Stopped in here after visiting my Nephew with my Sister and her Husband. The atmosphere put me in the mine of Cheers, the TV show. The food was awesome. I ordered the loaded potatoes and garlic parmesan wings. My sister had the ribs and buffalo chicken with fries n garlic toast and her husband had the lemon pepper chicken breast with side salad, and homemade chips. The margaritas are very good not to mention their under $5. Place appear to be the go to place. It opened up at 11:00 and the people kept coming. Will visit again n definitely recommend if you are ever in Galesburg.
Patricia Gohring
The waitress was a bit over bearing. She took our order without writing it down. By the time she took the 3rd order of the 4, she was getting the orders confused. When our food arrived one of the orders was wrong. The cup of soup never came. The potato chips that were ordered were French fries. Not wanting to make a stink we ate what she brought. They were not busy & it was after the supper rush. Sully's used to be a great place to go for a good time, not so much anymoree.
David Skaggs
Usually go and they're okay. Today we went and ordered wings and they were the most pathetic wings I've ever seen and I'm not exaggerating. I even told the waitress these are the most pathetic wings I've ever seen. One Wing wasn't even bigger than my pinky finger. They didn't even bother to take anything off the bill it was pretty expensive for pathetic wings!!! I wish I would have taken a picture of how pathetic they were. We ended up going to Coney Island to finish eating!!!
Love A.
I've never ordered a drink from this pub, but the food isn't great. Appetizers are good. Wings are small but that is with any restaurant in America currently. The staff I have had experiences with are not very welcoming. I've even been sent home with a completely wrong order, found out after I got home 7 ish minutes later, called to ask if our correct order was still there, and was told "well our kitchen is closed" without any mention of a refund or anything until I called the next day. If you're looking for a place to order a beer and some apps, this place would work. Anything else? Wouldn't recommend.
Tamara Wilson
When we came in we sat ourselves because no one was around and then we were ignored for abt 10 min before someone asked us if we had been helped yet.Careless staff, ran out of ribs 3 hours before they closed, didn’t bring appetizer until after food because they forgot. Forgot a side to my husband’s meal and when we asked about it the waitress lied and said they were out of that side. Later we seen it on other plates coming out of the kitchen.
Joel Thrailkill
This place use to be a staple of Galesburg, but has gone downhill for years. Yet tonight takes the cake. Ordered boneless wings and breaded mushrooms for pickup, got 6 mushrooms for 7 dollars and wrong wings. When I called, they said they would give us boneless if we brought the other ones back. (During Covid mind you) took them back and reviewed 8 wings. 30 dollars for 6 mushrooms and 8 wings. I will never go or recommend Sully's again. Thanks for ruining a good place
Dave Schultz
I can't say I'd recommend them because of several bad reviews of slow service & rude employees.
Joel Thrailkill
Use to be a staple of Galesburg but has gone to crap. Spent 30 bucks and recieved 6 mushrooms and 8 wings. I've worked in food over 25 years and am embarrassed to say I worked here years ago with how bad this place has gotten.
David Schenck Jr
Awesome place, great food, great atmosphere
S Pierce
Update: THEY NEED A NEW COOK! The one they have now will cook sausage that smells bad, put it in your food, he will admit the sausage has gone bad, but they'll still charge you for the food. I come here a lot and the food has been on the decline. I however do not come until evenings so that is all I can tell you about. The waitress was wonderful however!The portions are MUCH smaller. The soup and half sandwich was small, the "bowl" was a cup, the soup was cold, separated and barely edible. They've taken so much off the menu that I suggest you call ahead if time to make sure they still have what you want. Hopefully they will answer the phone for you.
It's been a while since Ive been to Sully's and I was very disappointed in the quality of their food. Two things in my order were their homemade tenderloins and they were hard as a rock all around the edges and tasted burnt. The burgers were fine. They did forget my fries and drink to go so I went back in and the lady told the kitchen she needed 2 orders of ff and she got my coke. When she came out with the styrofoam containers, she handed them to me. No bag or anything; which I know I should have asked but I had already wasted enough time going back in. When I tried putting the 2 containers of ff in the bags from the sandwiches, of course they didnt fit and then I dropped them and the lids popped open and they went everywhere. Grr. This was just a sad trip to what used to be our favorite restaurant ?
Robert Poppleton
Good food. Good service. Good atmosphere.
coolgamer yt
Good place. Foods good. Service is good.
Dylan Marschang
Took a while for someone to actually come up and greet us. The waitress was polite, we asked for 2 Jager bombs and 2 captain and cokes. They didn't know what Jager bombs were and our bill for that was $19. We asked to customize an appetizer, they said they were pre-made and they couldn't do that. Then we asked for a pizza which on the menu said served all day. Come to find out they only do pizza on Thursdays. Disappointing to say the least.
Dena Boone
Got super nachos , they were the worst I've ever had. They don't put cheese sauce on their nachos just the toppings very dry and not even hot.
Stopped in here after visiting my Nephew with my Sister and her Husband. The atmosphere put me in the mine of Cheers, the TV show. The food was awesome. I ordered the loaded potatoes and garlic parmesan wings. My sister had the ribs and buffalo chicken with fries n garlic toast and her husband had the lemon pepper chicken breast with side salad, and homemade chips. The margaritas are very good not to mention their under $5. Place appear to be the go to place. It opened up at 11:00 and the people kept coming. Will visit again n definitely recommend if you are ever in Galesburg.
The waitress was a bit over bearing. She took our order without writing it down. By the time she took the 3rd order of the 4, she was getting the orders confused. When our food arrived one of the orders was wrong. The cup of soup never came. The potato chips that were ordered were French fries. Not wanting to make a stink we ate what she brought. They were not busy & it was after the supper rush. Sully's used to be a great place to go for a good time, not so much anymoree.
Usually go and they're okay. Today we went and ordered wings and they were the most pathetic wings I've ever seen and I'm not exaggerating. I even told the waitress these are the most pathetic wings I've ever seen. One Wing wasn't even bigger than my pinky finger. They didn't even bother to take anything off the bill it was pretty expensive for pathetic wings!!! I wish I would have taken a picture of how pathetic they were. We ended up going to Coney Island to finish eating!!!
I've never ordered a drink from this pub, but the food isn't great. Appetizers are good. Wings are small but that is with any restaurant in America currently. The staff I have had experiences with are not very welcoming. I've even been sent home with a completely wrong order, found out after I got home 7 ish minutes later, called to ask if our correct order was still there, and was told "well our kitchen is closed" without any mention of a refund or anything until I called the next day. If you're looking for a place to order a beer and some apps, this place would work. Anything else? Wouldn't recommend.
When we came in we sat ourselves because no one was around and then we were ignored for abt 10 min before someone asked us if we had been helped yet.Careless staff, ran out of ribs 3 hours before they closed, didn’t bring appetizer until after food because they forgot. Forgot a side to my husband’s meal and when we asked about it the waitress lied and said they were out of that side. Later we seen it on other plates coming out of the kitchen.
This place use to be a staple of Galesburg, but has gone downhill for years. Yet tonight takes the cake. Ordered boneless wings and breaded mushrooms for pickup, got 6 mushrooms for 7 dollars and wrong wings. When I called, they said they would give us boneless if we brought the other ones back. (During Covid mind you) took them back and reviewed 8 wings. 30 dollars for 6 mushrooms and 8 wings. I will never go or recommend Sully's again. Thanks for ruining a good place
I can't say I'd recommend them because of several bad reviews of slow service & rude employees.
Use to be a staple of Galesburg but has gone to crap. Spent 30 bucks and recieved 6 mushrooms and 8 wings. I've worked in food over 25 years and am embarrassed to say I worked here years ago with how bad this place has gotten.
Awesome place, great food, great atmosphere
Update: THEY NEED A NEW COOK! The one they have now will cook sausage that smells bad, put it in your food, he will admit the sausage has gone bad, but they'll still charge you for the food. I come here a lot and the food has been on the decline. I however do not come until evenings so that is all I can tell you about. The waitress was wonderful however!The portions are MUCH smaller. The soup and half sandwich was small, the "bowl" was a cup, the soup was cold, separated and barely edible. They've taken so much off the menu that I suggest you call ahead if time to make sure they still have what you want. Hopefully they will answer the phone for you.
Restaurantji Recommends
It's been a while since Ive been to Sully's and I was very disappointed in the quality of their food. Two things in my order were their homemade tenderloins and they were hard as a rock all around the edges and tasted burnt. The burgers were fine. They did forget my fries and drink to go so I went back in and the lady told the kitchen she needed 2 orders of ff and she got my coke. When she came out with the styrofoam containers, she handed them to me. No bag or anything; which I know I should have asked but I had already wasted enough time going back in. When I tried putting the 2 containers of ff in the bags from the sandwiches, of course they didnt fit and then I dropped them and the lids popped open and they went everywhere. Grr. This was just a sad trip to what used to be our favorite restaurant ?
Good food. Good service. Good atmosphere.
Good place. Foods good. Service is good.
Took a while for someone to actually come up and greet us. The waitress was polite, we asked for 2 Jager bombs and 2 captain and cokes. They didn't know what Jager bombs were and our bill for that was $19. We asked to customize an appetizer, they said they were pre-made and they couldn't do that. Then we asked for a pizza which on the menu said served all day. Come to find out they only do pizza on Thursdays. Disappointing to say the least.
Got super nachos , they were the worst I've ever had. They don't put cheese sauce on their nachos just the toppings very dry and not even hot.