Lefty's Pizza Kitchen

600 Central Ave, Highland Park
(847) 926-7194

Recent Reviews

Sam W.

their deep dish is awesome! really enjoyed the veggie pizza, plus their crust and cheese is amazing!

Keith Stateler

Slice was a little well done. But tasty

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Amira Alburei

Responsive service. - our was brought out pretty quickly. The thin crust is underwhelming- it’s not very flavorful crust.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Thin Crust Pizza

E.K. M.

The seating is SO uncomfortable that it's not worth going even though the pizza is so so. The booth has a 2 foot space between the seat and the back, so there's no back support whatsoever. We were all super uncomfortable and we're all able bodied. Our pizza was unevenly cooked, some pieces crispy others soggy. The sauce tasted like canned crushed tomatoes (and not much more) and overall the pizza was cheesy but not a lot of flavor. Sadly, an extra large pizza with pepperoni on half arrived with exactly 3 pieces of pepperoni on the whole thing.

mark f.

Yes good pizza for sure man.Get the Detroit style with

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Jason G

Pan is 5 stars. Thin crust is 3 at best. Always under cooked. I always order it well done and never actually comes well done.

ari b.

Seriously one of the better tavern style pizzas I've had. We've taken out from lefty's but eating in it was even better. Great for kids. And the beef Sando is solid... really solid.

Megan Dorsey

I wish you all were open in the afternoons on Saturday's. It’s always disappointing to see you closed while we are in town. Luckily we found another place that is open nearby with great pizza. Please reconsider your hours.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 2

Yossi Alhadif

Closed before 8:45pm on Saturday night when website and signs state closing at 9

Service: 1

Katie S.

Best Italian beef I have ever had - juicy and with peppers yum. I wish it were closer to me.

Bryan Sansom

Really tasty. Got a pan crust sausage, onion and giardiniera. Cooked to perfection. Wife kept stealing my crust because it was so good (she got the chopped salad. It was huge and delicious). We came in with a bunch of rowdy 10yr old boys after a soccer game and pretty much took the place over. They were very patient and accommodating. The kids really enjoyed their thin crust cheese, too! We will definitely be back.

Recommended dishes: Deep Pan Pizza, Chopped Salad, Thin Crust Pizza

David Adler

I don’t understand this business. Great deep dish (possibly the best in the area along with Pequods), but they are not responsive to incoming phone orders during their listed operating hours. On countless occasions (most recently yesterday) I’ve been put on hold and left there indefinitely. Other times I’ve called and gotten a ‘line is busy’ or ‘not operable’ notice. So I ordered kabobs from elsewhere yesterday, and have opted for other choices in the past when this happens, as well.Seems like it should be easy enough to resolve this phone issue and poor customer service related to phone ordering, if they don’t want to continue to lose business. Silly reason to continually lose business, if you ask me.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Deep Pan Pizza, Wings

Siddharth Patel

Best pizza in the burbs.

Food: 5

Megumi Mladenovic

This is now my new pizza place. The sauce is not overpowering, the cheese is delicious, and the toppings were copious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Deep Pan Pizza

Samantha Guillén

excellent service and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More