Casey's

639 E Terra Cotta Ave, Crystal Lake
(815) 459-1518

Recent Reviews

Bruh What

I love this location. The cleanest Casey's I've been in by far. The staff are wonderdul. Nancy and Cindy are just so sweet and you are greeted like an old friend. The food is pretty good for gas station food, and Sky in the kitchen is so sweet and fast. When I ask for extra pickles she actually gives you EXTRA pickles, unlike mcDonalds. Im not sure what his name is, but the young store manager is a hard worker and he's pretty nice. The donuts look gorgeous and yummy too! I just wish they had the French Toast fritter still:(This location is not to be confused with the Terra Cotta location that has the car wash!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Mac

Anne Smith

The cashiers are openly rude and every customer coming through the door was slipping because it was wet and there were no rugs and they laughed when I said it’s not safe. Can not stress enough how rude the staff was.

Brodie Johnson

Was in the Store trying to get hot food no one was helping me so I ordered it online and click pay in store as I’m already there and There and immediately the 2 men working started throwing a fit about having to make food and one of them said “I’m not doing that just call him and tell him the kitchens closed it isn’t paid for so it won’t be an issue” so they call and I didn’t answer but I got my items and just before leaving I heard one guy say to the other “yeah I’m not doing that we close at 10 but I’m just not doing that” it was 8:40 when I ordered it….

Brian Stodola Sr

I ordered a thin crust pizza... That's what I got so 1 star.If it was cooked would have been more, cause after 20 minutes in the oven it was good.

Jeff Olsen

This review is only for the car wash. Don’t waste your money on it. Go elsewhere for wash. Car wash actually cleaner before the wash. Left a haze/film.

unkind jj

It's my local Casey's decent staff. Had a few issues in the past loading my chime debit card with cash.

Staci Bourland

The prices are good on gas and the selection of items inside is enormous. So much to choose from. The hot and ready selection is good too! Convenient location as well

Greg N.

This place has gone downhill. There's no food options anymore. And what is there is usually cold. I'm like a battered wife, I think they will change so I keep going back to them. But they're not changing without getting rid of the guy running the kitchen.

Randy Nowak

Close the doors. Turn the lights off. The shop has more problems with staying open and they are worth it

Tina Collins

Pizza is very good, staff is friendly! My one complaint is that the tea has an odd smell and flavor. Maybe using tap water? Definitely should only use fresh/filtered water

Deborah Fitzpatrick

Line out the door... 10 minute wait for a cup of coffee.

l roy

Thank you for stocking the organic cold press juice made by Casey’s. I will be getting my diesel fuel from you for now on

Rosa Garcia

I understand you make great pizza, but why would you mess with best donuts and concha’s! I was loving to come every morning for my cinnamon roll or fresh concha and my coffee! Seriously you all need to come up with a better option or go back to Bucky’s!!!!

Stefano Theofanous

Generous and kind service and affordable prices.

Ajay Patel

I stopped by there the first time ,don't live in Illinois, stopped to get some to drink ,and saw had a little sandwich place and got a sub. The gal name I think was andy,and there was another gal also they both were sweet and professional, and she made a awesome sin, plus the manager Robert that i met was also awesome and the gal who checked us out was also awesome and basically everyone there was above and beyond .

Load More