“We finally made it over from Peru to try and we were not disappointed! We ordered the garlic nuggets- the best ones we have had in the area. We also had boneless hot wings, chicken strips, old barrel pizza, and crab rangoon pizza. Everything was absolutely delicious. Best and most unique variety of specialty pizzas in the area, too. The chicken in the wings and strips was extremely tender and juicy and had a perfect coating. We will absolutely be back again to keep trying more off the menu. The only thing that could improve is if you move to Peru ?“
“The people working at this caseys are incredibly nice. I passed through this gas station on my way home to Iowa and I accidentally forgot my phone there. The people at this caseys were able to send it back to me in a few days in the same condition. Very trustful and nice people!“
“Not gonna lie they messed up my order but only the wings, the pizza was professionally made definitely good! normally I wouldn’t call but the wings were the wrong flavor which is fine but they were cold. But shout out to the manager on duty tonight for making it right by sending out another order and having a positive attitude the whole time I hate having to reorder stuff but definitely made it feel like they weren’t gonna spit in my food lol.“
“Ordered pizza….amazing as always to say the least. Anyway, delivery boy, delivered to Tiskilwa tonight about 5:15pm. My dumb ciusin hands him a $26 tio (story for another day). Now this delivery boy is young…. Teenager…. Comes back a couple minutes later beating on the window, wide eyed…. “Do you guys realize you have me a $26 tip??” Instantly I was so impressed by his honesty. You don’t see that much in young kids nowadays. Kudos to his mom, dad, whoever raised this young man…. And kudos to pizza cellar for not only have great pizza, but great staff. I never do reviews, but this young man could not go without recognition. You’re a good person kid!! Keep it up.“
“I HAD THE BEST VIST EVER!!! i've been coming here since i was a child, and Savannah Hollars gave us the best service! she sat us at a table with the "best ambiance" and she made us feel so welcome. she also took the pizza out of the oven for the fist time and i'm so proud! i love her so much, the feeling is my as well!“