We ordered the lasagna pizza and the four hooved pig pizzas from here and they were amazing! They were super busy because it was a Friday night and Chris contacted me right away with an update. Ingredients were extremely fresh and sauce was delicious. We will be making this our go to pizza place.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lzpf07 ..
Not enough sauce. Normal cheese. Flavors were mild at best. Wings were better than pizza. Not with the money, wouldn't order again.
Devin Ryan
Very yummy pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Emily T
Fantastic service and food! Chris was very informative on when the pizza was expected to be delivered and was right on time. Mike delivered with a smiling face and was incredibly kind. The pizza was a little slice of New York City heaven! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Jacqlyn P.
Pizza was hot with fresh ingredients. We also had park garlic wings that were delicious. We will definitely order again. Ordering was also super easy.
cody bernard
2.5 stars..Presentation looked good and cheese is good upon first glance when opening the box… but that’s about where it ends.Bottom of pizza was extremely over cooked and basically ruined the taste of the entire pizza because every bite was like biting into charcoal. I am a first time customer and was really hoping to like this place but for $40 for just a single pizza I could do a lot better for local options that are cheaper. But If u want customers to come back I suggest u fix ur oven…
Andrew S.
Costumer service was great our delivery man was spot on. But the pizza was not good. I have had pizza from all over these United States. This was some of the worst pizza. I have ever had. Frozen pizza from a box is better than this pizza. Stay away from this place
Rocky R.
Super nice people. I just don't think I like this type of pizza very much. It's cooked in a very hot oven quickly. I think it's a version of those brick fire ones you see everywhere. Barely any sauce. I don't get it. Again very nice people.
Chris Graef
Good pizza and maybe the best option for NY style. The toppings were flavorful, the crust was crunchy and a little bendy. My one complaint is the crust is a bit hard but would be complemented well with some extra sauce. Would other again!
Shawn Casselberry
NY Pizza Pie is no longer here. It is now a place called All Day Kitchens that has food from 13 different restaurants that you can order online and pickup or use a QR code in store. A couple of the restaurants they have food from are 90 Miles (cuban), Honey Butter Chicken, Jeni's ice cream, Devil Dawgs, We didn't get food here because we came specifically for NY Pizza Pie but the guy working here was really friendly. He said Google Maps hasn't changed the name of this location so a lot of people, like me, don't realize the place has closed.
Delicious NY style crust, chewy, crispy. Great white pie. The pies were delivered piping hot. The owner definitely has a passion for creating true NY style pies.
J English
Tried to visit, but place did not seem to be in business, or I was at wrong address. Really wanted to try their pizza. Closed?
Colin Gartner
Got an 18" cheese pizza (nice flavor, thin crust,now my favorite), bosco bsticks (cheese filled bread sticks that are delectable), Mac & cheese bites (VERY TASTY FOR ME AND MY 4 yr old) and sweet potato ? (super tasty, off the hook) with soda on the house.Customer service: second to NONE! You will get treated how one customer is supposed to be. It's just too bad I forgot to ask his name (guy with the brown beard).Great ambience, you call it cozy too, I'm definitely HOOKED. I'VE been looking for a pizza place to say this is my go to for a nice, cheesy, delicious slice.
Ty R
This place is on another level. Freshest ingredients with an amazing crust. The wings are excellent and travel well. Highly recommend this place. It's pure quality. It takes a little more time than your chains because of the quality to detail and the fresh ingredients. Well done NY PIZZA PIE, your product is pure class.
We ordered the lasagna pizza and the four hooved pig pizzas from here and they were amazing! They were super busy because it was a Friday night and Chris contacted me right away with an update. Ingredients were extremely fresh and sauce was delicious. We will be making this our go to pizza place.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not enough sauce. Normal cheese. Flavors were mild at best. Wings were better than pizza. Not with the money, wouldn't order again.
Very yummy pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Fantastic service and food! Chris was very informative on when the pizza was expected to be delivered and was right on time. Mike delivered with a smiling face and was incredibly kind. The pizza was a little slice of New York City heaven! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Pizza was hot with fresh ingredients. We also had park garlic wings that were delicious. We will definitely order again. Ordering was also super easy.
2.5 stars..Presentation looked good and cheese is good upon first glance when opening the box… but that’s about where it ends.Bottom of pizza was extremely over cooked and basically ruined the taste of the entire pizza because every bite was like biting into charcoal. I am a first time customer and was really hoping to like this place but for $40 for just a single pizza I could do a lot better for local options that are cheaper. But If u want customers to come back I suggest u fix ur oven…
Costumer service was great our delivery man was spot on. But the pizza was not good. I have had pizza from all over these United States. This was some of the worst pizza. I have ever had. Frozen pizza from a box is better than this pizza. Stay away from this place
Super nice people. I just don't think I like this type of pizza very much. It's cooked in a very hot oven quickly. I think it's a version of those brick fire ones you see everywhere. Barely any sauce. I don't get it. Again very nice people.
Good pizza and maybe the best option for NY style. The toppings were flavorful, the crust was crunchy and a little bendy. My one complaint is the crust is a bit hard but would be complemented well with some extra sauce. Would other again!
NY Pizza Pie is no longer here. It is now a place called All Day Kitchens that has food from 13 different restaurants that you can order online and pickup or use a QR code in store. A couple of the restaurants they have food from are 90 Miles (cuban), Honey Butter Chicken, Jeni's ice cream, Devil Dawgs, We didn't get food here because we came specifically for NY Pizza Pie but the guy working here was really friendly. He said Google Maps hasn't changed the name of this location so a lot of people, like me, don't realize the place has closed.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great NY style pizza. Delivery was quick.
Delicious NY style crust, chewy, crispy. Great white pie. The pies were delivered piping hot. The owner definitely has a passion for creating true NY style pies.
Tried to visit, but place did not seem to be in business, or I was at wrong address. Really wanted to try their pizza. Closed?
Got an 18" cheese pizza (nice flavor, thin crust,now my favorite), bosco bsticks (cheese filled bread sticks that are delectable), Mac & cheese bites (VERY TASTY FOR ME AND MY 4 yr old) and sweet potato ? (super tasty, off the hook) with soda on the house.Customer service: second to NONE! You will get treated how one customer is supposed to be. It's just too bad I forgot to ask his name (guy with the brown beard).Great ambience, you call it cozy too, I'm definitely HOOKED. I'VE been looking for a pizza place to say this is my go to for a nice, cheesy, delicious slice.
This place is on another level. Freshest ingredients with an amazing crust. The wings are excellent and travel well. Highly recommend this place. It's pure quality. It takes a little more time than your chains because of the quality to detail and the fresh ingredients. Well done NY PIZZA PIE, your product is pure class.