The place is decent, mostly depends what days and time you go. Sometimes the pizza is really good but other days it can be really dry ☹️ but when it's NOT dry the flavor immaculate
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Actually 1 Slice of Pepperoni
John Robel
This place never has their pizza special of the day available for immediate purchase on walk in. I confronted management about this about a year ago, and they changed, for a little while. From then on, I started calling in advance to ensure they had pizza to buy when I went to their pizza place, where they never had any pizza to sell, once again. I stopped in tonight to buy the special of the day, and again, no pizza. The only person who kept me in the place and as a customer was Jocelyn. She was very kind and made the pizza, right away. Either make pizza, or pay Jocelyn more to keep your customers because this is a disgrace.
Josh D.
This pizza place was a bit weird I walked in and placed an order for a large pizza to go, and while waiting they were playing r&b genre songs that were extremely graphic and explicit, I was the only one their on Tuesday 1/16 at 2pm, and the pizza was ok
Robert S.
Pizza is average. Delivery times are not accurate and unpredictable. Order from somewhere else if you need a specific time,
Becky Petermeyer
Angelica B. had a very bad attitude. I work at a restaurant and I'm never rude to the guests! The pizza tasted good but the service was bad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Percy Jackson
Last time I went, it was roughly 1 pm, they didn't have any pizza's ready. Nowadays, the pizzas are doughy and undone. Wouldn't really recommend, has gone down hill.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ronald Moore
Called to place an order for delivery workers didn't know the menu poor
Service: 1
Lex
This has always been my go to spot for several years when I want a quick slice, however lately I feel like the attention to quality on the slices has gone downhill. I never know if I am going to get a slice that is fresh, or looks like it’s been sitting out for hours. Half the time the pieces are overcooked and burnt, or they are dry and old. Please—if you overcook a pizza, don’t serve it. If it’s been sitting out for too long and is completely dried out and cold, don’t serve it. I’ve been going to slice factory instead now, only because I don’t get dry old pizza over there. Please go back to the quality we all love so I don’t have to order elsewhere :(
Food: 2
Zachary David
SECOND UPDATE: they reached out to me and I spoke with Lawrence. He was really thoughtful and receptive of what happened and wanted to make things right. I really appreciate that. I will be back for my favorite pizza place. Thanks for your help Lawrence!UPDATE: i called back and emily said the GM gave permission to no longer service me. What kind of business is this place? Rude, messes the order up, offers 10%? There are 100s of pizza places in the area and I always choose this place. But that will most likely change unless someone is willing to make it right. I didn’t even want my money back, all I wanted was them to deliver the correct pizza at no charge. I do not think that is an unreasonable ask. I do not eat sausage, but what if I were someone who is either allergic or based on religion or beliefs that I do not eat meat. Just terrible service overall. I do not try to be rude because i worked in the service industry but good lord this has to be the worst service I have ever gone through. Really hope they try and make things right.I have been coming to this place since it was di nicos. Im not sure what happened but it was an excellent place. However now it is awful. Sarah who now works in corporate was amazing to deal with, even if something got messed up but now shes in corporate. If she can see this, please reach out to me.Anyways, i ordered a pizza for delivery. The last few times they have messed something up. I ordered a cheese pizza and got a sausage. Called the store and spoke with the manager Emily. She was extremely rude and before we even conversed her offer was to refund me 10%? For something I dont want and am not going to eat. She said no she’s canceling the order to which i said fine cancel this one and refund and I will pay for the correct one. She said okay and then hung up. Extremely unprofessional. Literally been a lifelong customer and go at least 1-2x a week. Unbelievable. I would like to get my pizza. This is absolutely absurd. Terrible service. Really sad. I hope they are willing to make this right.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leny C.
had a pizza delivered last night that I never ordered (prank) - no one ordered it and I didn't accept it. so who is paying for it?? you are!
Great slice of pizza! Only problem is the location, downtown Lagrange, can be really busy and full of rather snobbish kids but nothing you can do about that. Highly
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greg Markus
Great price for a quick slice of pizza in a great area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Guzman
Nothing to write home about; we were just looking for a quick bite to eat. I wish we were told that 1 slice = 1/4 of the pie, aka 2 slices. 1 slice or 1/8 of the pie is more than sufficient cuz it’s a very thick crust. It’s a lot of food for $5.99 so it is a deal, but not a very tasty one. The young lady who took our order was very friendly though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Jeannetta Harris
Pizza was hard and cold cheesy garlic bread was just bread with slightly melted cheese also got a buffalo chicken salad now I know what a $16 salad looks like and that was not it no dressing for my salad there was nothing buffalo about the salad just lettuce a few pieces of dry chicken and a few olives fries were hot and soggy I got the fried dough it was more like fried graham crackers with a baby pinch of powdered sugar I won’t be back and I spent $70 I will be calling for a refund
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Greyson Fox
Unique and delicious. Sauce swings on the sweet side but good
The place is decent, mostly depends what days and time you go. Sometimes the pizza is really good but other days it can be really dry ☹️ but when it's NOT dry the flavor immaculate
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Actually 1 Slice of Pepperoni
This place never has their pizza special of the day available for immediate purchase on walk in. I confronted management about this about a year ago, and they changed, for a little while. From then on, I started calling in advance to ensure they had pizza to buy when I went to their pizza place, where they never had any pizza to sell, once again. I stopped in tonight to buy the special of the day, and again, no pizza. The only person who kept me in the place and as a customer was Jocelyn. She was very kind and made the pizza, right away. Either make pizza, or pay Jocelyn more to keep your customers because this is a disgrace.
This pizza place was a bit weird I walked in and placed an order for a large pizza to go, and while waiting they were playing r&b genre songs that were extremely graphic and explicit, I was the only one their on Tuesday 1/16 at 2pm, and the pizza was ok
Pizza is average. Delivery times are not accurate and unpredictable. Order from somewhere else if you need a specific time,
Angelica B. had a very bad attitude. I work at a restaurant and I'm never rude to the guests! The pizza tasted good but the service was bad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Last time I went, it was roughly 1 pm, they didn't have any pizza's ready. Nowadays, the pizzas are doughy and undone. Wouldn't really recommend, has gone down hill.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Called to place an order for delivery workers didn't know the menu poor
Service: 1
This has always been my go to spot for several years when I want a quick slice, however lately I feel like the attention to quality on the slices has gone downhill. I never know if I am going to get a slice that is fresh, or looks like it’s been sitting out for hours. Half the time the pieces are overcooked and burnt, or they are dry and old. Please—if you overcook a pizza, don’t serve it. If it’s been sitting out for too long and is completely dried out and cold, don’t serve it. I’ve been going to slice factory instead now, only because I don’t get dry old pizza over there. Please go back to the quality we all love so I don’t have to order elsewhere :(
Food: 2
SECOND UPDATE: they reached out to me and I spoke with Lawrence. He was really thoughtful and receptive of what happened and wanted to make things right. I really appreciate that. I will be back for my favorite pizza place. Thanks for your help Lawrence!UPDATE: i called back and emily said the GM gave permission to no longer service me. What kind of business is this place? Rude, messes the order up, offers 10%? There are 100s of pizza places in the area and I always choose this place. But that will most likely change unless someone is willing to make it right. I didn’t even want my money back, all I wanted was them to deliver the correct pizza at no charge. I do not think that is an unreasonable ask. I do not eat sausage, but what if I were someone who is either allergic or based on religion or beliefs that I do not eat meat. Just terrible service overall. I do not try to be rude because i worked in the service industry but good lord this has to be the worst service I have ever gone through. Really hope they try and make things right.I have been coming to this place since it was di nicos. Im not sure what happened but it was an excellent place. However now it is awful. Sarah who now works in corporate was amazing to deal with, even if something got messed up but now shes in corporate. If she can see this, please reach out to me.Anyways, i ordered a pizza for delivery. The last few times they have messed something up. I ordered a cheese pizza and got a sausage. Called the store and spoke with the manager Emily. She was extremely rude and before we even conversed her offer was to refund me 10%? For something I dont want and am not going to eat. She said no she’s canceling the order to which i said fine cancel this one and refund and I will pay for the correct one. She said okay and then hung up. Extremely unprofessional. Literally been a lifelong customer and go at least 1-2x a week. Unbelievable. I would like to get my pizza. This is absolutely absurd. Terrible service. Really sad. I hope they are willing to make this right.
Food: 5
Service: 5
had a pizza delivered last night that I never ordered (prank) - no one ordered it and I didn't accept it. so who is paying for it?? you are!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great slice of pizza! Only problem is the location, downtown Lagrange, can be really busy and full of rather snobbish kids but nothing you can do about that. Highly
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great price for a quick slice of pizza in a great area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nothing to write home about; we were just looking for a quick bite to eat. I wish we were told that 1 slice = 1/4 of the pie, aka 2 slices. 1 slice or 1/8 of the pie is more than sufficient cuz it’s a very thick crust. It’s a lot of food for $5.99 so it is a deal, but not a very tasty one. The young lady who took our order was very friendly though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Pizza was hard and cold cheesy garlic bread was just bread with slightly melted cheese also got a buffalo chicken salad now I know what a $16 salad looks like and that was not it no dressing for my salad there was nothing buffalo about the salad just lettuce a few pieces of dry chicken and a few olives fries were hot and soggy I got the fried dough it was more like fried graham crackers with a baby pinch of powdered sugar I won’t be back and I spent $70 I will be calling for a refund
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Unique and delicious. Sauce swings on the sweet side but good
Food: 3