Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop - Tinley Park

7903 W 171st St, Tinley Park
(708) 444-1800

Recent Reviews

Jenny Baier

Great ice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sundae

Chassidy Gonzales

Smells like ice cream as soon as you walk in! Tons of flavors and non dairy options too! Great place to check out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle, Ice Cream Sundae

Mahmoud Zegar

Best ice cream around!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

3D M3NaYeZ

Decided to come here with a friend. Their cookies were delicious. Ended up purchasing a valentine cookie along with a sundae. The sundae consisted of Grasshopper flavored ice cream with gummy bears, hot fudge, and nuts.Aside from the treats and ice cream flavors, I really appreciated the customer service. When I first got the sundae, I noticed the gummy bears were missing on my sundae. When addressed this, one of the staff members fixed my order and it made my night. I’d come back again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sara Schneider

My kids' favorite place to go for ice cream. Less busy and more parking than the Palos one.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eduardo C.

Yeah, ice cream and cookies are delicious. Service is very good The ambience is nice.

Marta Coleman

If you’re a fan of mint ice cream, the grasshopper ice cream pies are dynamite!! They’re not overly sweet like others can be. I had one for my birthday and it’s been a hit with the whole fam! (The mint chip ice cream is also my favorite).

Food: 5

Audrey Brodie

Generous portions of homemade iced cream. Lots of flavors to choose from and all of the usual offerings, such as sundaes, milkshakes and more! If you like iced cream, this place is a must try!

Megan Kuhl-Horbin

Wow. This place is pretty cool. All hand made ice cream on-site. When we went they had 5 vegan flavors: vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, rocky road, and cinnamon (made with coconut milk). They also have sugar free ice cream! Definitely recommend. And on Fridays they have color changing spoons!!

muzique1960

A beautiful shop with tables for adults and kid-sized tables and chairs! Lots of great flavor choices, including dairy-free ice cream! Fun decor, large windows, and a helpful staff.

M. Dani C

First and last time trying. There were no friendly vibes inside from the staff, and the ordering process was weird. Ice cream was not good at all. I ordered cake batter ice cream and it just tasted like plain vanilla with sprinkless in it. I wouldn't have minded the cake batter flavor tasting like regular vanilla, but the vanilla was bland. I also orderedthe key lime pie flavor but it was was also bad tasting. I ended up throwing it away. Definitely will not return here. I thought I might try this place since they look pretty busy, must be good right? Wrong, I was highly disappointed.

yolanda cardona

I really enjoy this place better than the other location in Palos Heights there is more space and you can at least sit down inside and enjoy your ice cream and the other location you cannot The only complaint I have is that the staff are not too friendly ?

Zman

Best ice cream in the Chicsgo area! Store is very clean. service is great, and there is a very large flavor selection.

Rick Buda

It was not crowded (unusual), service was great. Believe me, their small sundae is plenty good!

kpK5938YO

Staff is super friendly. Lots of in house made ice cream from standard flavors to slightly exotic. Lots of different cones to choose from. Or get it in a cup. Scoops are great sizes. Can't wait to go again

Load More

Plush Horse Ice Cream Shop - Tinley Park

7903 W 171st St, Tinley Park, IL 60477
(708) 444-1800