Old Neighborhood Grill

2902 Central St, Evanston
(847) 492-9500

Recent Reviews

John R.

This place is ate up. A group of about 7 people were exiting as I walked in. They told the cashier they were going to eat somewhere else. They looked annoyed. I ordered a gyro with no tomato togo and when i got home saw i had a gyro with nothing on it. I drove back with the sandwich and asked for a refund. I was refused. This used to be our goto spot. Has really gone downhil.

John P.

Burger was red the whole way through. Fried were served cold. The $8 can of beer was drinkable.

Luis Acosta

Great beer and good food

Dwayne Hawkins

I simply loved their food. I always get excellent service here. The place is always clean and the staff members are always very friendly. Will come visit again.

Ryan Cool

Love the atmosphere, love the staff, love the food. Would strongly Recommend stopping in.

Steve Weissmann

Good food. Casual atmosphere in nice neighborhood.

Lenny Falstick

I’m from Houston and just stumbled on this place today. Had a great conversation with a couple patrons and the owner. Very good afternoon.One of the best cheeseburgers I’ve ever eaten. On top of that the feta cheese fries were great. Oh yes and the beer was good and cold. ?

Karen M.

We love going to the Neighborhood Grill. The owner has a tent, tables and heat lamps set up in the back during Covid. I highly recommend it. It has a fun family atmosphere!

John Fitterer

Very friendly staff and owner. Good beer selection, excellent wings!

Lori Calabrese Malecki

Quick service, friendly people, good food! My son just moved here and I’m sure he will go there again!

Otis Rodriquez

Great and tasty food, I like the mood the spot has, and the staff members were very nice. Will definitely visit here next time.

James Iverson

The pulled pork sandwich was outstanding! And really nice bar and great service.

Joseph DiPadova

Ian Bryan is the best employee ever! Such a great young man.

Andrea R.

Thank you John for staying open and supporting the neighborhood. We love you and your family. We will be in soon for some Gyros.

JoseLuis B.

John, Theresa and their girls are neighbours and truly represent a local family business. They have been there for the community since they opened about 11yrs ago, and they continue to be there for the Neighbourhood these days. Good food. Good people. Love their burgers and Gyro. Call to order your food +1 (847) 492-9500 and pick it up at 2902 Central St, Evanston You will meet John every day there and...no joke!...he will disinfect your credit card and signing pen for you! ;-) Be well and safe.

Load More