None of the 3 items I ordered on a recent DoorDash order were correct. My 14-inch had everything we ordered except that there were onions on the whole pizza when I ordered it only on half. My husband is allergic to onions. We got a 12-inch cheese pizza instead of the one we ordered which had a different assortment of veggies than the 14 inch. This one was for a caregiver. And the garden salad was missing altogether. This is all on Alfredo’s, not DoorDash. The delivery service had its own issues with a driver who showed up at an unmanned gate and couldn’t speak English for additional directions. All in all, a bad experience. I wish people would stop to read the order instead of winging it.
Food: 1
Harrison B.
Have never been disappointed, pretty standard Chicago style Tavern
Food: 5
Ryan
Last night I went to Alfredo's Pizza in Lake In The Hills. I walked in and immediately noticed that they only have 2 tables now. They converted mostly all of the dining room into a gaming area. I walked up to the counter to order and over the wall I could see into the kitchen and I noticed an old rotating deck oven. This place has a really old Middleby Marshall rotating deck oven. I went with the Gold medal standard sausage pizza. That old oven cooked the pizza perfectly. The edges were crispy and flaky with a good flavor. Crust was very thin with a nice dusting of cornmeal. Even the center pieces held up well. The cheese had a good fresh taste and a nice pull to it. The sauce was a bit of a thicker sauce and on the sweet side. The sausage had just a hint of fennel, but still had a great flavor. The pizza was topped with oregano and other seasonings. Overall a really good pizza and I was pleasantly surprised by this place. If you're in the area stop by and get a pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Leeann Richert
Ordered the stuffed shells. The sauce was burned as well as the shells. The cheese insided the shells was hard not creamy. Paid 20 dollars for a side
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
T K
I was just told Alfredos in LITH was under new management as of last month when I called to let them know that the quality of Italian beef sandwich they are giving customers is foul. It was cold, bone dry (like au jus AT ALL), smelled rancid and was a greyish color that is hard to portray through photos. And look at all of that fat! The giardiniera was swimming in oil. Like a cup of oil and maybe 5 pieces of vegetables. Barely any sauce on pasta and they apparently can no longer substitute a different sauce with their pasta. I usually ask for alfredo instead of marinara on the tortellini and I was told new management does not allow that anymore. Not the end of the world but still annoying for those with allergies/sensitivities.Totally bummed at how bad this place is now.
Food: 1
Service: 1
MARY GENTILE
Ordered pizza for family gathering .I asked about the special and was given it plus extra!! Generous and thoughtful! I am glad they are still here!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Chicago Hot Dog Sandwich, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Italian Beef Sandwich, Hamburger, Cheese Fries, Chicken Parmigiana
Mara Ruiz
Order first time from Alfredo’s it was a great experience. Pizza taste great!! Thank you!!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Tyler Roray
Took my order… told me 45 min, and never showed up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Roxanne Heiliger
Today was the first time we had ordered from Afredo's. What a pleasant surprise we got! The pizza was GREAT!! Everyone was friendly. We will definitely be going back for more!!!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pat Savage
Pizza used to be better than recent deliveries. Took a while to get it delivered definitely was not hot Luke warm at best.
Jalapeños Poppers were awesome (Thanks Autumn). The pizza was really good baked to perfection and tasteful.Bleu Cheese sauce could have been better for the wings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Slay
Ordered a meatball sandwich a cheezy beef and a small pizza for pickup.When I got home I found my Italian beef sandwich very skimpy on the beef. It was the first time I ever had a beef where I ended up with a quarter of the bread left over.If you want a beef go to the Beef Shack or Goodfellas beef on 47Sure prices have gone up but for the same price and a loaded beef go to Beef Shack
Edward U.
I have 20+ in the industry as an executive chef, sous, and other titles I can't spell. I'm a chef ; not an English teacher. I have had nothing but great experiences with these guys. ( sorry to those who don't identify as guys, porpoises, the non binary...I have MAD LOVE for you all) Price point-fantastic Spaghetti meatballs; quite possibly life changing That said; many menu items have not found their way to my lower intestines. Spaghetti meatballs people Yeah! Kick a** job
Hank Klich
Ordered a meatball sandwich a cheezy beef and a small pizza for pickup.When I got home I found my Italian beef sandwich very skimpy on the beef. It was the first time I ever had a beef where I ended up with a quarter of the bread left over.If you want a beef go to the Beef Shack or Goodfellas beef on 47Sure prices have gone up but for the same price and a loaded beef go to Beef Shack
ツKaylaツ
Ordered a meatball sandwich a cheezy beef and a small pizza for pickup.When I got home I found my Italian beef sandwich very skimpy on the beef. It was the first time I ever had a beef where I ended up with a quarter of the bread left over.If you want a beef go to the Beef Shack or Goodfellas beef on 47Sure prices have gone up but for the same price and a loaded beef go to Beef Shack
None of the 3 items I ordered on a recent DoorDash order were correct. My 14-inch had everything we ordered except that there were onions on the whole pizza when I ordered it only on half. My husband is allergic to onions. We got a 12-inch cheese pizza instead of the one we ordered which had a different assortment of veggies than the 14 inch. This one was for a caregiver. And the garden salad was missing altogether. This is all on Alfredo’s, not DoorDash. The delivery service had its own issues with a driver who showed up at an unmanned gate and couldn’t speak English for additional directions. All in all, a bad experience. I wish people would stop to read the order instead of winging it.
Food: 1
Have never been disappointed, pretty standard Chicago style Tavern
Food: 5
Last night I went to Alfredo's Pizza in Lake In The Hills. I walked in and immediately noticed that they only have 2 tables now. They converted mostly all of the dining room into a gaming area. I walked up to the counter to order and over the wall I could see into the kitchen and I noticed an old rotating deck oven. This place has a really old Middleby Marshall rotating deck oven. I went with the Gold medal standard sausage pizza. That old oven cooked the pizza perfectly. The edges were crispy and flaky with a good flavor. Crust was very thin with a nice dusting of cornmeal. Even the center pieces held up well. The cheese had a good fresh taste and a nice pull to it. The sauce was a bit of a thicker sauce and on the sweet side. The sausage had just a hint of fennel, but still had a great flavor. The pizza was topped with oregano and other seasonings. Overall a really good pizza and I was pleasantly surprised by this place. If you're in the area stop by and get a pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Ordered the stuffed shells. The sauce was burned as well as the shells. The cheese insided the shells was hard not creamy. Paid 20 dollars for a side
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
I was just told Alfredos in LITH was under new management as of last month when I called to let them know that the quality of Italian beef sandwich they are giving customers is foul. It was cold, bone dry (like au jus AT ALL), smelled rancid and was a greyish color that is hard to portray through photos. And look at all of that fat! The giardiniera was swimming in oil. Like a cup of oil and maybe 5 pieces of vegetables. Barely any sauce on pasta and they apparently can no longer substitute a different sauce with their pasta. I usually ask for alfredo instead of marinara on the tortellini and I was told new management does not allow that anymore. Not the end of the world but still annoying for those with allergies/sensitivities.Totally bummed at how bad this place is now.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered pizza for family gathering .I asked about the special and was given it plus extra!! Generous and thoughtful! I am glad they are still here!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Chicago Hot Dog Sandwich, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Italian Beef Sandwich, Hamburger, Cheese Fries, Chicken Parmigiana
Order first time from Alfredo’s it was a great experience. Pizza taste great!! Thank you!!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Took my order… told me 45 min, and never showed up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Today was the first time we had ordered from Afredo's. What a pleasant surprise we got! The pizza was GREAT!! Everyone was friendly. We will definitely be going back for more!!!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza used to be better than recent deliveries. Took a while to get it delivered definitely was not hot Luke warm at best.
Food: 4
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Jalapeños Poppers were awesome (Thanks Autumn). The pizza was really good baked to perfection and tasteful.Bleu Cheese sauce could have been better for the wings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a meatball sandwich a cheezy beef and a small pizza for pickup.When I got home I found my Italian beef sandwich very skimpy on the beef. It was the first time I ever had a beef where I ended up with a quarter of the bread left over.If you want a beef go to the Beef Shack or Goodfellas beef on 47Sure prices have gone up but for the same price and a loaded beef go to Beef Shack
I have 20+ in the industry as an executive chef, sous, and other titles I can't spell. I'm a chef ; not an English teacher. I have had nothing but great experiences with these guys. ( sorry to those who don't identify as guys, porpoises, the non binary...I have MAD LOVE for you all) Price point-fantastic Spaghetti meatballs; quite possibly life changing That said; many menu items have not found their way to my lower intestines. Spaghetti meatballs people Yeah! Kick a** job
Ordered a meatball sandwich a cheezy beef and a small pizza for pickup.When I got home I found my Italian beef sandwich very skimpy on the beef. It was the first time I ever had a beef where I ended up with a quarter of the bread left over.If you want a beef go to the Beef Shack or Goodfellas beef on 47Sure prices have gone up but for the same price and a loaded beef go to Beef Shack
Ordered a meatball sandwich a cheezy beef and a small pizza for pickup.When I got home I found my Italian beef sandwich very skimpy on the beef. It was the first time I ever had a beef where I ended up with a quarter of the bread left over.If you want a beef go to the Beef Shack or Goodfellas beef on 47Sure prices have gone up but for the same price and a loaded beef go to Beef Shack