Nice little place cute on the inside 4 tables with 4 chairs each, not sure if this is the style of pizza that people like but it’s like a big lunch-able pizza crust baked to be a bit crispy and then regular sauce and lots of oily cheese, reminded me of school pizza to be honest not a fan, also I thought it’s a bit pricy at $6 a slice for plain cheese
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Justin Bassett-Green
Quick by the slice spot, great slices. Usually only a few pies are ready for slices, but you'll find something you like.Wheelchair accessibility: This location does not have a permanent wheelchair ramp.
Some of the worst pizza Ive ever had and at 7$ a slice are you kidding me? It was a step above frozen pizza you buy at the
Food: 1
Mah Rou
I loved their mushroom pizza. It was perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alan Arroyo
If you haven't tried the pizza here, yall snoozing. Got myself a slice of sausage pizza and it was delicious. Baked to perfection (crunchy), with that soft feeling of the dough aswell?. Very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JayeLynn Padilla
Someone who grew up in chicago, I've seen my fair share of pizza places especially being italian. This place holds a very near and dear place in my heart. I started going here because I used to bartend at Beaumont on Halstead. Someone who used to be in the club industry I believe owned it and it was open super late I want to say four or five in the morning if I'm not mistaken. We would order there all the time they delivered and when I had my son I was at Northwest hospital downtown chicago. Even though it was out of there a delivery area they made a trip for us and that meant the world to me that I will always hold pie eyed in my heart. I'm in Arizona now and I miss this so much. Also the pizza was amazing and they had the best mozzarella sticks I've ever had in my life. If you are debating going to pie-eyed, I definitely recommend you make the trip it is phenomenal. My question now is Ian still there????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashwini Naik
Tried their fried shrimp, jumbo wings and boneless wings. Everything was great but I think the fried shrimp was simply the best!! Kind staff, quick service and exceptional food!! My new go to place for comfort food :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emma Harnsberger
The pizza was alright. I didn’t think there was much flavor at all. For the price, there are many other places to order from for cheaper. Probably wouldn’t get it again. I did like their shoe string fries tho.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Fries
Seth A.
For $10 for a slice & fountain soda, they could really be making a better slice of pizza. As a matter of pride, guys, make a better slice of pizza. It's fine; it could so easily be better. You're charging $10 for a slice and a fountain soda. Surely could make this slice better.
Carina Esquivel
I hadn’t visited this place in approximately 2yrs. To the point that I had forgotten how good it was. That’s why I decided to go back and bring those vivid memories back again. Didn’t disappoint.
This place is dope. Chill vibes, great pizza. Hail ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
Foodie W.
Horrendously bad. Horrendously overpriced pizza. Hard to tell which is worse, crust or sauce. $6.25 all in for a cheese slice. If this was a 99 cent slice place it would be overpriced
Elise McKnight-Kim
I have eaten here twice now, both times right after attending Lolla: First of all, I can’t help love the location which is conveniently right next to the Chicago blue line stop. But somehow I had never eaten here before despite living in the neighborhood of West town.The first night, I had an Italian beef with cheese and hot peppers around 11 PM: probably the most delicious thing I’ve ever eaten, and I believe that it gave me the strength to go on despite being very tired and sore from all day dancingThe second night, I had a slice of sausage pizza around midnight almost: also very delicious. It was a very saucy but still not too saucy pizza, generous portion sizeDefinitely know I will be coming back. Also, I love all the metal posters!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Anuj S.
Recently did a pizza by the slice tour in my neighborhood of West Town and Pie Eyed Pizza was a cool though unplanned discovery. I was driving by towards another pizza slice place and happened to see the sign for Pizza slice. The pizza here was decent. Nice and crispy crust, which is my style of tavern pizza. Good stuff, although they didn't have enough sauce in the pizza. I think if they had had more sauce, this would've been a really good pizza. No other complaints. I'd give it 3.5 if I had that option. Price-wise at $5.75 or so for the slice, the pricing was just in-line with nearby pizza joints. I'm willing to give this place another shot in case the less sauce thing was a one-time miss. Love when you find something unexpected, though.
Sofia Cruz
been coming here since i was 17 (i’m 23 now) and it’s always been my favorite pizza spot. i love the shoe string fries and now you can get them with cajun seasoning. 10/10 recommend
Nice little place cute on the inside 4 tables with 4 chairs each, not sure if this is the style of pizza that people like but it’s like a big lunch-able pizza crust baked to be a bit crispy and then regular sauce and lots of oily cheese, reminded me of school pizza to be honest not a fan, also I thought it’s a bit pricy at $6 a slice for plain cheese
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Quick by the slice spot, great slices. Usually only a few pies are ready for slices, but you'll find something you like.Wheelchair accessibility: This location does not have a permanent wheelchair ramp.
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice Combo, Classic Thin Crust Pizza
Some of the worst pizza Ive ever had and at 7$ a slice are you kidding me? It was a step above frozen pizza you buy at the
Food: 1
I loved their mushroom pizza. It was perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you haven't tried the pizza here, yall snoozing. Got myself a slice of sausage pizza and it was delicious. Baked to perfection (crunchy), with that soft feeling of the dough aswell?. Very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Someone who grew up in chicago, I've seen my fair share of pizza places especially being italian. This place holds a very near and dear place in my heart. I started going here because I used to bartend at Beaumont on Halstead. Someone who used to be in the club industry I believe owned it and it was open super late I want to say four or five in the morning if I'm not mistaken. We would order there all the time they delivered and when I had my son I was at Northwest hospital downtown chicago. Even though it was out of there a delivery area they made a trip for us and that meant the world to me that I will always hold pie eyed in my heart. I'm in Arizona now and I miss this so much. Also the pizza was amazing and they had the best mozzarella sticks I've ever had in my life. If you are debating going to pie-eyed, I definitely recommend you make the trip it is phenomenal. My question now is Ian still there????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried their fried shrimp, jumbo wings and boneless wings. Everything was great but I think the fried shrimp was simply the best!! Kind staff, quick service and exceptional food!! My new go to place for comfort food :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was alright. I didn’t think there was much flavor at all. For the price, there are many other places to order from for cheaper. Probably wouldn’t get it again. I did like their shoe string fries tho.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Fries
For $10 for a slice & fountain soda, they could really be making a better slice of pizza. As a matter of pride, guys, make a better slice of pizza. It's fine; it could so easily be better. You're charging $10 for a slice and a fountain soda. Surely could make this slice better.
I hadn’t visited this place in approximately 2yrs. To the point that I had forgotten how good it was. That’s why I decided to go back and bring those vivid memories back again. Didn’t disappoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is dope. Chill vibes, great pizza. Hail ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
Horrendously bad. Horrendously overpriced pizza. Hard to tell which is worse, crust or sauce. $6.25 all in for a cheese slice. If this was a 99 cent slice place it would be overpriced
I have eaten here twice now, both times right after attending Lolla: First of all, I can’t help love the location which is conveniently right next to the Chicago blue line stop. But somehow I had never eaten here before despite living in the neighborhood of West town.The first night, I had an Italian beef with cheese and hot peppers around 11 PM: probably the most delicious thing I’ve ever eaten, and I believe that it gave me the strength to go on despite being very tired and sore from all day dancingThe second night, I had a slice of sausage pizza around midnight almost: also very delicious. It was a very saucy but still not too saucy pizza, generous portion sizeDefinitely know I will be coming back. Also, I love all the metal posters!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recently did a pizza by the slice tour in my neighborhood of West Town and Pie Eyed Pizza was a cool though unplanned discovery. I was driving by towards another pizza slice place and happened to see the sign for Pizza slice. The pizza here was decent. Nice and crispy crust, which is my style of tavern pizza. Good stuff, although they didn't have enough sauce in the pizza. I think if they had had more sauce, this would've been a really good pizza. No other complaints. I'd give it 3.5 if I had that option. Price-wise at $5.75 or so for the slice, the pricing was just in-line with nearby pizza joints. I'm willing to give this place another shot in case the less sauce thing was a one-time miss. Love when you find something unexpected, though.
been coming here since i was 17 (i’m 23 now) and it’s always been my favorite pizza spot. i love the shoe string fries and now you can get them with cajun seasoning. 10/10 recommend