7 Best Pizza Restaurants in Mchenry

Buddyz Pizzeria Pizza • $
1138 N Green St, McHenry

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Build Your Own Skillet
Butter Crust Pizza Chicago
Biscuits and Gravy
Pepperoni Calzone
Hand Tossed Pizza
Chicago Fire Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
BBQ Flavor Wings
Toasted Ravioli
Breakfast Pizza

“I love Buddyz, always have, but last night we had a little birthday party for my mom in the back room and not only was the food the delicious as usual, and the room perfect for the occasion, they let us bring in a little entertainment (Elvis is in the building!) but it was the service tha was a knock out! Our servers were so attentive, so much fun, so friendly, they added that cherry on the cake that made the evening perfect! Thanks again Buddyz, you guys are the best!!Kid-friendliness: We had a ton of little ones and they had a blast and the servers actually brought them out pizza dough to play with - so cool!“

4.4 Superb90 Reviews
Kief's Reef Pizza • $
3505 S Wright Rd, McHenry

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Parmesan Wings and Fries with Irish Coffee
School of Lake Perch Sandwich
Hand Battered Jumbo Shrimp
Chix Wings and Onion Rings
Pizza with Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic and Parmesan Wings
Soft Pretzel with Cheese
Pepperoni Bacon Mushroom
Mobby Dick Fish Sandwich
All You Can Eat Crab Legs

“Kiefs reef is a fun clean and friendly establishment. My family and I often come here and are treated like family. The service is amazing the food is great and the atmosphere is very inviting. The waitresses and staff are wonderful. Couldnt ask for a better home town bar and restaurant.“

4.4 Superb86 Reviews
Antioch Pizza Shop - McHenry, IL Pizza • $$
514 State Rte 31, McHenry

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheese Fries
Thin Crust
Chicago
Cannoli

“Antioch pizza shop has the best pizza around, it’s consistently delicious and I think fairly priced compared to some others. What really prompted me to write a review though was tonight our pizza wasn’t ready on time (had 10 mins to go), I didn’t mind because these things happen. So I went to give her my credit card and the cashier told me that the pizzas were free because of the wait! I was so shocked (and super happy hah). Really excellent customer service, thank you all so much!“

4.2 Good53 Reviews
Jimano's Pizzeria Pizza • $
366 Bank Dr, McHenry

Customers` Favorites

Fried Mushrooms with Ranch
Chicken Bacon Caesar Salad
Pepperoni Deluxe 10
Cinnamon Sticks
Steak-Cut Fries
Cinnamon Stix
Loaded Fries
Supreme Salad
Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Wings

“This restaurant participates in the 'Too Good to Go' program where good food that has not been sold is offered at a fraction of the retail cost. We had never been there, but when we were able to get a surprise bag of pizza for $4, we decided to give it a try. We got to try 3 different kinds of pizza, and it was all great! This is a wonderful way to keep food from the landfill. We will definitely be visiting this restaurant again.“

4.2 Good43 Reviews
Jexal's Pizza & Wing-Zeria Pizza • $
1260 N Green St, McHenry

Customers` Favorites

Detroit-Style Pizza
Traditional Wings
Thin Crust Pizza
Chicken Wings
Beer Nuggets
Detroit Pizza
Bruschetta
Burger
Sauce
Salad

“I have driven by this place more than a few times and never really gave it a second notice. Mainly because the sign and building art are confusing during the day. Maybe at night it lights up like a Christmas tree and easier to understand.What is a Zeria? I pondered on that each time I drove by. Is it some type of specialty type of chicken wing from the hidden fields of Zeria? Even after eating there and Googling the word, it remains a chicken wing folk lore mystery..On to the food! This was just a quick pop in for a snack, and we ordered the Beer Nuggets and a basket of 10 wings with the hottest and not so hottest sauces. Both were good quality and tasty as well.Speaking from experience, since I often make my own wings for the family, including having bowls of different sauces as I take orders from the kids and flip the wings to coat them for ech of their orders, these wings had the crispiness I desire and the sauces to add the zing to my taste buds.The Beer Nuggets were unexpected in how puffy and tasty they were. I make my own breads, of which I have been experimenting with doughs for many years. It is hard to pinpoint what the dough was. It was like the puffiness of a Hawaiin Roll and the softness of a pizza dough. The flavor was on point, not as much as beer flavor, but buttery with little colorful herbs on the exterior. I think the name would indicate they go well with a beer.To sum it all up, I would go back and expound upon the menu options to see how the other food compares to what we already tried. Before I forget, the service was on-point, polite, and friendly.“

3.8 Good80 Reviews
Salerno's Pizzeria & R. Bar Pizza • $
621 Ridgeview Dr, McHenry

Customers` Favorites

Italian Beef and Giardiniera Pizza
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
1 2 Price Cheese Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Chopped Salad
Caprese Salad
Traditional
Ravioli
Fried

“The service was slow but not due to the workers. More due to management not properly staffing the establishment. The bartender/waitress deserved some large tips for handling the plus 30 people in there today. I just went in to pick up three pizzas and had to patiently wait to be served. But she had an almost full bar and another 15 people at tables. Food was good but it seems management is lacking.“

3.8 Good52 Reviews
Rosati's Pizza Pizza • $
4802 W Elm St, McHenry

“This pizza is great! The pizza is always fresh. Delivery is super fast and still HOT upon arrival, and drivers are always friendly. Have not eaten in yet, but I hear it's a great atmosphere and a good spot to grab a bite. I also completed a survey after delivery at one point and mentioned paying for and getting an additional topping on the pizza that wasn't asked for, I received an email the same day from manager apologizing, that is great customer service right there! This has definitely become our go-to spot for pizza!“

3.5 Good47 Reviews
Loading...
map Map