Best Slice of Your Life In Chicago. I was ecstatic when they opened a suburb location as I've tried the one in Chicago. They truly live up to the hype. Thin crust that holds up, no soggy crusts here. The dough is crisp then transforms into a cloudy chewy experience. They take their dough seriously and pride themselves in the process of making it which shines through when you take a bite. They have many options but our fave is hot honey pepperoni. Perfectly sweet n salty, a little spicy. The slices are thin but large so if you plan to try more than one flavor, come with a group and come hungry. They do however, offer slices before 4pm I believe. So if you really do want to sample many flavors, I recommend that. Their place is small but acommodates a decent amount of people. Their staff is always lovely. If you are not a fan of waiting, then of course avoid peak dinner hours on a weekend. Other than that, just get ready to have one of the best pizzas you've ever had.
Diane Lynn
The best pizza!!! Great staffI’m a lifelong New Yorker and I have to say this pizza is just as great as the pizza I had back homeVegetarian options: Great cheese pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NY Classic Cheese Pie
Nancy Petrone
A recipe for disaster! I mean how do you serve pizza on a wobbly pizza stand and metal eating plates on a slick wooden table?!? We were a table of six and most of us had pizza on our lap, my son burning his hand after the Manager tells us to be careful The pizza is known to fly off! I want you to tell me how you would feel with pizza out of blazing hot oven on your hand and lap?!? We basically ran out of there and took the pizza to go. …this was a frustrating experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Steve J.
Awesome spot! My family went for the first time and it will most certainly not be our last. The food was incredible and the service was top notch. My son continues to talk about the vodka pepperoni grandma pizza "it was bussin". Awesome spot, must stop!
Karina Gomberg
my boyfriend and i went for a little date night and our server was extremely kind, helpful and attentive. food was amazing, and the atmosphere was fun and chill. the size of the restaurant allows for a more quaint hometown vibe. it may be new, but could believably be a long time classic in Geneva!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
El Magnifico52
Stopped in there last night with my wife. We’ve heard nothing but great things about this pizza place. Let me tell you, it didn’t not disappoint, first off the service was top notch. Charlie is a great waiter and was always attentive, stopping by our table often and making sure we were taken care of. Shoutout to Charlie! Keep up the great work! ?? Let’s start with the garlic knots, ? one word for those… Amazing! I’ve been searching for the perfect garlic knots in the Midwest, I know I have found them.. Now on to the pizza, I’ve had East coast pie all up and down the east coast. The New York Classic Cheese Pie is as good if not better than some places out east. The sauce is perfect! Not overwhelming or over seasoned. The crust is amazing as it should be, crunchy with the perfect amount of chew. The amount of cheese that tops this pizza is spot on! Overall this was a great experience and will absolutely be back again! Keep slinging those great pies!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NY Classic Cheese Pie, Garlic Rolls
Sharayah G.
I am giving this place 3 stars not because of the food but because of the experience. The pizza was excellent, it was thin crispy crust with the right amount of chew, it had great flavor and the lemons were a great touch, it obvious that they know what they're doing in the kitchen! The service however unfortunately wasn't great. We were seated at a dirty table, we ordered a salad that never came, and the pizza took about 45 min. A table that came in well after us received their food within about 15 min. And we had to flag down our server for plates and napkins as they didn't bring any when are food arrived. Overall we just felt a bit ignored and didn't have the best experience.
Rose Ann D.
These are the best pies in the area. They are so flavorful. We recently ordered four different pies, and they were all delicious. My favorite is the pesto and sausage pie. Yum! Make sure to also try the veal meatballs. And definitely get a Thicc A** cookie. You could feed a family with one! Needless to say, we will make this place our go-to for innovative and delicious pizza.
Rolo B.
By far my favorite pizza! A must try! So excited that they are opening another location in Glen Ellyn 2 minutes from my office! My fav is the White Pie!
Angela C.
The garlic knots were a hit. Not sure about the slices - seemed to get warmed back up in oven too much that ours had a charred/burnt crust and taste. Maybe we try a whole pie next time to see if a made fresh pie makes the difference.
Best NY style pizza!!! ? I have not found a place that comes closer to my favorite pizza on Long Island!!We came in March 2nd for dinner with our son. We all loved it. So March 8th my husband picked up two pies and brought them home. Tasted just as good with take out as it did eating there.Great job!! Thank you for bringing this type of pizza to the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Karen R.
Pizza was delivered on time through GrubHub but unfortunately the pizza was very dried out. We ordered the cheese pizza.
Ashley Strickland
The best pizza we have ever had hands down! We finally tried the location in Geneva a couple weeks ago and already have ordered from there twice! Also the staff is very welcoming and friendly! Easily 5 stars!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sid G.
Great, fresh ingredients, homemade crust makes this pie delicious. Nice and thin, cooked to perfection....staff couldn't be nicer and attentive and the garlic twists and sauces are really tasty.....5 stars! 3 stars on the table size, four of us and we ordered 2 pies. Our plates were almost falling off the table, hardly any room for our drinks, you're packed in there pretty tight. Limited beer and other alcoholic drink selections.
Jonathan K.
I think this place will do well, but it was far from a great NY style pizza. Crust was not classic in anyway and not sure what they brush on it. I hope they do well, but for me the pizza was a bust. Texture, taste, not airy at all, but a compacted crust that was just disappointing. Will try one more time.
Best Slice of Your Life In Chicago. I was ecstatic when they opened a suburb location as I've tried the one in Chicago. They truly live up to the hype. Thin crust that holds up, no soggy crusts here. The dough is crisp then transforms into a cloudy chewy experience. They take their dough seriously and pride themselves in the process of making it which shines through when you take a bite. They have many options but our fave is hot honey pepperoni. Perfectly sweet n salty, a little spicy. The slices are thin but large so if you plan to try more than one flavor, come with a group and come hungry. They do however, offer slices before 4pm I believe. So if you really do want to sample many flavors, I recommend that. Their place is small but acommodates a decent amount of people. Their staff is always lovely. If you are not a fan of waiting, then of course avoid peak dinner hours on a weekend. Other than that, just get ready to have one of the best pizzas you've ever had.
The best pizza!!! Great staffI’m a lifelong New Yorker and I have to say this pizza is just as great as the pizza I had back homeVegetarian options: Great cheese pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NY Classic Cheese Pie
A recipe for disaster! I mean how do you serve pizza on a wobbly pizza stand and metal eating plates on a slick wooden table?!? We were a table of six and most of us had pizza on our lap, my son burning his hand after the Manager tells us to be careful The pizza is known to fly off! I want you to tell me how you would feel with pizza out of blazing hot oven on your hand and lap?!? We basically ran out of there and took the pizza to go. …this was a frustrating experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Awesome spot! My family went for the first time and it will most certainly not be our last. The food was incredible and the service was top notch. My son continues to talk about the vodka pepperoni grandma pizza "it was bussin". Awesome spot, must stop!
my boyfriend and i went for a little date night and our server was extremely kind, helpful and attentive. food was amazing, and the atmosphere was fun and chill. the size of the restaurant allows for a more quaint hometown vibe. it may be new, but could believably be a long time classic in Geneva!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in there last night with my wife. We’ve heard nothing but great things about this pizza place. Let me tell you, it didn’t not disappoint, first off the service was top notch. Charlie is a great waiter and was always attentive, stopping by our table often and making sure we were taken care of. Shoutout to Charlie! Keep up the great work! ?? Let’s start with the garlic knots, ? one word for those… Amazing! I’ve been searching for the perfect garlic knots in the Midwest, I know I have found them.. Now on to the pizza, I’ve had East coast pie all up and down the east coast. The New York Classic Cheese Pie is as good if not better than some places out east. The sauce is perfect! Not overwhelming or over seasoned. The crust is amazing as it should be, crunchy with the perfect amount of chew. The amount of cheese that tops this pizza is spot on! Overall this was a great experience and will absolutely be back again! Keep slinging those great pies!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NY Classic Cheese Pie, Garlic Rolls
I am giving this place 3 stars not because of the food but because of the experience. The pizza was excellent, it was thin crispy crust with the right amount of chew, it had great flavor and the lemons were a great touch, it obvious that they know what they're doing in the kitchen! The service however unfortunately wasn't great. We were seated at a dirty table, we ordered a salad that never came, and the pizza took about 45 min. A table that came in well after us received their food within about 15 min. And we had to flag down our server for plates and napkins as they didn't bring any when are food arrived. Overall we just felt a bit ignored and didn't have the best experience.
These are the best pies in the area. They are so flavorful. We recently ordered four different pies, and they were all delicious. My favorite is the pesto and sausage pie. Yum! Make sure to also try the veal meatballs. And definitely get a Thicc A** cookie. You could feed a family with one! Needless to say, we will make this place our go-to for innovative and delicious pizza.
By far my favorite pizza! A must try! So excited that they are opening another location in Glen Ellyn 2 minutes from my office! My fav is the White Pie!
The garlic knots were a hit. Not sure about the slices - seemed to get warmed back up in oven too much that ours had a charred/burnt crust and taste. Maybe we try a whole pie next time to see if a made fresh pie makes the difference.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best NY style pizza!!! ? I have not found a place that comes closer to my favorite pizza on Long Island!!We came in March 2nd for dinner with our son. We all loved it. So March 8th my husband picked up two pies and brought them home. Tasted just as good with take out as it did eating there.Great job!! Thank you for bringing this type of pizza to the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza was delivered on time through GrubHub but unfortunately the pizza was very dried out. We ordered the cheese pizza.
The best pizza we have ever had hands down! We finally tried the location in Geneva a couple weeks ago and already have ordered from there twice! Also the staff is very welcoming and friendly! Easily 5 stars!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great, fresh ingredients, homemade crust makes this pie delicious. Nice and thin, cooked to perfection....staff couldn't be nicer and attentive and the garlic twists and sauces are really tasty.....5 stars! 3 stars on the table size, four of us and we ordered 2 pies. Our plates were almost falling off the table, hardly any room for our drinks, you're packed in there pretty tight. Limited beer and other alcoholic drink selections.
I think this place will do well, but it was far from a great NY style pizza. Crust was not classic in anyway and not sure what they brush on it. I hope they do well, but for me the pizza was a bust. Texture, taste, not airy at all, but a compacted crust that was just disappointing. Will try one more time.