Tag's Bakery

2010 Central St, Evanston
(847) 328-1200

Recent Reviews

Benjamin Reha

Incredible bakery you must go visit! Half of the location is a bit green and the other half is a café. When I walked in, I was greeted with the smile and excellent service. I let them know. This is my first time visiting. They suggested a few of their most popular treats I picked up a few cookies to try And the friendly woman behind the counter, offered me a complementary cookie on the house. Not only was the service, great, and the cookies were delicious, but the interior space was immaculate. I will definitely come back and will recommend this location to any of my fellow Bakery lovers, thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Florentine Cookies

Deborah H.

For Purim, they had Hamentaschen, almond cookies (which they called macaroons), and tiny chocolate dipped coconut macaroons. Both the macaroons were decidedly stale. Guess they tried!

c.m. Isaac

If you are looking for delicious cheese strudel ,apple slices or biscotti then this place is a must try!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Julie-Ann Klein

The best cookies ever! I order boxes for clients and friends and they never disappoint. The service is excellent and the adjoining cafe is a great place to hang out and order their hot soup - I love the mushroom soup! My new favorite neighborhood hangout!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emily R

Really pleased with this place! A go-to coffee shop was closed so I decided to pop in here. The service was so personable and lovely. My mocha was delicious! Chiron was patient and helpful as I couldn’t decide! It’s super cute and spacious inside. Give this place a try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Angel Morales

The best of the bestSo if they will be a pleasureIt counts but it's worth it

Ray C.

Tag's Bakery is such a great place to get unique and outstanding bakery items as gifts for others. Of course, I always treat myself as well. I highly recommend Tag's Bakery.

Peter Daw

They made a custom cake for us and it was perfect!

Elizabeth Gussis

My first visit to Tags I live in NW suburbs 35 miles away . I was working in area . I Purchased cake slices there were delicious , purchased more a week later (working in area) next day purchased cake was okay little dry . Not as good as the cake slices . Purchased cake slices next day they were not as fresh . Went there a week later to purchase cake slices on a Thursday they were out of cake slices . Went there the following Tuesday they still had not replenished there bakery stock . Cakes were sitting in display case over 1-2 weeks old . . I thought I had finally found a great bakery however , I am Very disappointed in consistency and staff attitude

Marianne P.

If you want a special cake to celebrate a special occasion, Tag's Bakery is the best. They also feature a variety of cupcakes, cookies and pastries. Tag's is known for their florentines. The staff is kind and helpful. Tag's also opened a Cafe. Food is simple but delicious. Need to try it all!

Jorge Juarez

My mother, Gloria, worked at Tag's bakery in 1982. Visiting brings back joyful and tasty memories. Their Florentines are uniquely classic and so delicious. So very glad to see the bakery is still open and thriving, their staff is wonderful. Definitely a place to go and enjoy with others.

Haley Cole

I grew up I Evanston, have visited tags bakery many many times and used them for various occasions and celebrations. I have ordered the half smiley cookies for many occasions and they have always been beautiful and delicious. My mom ordered a dozen cookies for a bridal shower this weekend and requested sage green with white initials of the bride and groom. When she got them home and I opened the box I was surprised to find these awful green cookies with messy handwriting looking like an amateur had done them. When I called and spoke to the manager she offered no apology or anything to rectify the situation. She even said that she thought they looked pretty so shows how low their standards have gotten. Clearly new management. I’ll be ordering my cookies elsewhere from now on.

Andy Kim

Their cakes are extremely dry. I bought a black and white cake and a raspberry cake and I was extremely disappointed. You would be better off buying your cakes at Jewel.

Daniel Devine

My childhood neighborhood bakery. Still making the same amazing, perfect baked goods. I'm so grateful they haven't really changed anything. They even still have the same wooden chair & take-a-number. If it ain't broke dont fix it.Famous for their florentines (best I've ever had) but everything else is great and I'll never pass up a smiley cookie from Tags. I just wish they shipped to NC

Rolf Hofmann

AFTER TWO PHONE CALL, I was put off by your employe's who basically told me I could not make an order with the store,, when I tried the so-called shipping number it was the store number , Being a senior Vet I do not get out much, I found your employees to be less then helpful!

Load More