Excellent complete dining experience. The food choices are great. The atmosphere is very airy and refreshing. The staff was on point. Dined on Mother's day. My wife had the jambalaya. She was very pleased. Spicy, but not overwhelming. I had crab stuffed shrimp & braised short ribs. The stuffed shrimp was delicious. Braised short ribs were tender and perfect. Our server was very attentive and catered to everything needed.The only thing I would suggest is a small change in the music selection. Not a major issue at all. Music was classic but maybe mix it up with a soft jazz perhaps. Other than that, absolutely an excellent experience and would recommend.Parking: At this time (5/15/24), street construction is ongoing and street parking would be challenging.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood, Crab Stuffed Shrimp & Braised Short Rib
Gaenor Harris-obrien
Gracious, handsome servers. Welcoming staff. Good food...<< that was last year. This year I looked forward to a rum and Coke... no Coke, pepsi (watered down Coke) in an Old Fashioned glass, you know the short glass... filled with ice, three swallows? of a very weak rum/coke...make it lower case... guess how much...$14 USD.I was ad at my bank when I came in there but now I m mad at C.35 as well.If you need a drink it s gonna cost ya.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
John Collura
Excellent dinner
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood
Gerda Kugaudaite
Service was fantastic. Husband and I ordered the crab stuffed shrimp with Brussels sprouts and a lobster roll. The shrimp tasted like dirt, and the lobster roll tasted like straight celery. The Brussel sprouts were good, but not good enough for us to return. Many better places in Naperville to dine.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Cynthia Pirami
A wonderful dinner to celebrate our 48th anniversary. The food was fabulous, our server Trey, was very good. The only thing that was negative was, because of the open kitchen, they were talking very loud, which was distracting. All in all a good experience, on an important day for us.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish, Steak, Seafood
Papa'sWife jo
The food was good, maybe a little skimpy, but good. They're were 6 off us and we all enjoyed what we ate
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
George Holscher
Great seafood, great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went here for a seafood treat and left disappointed. I ordered fried calamari and other was just ok, wasn't any better than an average spot. For entrée, I chose catch 35 mixed grill. It was cooked well but it was cold. The portions were good size. I wouldn't be going back.
RonaldC
Have not been to catch 35 for some time, been Hugos and Eddie Merlot more often. Services was fine slight mistake on delivering whipped Potatoes vs. Cilantro rice, but it was corrected: Spouse had and enjoyed lobster tails and brussel sprouts, very tasty.. Appetizer was scallops also quite good. However seared tuna steak, was not good. Was not cooked as ordered, med rare +, had the cut been good I could have enjoyed, but just not a good fish and not cooked as I would have liked. The whipped potatoes and cilantro rice, just average at best. Desert was awesome some sort of toffee date pudding cake. Overall my meal just not that good, wife enjoyed her meal, apps and drinks good and desert tasty.
We came here after walking out of Gordon Ramsay's restaurant in downtown Naperville for my boyfriend's birthday. We told our server how we came to be there at that time and she was absolutely incredible. But I see everyone in the restaurant we must have had four different people at our table at one time or another and it wasn't only us. It was all of the surrounding tables so their customer service is absolutely top-notch. The food was incredible had the stuffed shrimp and shrimp and scallop risotto which were absolutely incredible. Moscato was awesome. And they even brought out a creme brulee for my boyfriend's birthday. I would choose this place over Gordon Ramsay's any day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rotana
We celebrated my husband's birthday and they made it a wonderful night. The food was delicious. Service was great. They let us cut our own cake. My MIL is vegetarian and they were able to accommodate her dining restrictions. Overall just a great night.
Peter Matousek
Fresh, quiet, good service, unique
Went for lunch and had a most enjoyable experience. Service was terrific and the food was delicious. I had the lobster roll, which was fantastic and my sister had Caesar salad with salmon which she loved. Will return again for dinner.
Made a reservation for 6:30 pm, arrived at 6:30 and was made to wait until 7:00 pm for Table ! This is not good sign, but the restaurant was very, very busy, too busy ! Ordered soup and salad to start, salad was drowned in dressing, will order dressing on the side in future. Then an unordered chocolate lava cake arrived !!! Main course, the chilean sea bass was good, but is usually better. We then ordered a chocolate lava cake which took forever to arrive !!!!!! We should have kept the one that arrived before the main course. Very chaotic dinner. Was constantly having to ask for the right silverware and top up water glass. I feel that the restaurant had more diner's than they could handle comfortably, Its clear that money was more important than diners experience Saturday night. Pity, as usually this restaurant is one of my favourites in Naperville. Disappointed. Go on a quiet night, this experience was not good value !!! ?
This place is like Red Lobster on crack
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent complete dining experience. The food choices are great. The atmosphere is very airy and refreshing. The staff was on point. Dined on Mother's day. My wife had the jambalaya. She was very pleased. Spicy, but not overwhelming. I had crab stuffed shrimp & braised short ribs. The stuffed shrimp was delicious. Braised short ribs were tender and perfect. Our server was very attentive and catered to everything needed.The only thing I would suggest is a small change in the music selection. Not a major issue at all. Music was classic but maybe mix it up with a soft jazz perhaps. Other than that, absolutely an excellent experience and would recommend.Parking: At this time (5/15/24), street construction is ongoing and street parking would be challenging.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood, Crab Stuffed Shrimp & Braised Short Rib
Gracious, handsome servers. Welcoming staff. Good food...<< that was last year. This year I looked forward to a rum and Coke... no Coke, pepsi (watered down Coke) in an Old Fashioned glass, you know the short glass... filled with ice, three swallows? of a very weak rum/coke...make it lower case... guess how much...$14 USD.I was ad at my bank when I came in there but now I m mad at C.35 as well.If you need a drink it s gonna cost ya.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Excellent dinner
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood
Service was fantastic. Husband and I ordered the crab stuffed shrimp with Brussels sprouts and a lobster roll. The shrimp tasted like dirt, and the lobster roll tasted like straight celery. The Brussel sprouts were good, but not good enough for us to return. Many better places in Naperville to dine.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
A wonderful dinner to celebrate our 48th anniversary. The food was fabulous, our server Trey, was very good. The only thing that was negative was, because of the open kitchen, they were talking very loud, which was distracting. All in all a good experience, on an important day for us.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish, Steak, Seafood
The food was good, maybe a little skimpy, but good. They're were 6 off us and we all enjoyed what we ate
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great seafood, great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went here for a seafood treat and left disappointed. I ordered fried calamari and other was just ok, wasn't any better than an average spot. For entrée, I chose catch 35 mixed grill. It was cooked well but it was cold. The portions were good size. I wouldn't be going back.
Have not been to catch 35 for some time, been Hugos and Eddie Merlot more often. Services was fine slight mistake on delivering whipped Potatoes vs. Cilantro rice, but it was corrected: Spouse had and enjoyed lobster tails and brussel sprouts, very tasty.. Appetizer was scallops also quite good. However seared tuna steak, was not good. Was not cooked as ordered, med rare +, had the cut been good I could have enjoyed, but just not a good fish and not cooked as I would have liked. The whipped potatoes and cilantro rice, just average at best. Desert was awesome some sort of toffee date pudding cake. Overall my meal just not that good, wife enjoyed her meal, apps and drinks good and desert tasty.
Restaurantji Recommends
We came here after walking out of Gordon Ramsay's restaurant in downtown Naperville for my boyfriend's birthday. We told our server how we came to be there at that time and she was absolutely incredible. But I see everyone in the restaurant we must have had four different people at our table at one time or another and it wasn't only us. It was all of the surrounding tables so their customer service is absolutely top-notch. The food was incredible had the stuffed shrimp and shrimp and scallop risotto which were absolutely incredible. Moscato was awesome. And they even brought out a creme brulee for my boyfriend's birthday. I would choose this place over Gordon Ramsay's any day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We celebrated my husband's birthday and they made it a wonderful night. The food was delicious. Service was great. They let us cut our own cake. My MIL is vegetarian and they were able to accommodate her dining restrictions. Overall just a great night.
Fresh, quiet, good service, unique
Went for lunch and had a most enjoyable experience. Service was terrific and the food was delicious. I had the lobster roll, which was fantastic and my sister had Caesar salad with salmon which she loved. Will return again for dinner.
Made a reservation for 6:30 pm, arrived at 6:30 and was made to wait until 7:00 pm for Table ! This is not good sign, but the restaurant was very, very busy, too busy ! Ordered soup and salad to start, salad was drowned in dressing, will order dressing on the side in future. Then an unordered chocolate lava cake arrived !!! Main course, the chilean sea bass was good, but is usually better. We then ordered a chocolate lava cake which took forever to arrive !!!!!! We should have kept the one that arrived before the main course. Very chaotic dinner. Was constantly having to ask for the right silverware and top up water glass. I feel that the restaurant had more diner's than they could handle comfortably, Its clear that money was more important than diners experience Saturday night. Pity, as usually this restaurant is one of my favourites in Naperville. Disappointed. Go on a quiet night, this experience was not good value !!! ?