Terry's Toffee

1853 2nd St, Highland Park
(312) 733-2700

Recent Reviews

Anna Cienkowski (Ania C'ski)

I stumbled upon this place by accident but the crisp white and black colors from inside drew me in. It is bright, spacious and very well organized and clean. The customer service is BEYOND spectacular. I arrived just shortly after they opened and was walking around, the gentleman was kind and had a plethora of knowledge on the toffee and Gelato products. He gave me the history of the business and even about the toffee and co-business with the Gelato. His honest and product knowledge was superior. He demonstrated he knows his clients and product. The Gelato was out of this world, tasted like the Gelato in Italy because it really was produced by the Italians and the same way. We love toffee and they had numerous variations of flavors and chocolate collaborations. The coffee was spit on too. The quality of every product is truly superior like their customer service and very generous portions. Pricing is spot on for what you get. This place is worth the 30cminite drive from Glenview. Nothing compares to their flavors of Gelato and toffee selection. Lots of sitting room to socialize, read or work on your computer.

Karyn M.

Terry's Toffee and Sweet Home Gelato -- I stopped in to pick up a gift of their delicious toffee. There are many tempting flavors in the case -- also covered Oreos--and prepackaged toffee. I purchased a hatbox and selected my own mix -- pretzel sea salt, peppermint pistachio, McCalls Classic, Espresso, Cinnamon Chipotle and Mazel Toffee. So envious of the gift recipient who is going to enjoy all this toffee so I wanted to purchase a piece for myself and they gifted me a small bag of toffee. Can't wait to dig in!

Ben Squire

Exceptional toffee, zero customer service. Each year, I order toffee as stocking stuffers for my family. This year, I ordered and received the box, but didn't open it until Christmas eve. That's when I discovered I only got half my order. I confirmed the quantities on the order and replied to the order email asking them to correct it. I received no response. After a week, I emailed again. I received no response. After a week, I filled out the Contact Us form on the webpage. I received no response. I have given up hope on receiving the other half of my order or a refund for the missing items. I was a loyal customer and promoted them to others.

Annette D

Nice place with nice people working there. Enjoyed the coffee and toffee very much.

Darius Urbanski

Love this place!! The selection si not overwhelming and the spectrum of flavors is just right.I saw someone mention a sugar free option, are you serious?? That’s like going to a coffee shop and asking for caffeine free espresso!! Lol gettattahere!! Anyway, great place, great flavors.

Ajit Kalra

Here’s what you need to know: love the launch of Terry’s in downtown HP and even more the re-launch of Sweet Home Gelato. Great collaboration and partnership. Amazing toffee and incredible Gelato. Mike, the new manager for the business is brilliant. As good as you can find anywhere in the business. He’s Super customer focused and an absolute joy to interact with. And that translates down to a terrific store experience with attention to detail for sure - store always very clean with good design and ambiance and the treats are always perfectly made. Just a terrific product and terrific service at the Terry’s / Sweet Home Gelato store. We have been going there several times a week this summer and expect to do so for years.

Google user

Here’s what you need to know: love the launch of Terry’s in downtown HP and even more the re-launch of Sweet Home Gelato. Great collaboration and partnership. Amazing toffee and incredible Gelato. Mike, the new manager for the business is brilliant. As good as you can find anywhere in the business. He’s Super customer focused and an absolute joy to interact with. And that translates down to a terrific store experience with attention to detail for sure - store always very clean with good design and ambiance and the treats are always perfectly made. Just a terrific product and terrific service at the Terry’s / Sweet Home Gelato store. We have been going there several times a week this summer and expect to do so for years.

Donna P.

I love the gelato, but the last two evenings that I had it it was like soup.... melted. yuk! but they still served itvery disappointing.......

Brian B.

Placed internet order that they shipped via FedEx. Received a tampered delivery February 1, 2023. Label had been opened and resealed. 2 of the 3 items were missing. FedEx requires that claims must include a statement from the shipper stating that they authorize me to make the loss claim. Keith at terrys toffe said in an email feb 7 he would send the letter .emails from me since then have been ignored.

Maricela Rodriguez

Very nice Cozy place for cup of coffee or Hot Chocolate

Susan Jungels

Very disappointing that you no longer have Sugarfree options.

Lee W.

This is such a cute shop, right off the train stop. Coffee, ice cream, toffees This place was fantastic and friendly. Got some good recommendations and had a really nice conversation with guy at the counter. He had a great selection of toffees and some really nice mixed sets. There were some very tasty selections, we went with the Lincoln Park Mix (Pretzel & sea salt; McCall's Classic; Koffee Toffee and Peanut Butter Chocolate). YUM. We also grabbed a Cinnamon-Chipotle toffee too.

Melissa M.

One of the last stops on our food tour. Talk about save the best for last!! I'm a toffee lover so maybe I'm biased- however I'm told this is one of the swag items if you win an academy award??!!! Delicious artisanal toffee!!

Tim Ritts

Great toffee and ice cream! Lots of variety of flavors and the owner is very welcoming!

Jaela Boeve

The best toffee I have ever had! I recommend the white chocolate covered toffee, it is delicious!!!?

Load More