool you, it is a pucker sour as intended. Annexation and Squeeze box also delicious, in that order. Restaurant SUPER clean.Pulled pork lean, not too spicy, the Mac n’ cheese is incredible, with panko crumbs under a broiler – perfectly crispy and served in cool miniature cast iron.Grass fed burger, wonderful.Half rack of baby backs, meat fell off the bone, prepared wonderfully. When returning to this area, Horse Thief Hallow Brewing will be my go-to, thank you guys & gals.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great tasting food, excellent service! Had the Dunkel stein of the house brewed beer & the Sicilianaire with a side salad. The other party had the pulled pork sandwich. & the cheese pierogi was amazing! (Didn't get a pic of that, it disappeared so fast)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich
I enjoy supporting locally owned establishments, especially when the food is good. I had the burger that was made with beef from the local High School was flavorful, the atmosphere lively, and staff attentive.