Papa Johns Pizza

100 N Henrietta St, Effingham
(217) 347-4744

Recent Reviews

Doug Sharp

The call center needs to go away id rather call the store itself and the person that answered the phone can hardly speak good English hard to understand the call center is the biggest reason I don't order from Papa John's very often only place that has a call center to all other you talk to actual people at the store and you can understand what they are saying

David Faurie

To expensive. Won't be visiting soon.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Robin Murrell

The pizzas were ok. Service was super slow. We ordered 2 pizzas and it said they were done. We went to pick them up and were told they only had 1 pizza done and the other would be about 10 more minutes because the pizza oven wouldn't let them make 2 pizzas at a time. They said they made one and the oven shuts off to cool down and then they have to heat up back up to cook the other pizza. The restaurant didn't look very clean and the windows looked gross. We chanced it because we were starving.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Create Your Own

tony anderson

The staff are always friendly with a smile. The bread doesn't have any flavor. Taste blah.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings and Pizza

Charlene Mosby

I had my son place my order & yeah the Pizza was great but I didn't get my $4.00 bottle of Pepsi which totally sucked probably won't order from here any time soon ?

Food: 4

Service: 3

Melena Howard

Pizza was delicious and on time. Toppings could have been spread out better and staff could have been a bit friendlier and more accommodated but over all a good experience and I will return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Cyn R

Rude, and not clean at all. Lobby is a mess every time I go in. It appears no one cleans the bathrooms either. I also have seen many pizza screens on the floor. Employees just kick them around instead of picking them up.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Zackarias Martin

We ordered from the road (driving on the Interstate) and zoomed in (perfect timing), picked up our free pizza and headed back to the Interstate at Mach 2 ! Such fresh pizza !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mel Jane

Just say no. We tried to use online order, wouldnt work. Tried to order what we chose online and was told by employee I cant help you. They obviously have enough business they dont care.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

UnkleToe97

Great pizza and great staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brandon Taylor

You know I normally wouldn't give a 5 star review. But having mentioned that I say this. The quality at this location is second to none. My family frequently visits this location. We had a small bit of trouble with an order and the manager/ owner, more than made up for it. It was beyond what I would have expected as I would've been happy with a simple apology. This place will continue to be our regular pizza place for family pie night.

Lemon Boi

Andrew Miller delivered my food quickly and had amazing manners. 10/10 guy

James Pillsbury

I have to call...INDIA to place an order at papa John's. ONE mile away?Are.you.kidding me?Last time for that.

Phil Logsdon

VERY dirty outside of building... several attempts to pressure wash leaves me to believe the management just don't care

Samanthia Hall

I love their pizza from the crust, sauce and fresh toppings. The manager and crew are very friendly.

Load More