Capones Hideout

200 W Illinois St, New Berlin
(217) 488-6121

Recent Reviews

Darlene Agena-Hombaker

What a gem to find! Had a fabulous ribeye dinner, with baked potato, house salad (don't miss out on the creamy Italian salad dressing), and dinner roll. The ribeye was cooked perfectly at medium rare! The mushroom appetizer with horseradish-ranch dip was great, but even better, the perfect Bloody Mary. I'll definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ribeye Steak Entree, Capone's House Salad

John Dundon

It had been several years since we've tried them so I thought they were due for another try and I'm really glad I did. Ordering pizza to go at 5pm on Friday night I expected them to be busy and they were. Had to wait several minutes on hold to place my order, I could hear her dealing with customers in person while on hold, but she got back to me when she could and I was told 35 minutes and it would be ready.I live really close, less than a block, so I did my best and gave them 25 minutes before I went to pickup. I was third in line for pickup but she was pretty efficient and checking the time it was still under half an hour but it was fresh and ready to go.I like thin crust, which they offer, but I don't like it crunchy so I'm used to be disappointed when I do try thin crust. I was extremely happy to not be disappointed but instead I had a thin crust pizza that wasn't hard like a cracker but baked to delicately toasted perfection.They have allot of good looking options for specialty pizzas and the cheese sticks were pretty good too. This was like a different place from my previous experiences, fast, friendly, and really good. I can't think of any pizza in Springfield or Jacksonville that I'd rather have

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christine M.

Love the pizza's!! Yum! They get busy during the dinner rush! Might need to wait a few minutes when calling in an order. The wait is worth it!

Dale Workman

Small town flare with great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cindy Crow

This place is great! Made reservations so no wait. Food was amazing! Server went above and beyond to make up for the short-staffed kitchen. We had to wait a bit but our meal was well worth it. We'll be back!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

kendy g.

Always wonderful food and drinks. The scallops are melt in your mouth. There pasta dishes are all delicious

Jessica Vice

We went here for my fiances work Christmas party, it's attached to a gas station neither of us had ever been there before so we were beyond confused when GPS took us to the gas station. Haha. The food was very good. The staff were all very nice. They unfortunately were short handed but what place is actually fully staffed right now? We will definitely be returning.Parking: Parking in the parking lot and around the restaurant/gas station on the roadWheelchair accessibility: One level

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 1 1 2 Rib Eye Steak and Green Beans, Fried Ravioli, Cut Ribeye, Ribeye Steak Entree, Toasted Ravioli

Alyssa T.

Do they have desserts? Apparently my review needs at least 85 characters so I'll say I'm going there tonight just curious abt desserts.

Dave C.

I'll be back as the waitress told me 20 years and running that I have been clueless of this place which is a hidden gem! I'm looking forward to my next visit ordering pasta as the regulars are eating it from table to table while I was waiting for my ribeye last night. Important to have patience as one other place quote says - good food takes time! Another bad thing. My phone bar was one tick then finally left the town boom back to 4 bars! No internet service - if you want to wait for your meal. Better download your favorite phone game as I saw the next table playing their game - husband and wife. Sad. Please do not gossip talking while waiting. Ha. I didn't hear but my son told me about it -umm Be happy!

Mary Post

Large portions. Pricing is not too bad either. Parking can be tricking but accessible. Kid friendly. Darkened lightening for relaxed atmosphere. Wheelchair accessible. Friendly service. If it is busy, be patient, they do a great job, there were just a lot of folks there enjoying their time together.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dave Walters

AWESOMELY delicious food. Servers were very busy. Our party of 7 waited 2 hours after we ordered for the food to be served...but it was well worth the wait. Parking is also a little bit of a hassle.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Jayson Coble

Buyer beware. I've not had worse service at a sit down restaurant ever in my life until tonight. 6 people in our party. 5 had dinner. I never was served mine...even after being there for 90 minutes. Even the other staff couldn't locate our waitress when asked. Then when I asked for the check, no suprise it wasn't split correctly. Drinks stayed empty more than once. Even had to ask for silverware. The waitress even said the salads weren't made correctly when she brought them to the table. Very poor.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Janice Vaughn

Capone's Hideout has a cool atmosphere and amazing food!! The steaks are truly the BEST I have ever tasted!! Definitely worth the trip!! Everything is home-made and I look forward to trying their

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ribeye Steak Entree

Dwayne Terry

Had problems locating entrance on my first visit. Excellent food for all occasions.Kid-friendliness: This is a family friendly venue

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tim D.

Not the fanciest place ever but the food was good. I had Ribeye & Shrimp. House salad was also delicious.

Load More