I've been to other Rosati's and enjoyed everything. Today was not the case. The place a on the dirty side and seem to lack leadership. They didn't have drinks that were advertised. We just ordered an appetizer (that was good) and left. Ill try Rosati's again, just not this location.
I'm editing this review as I didn't like how it rubbed me when I read it later. I picked up a pizza my mother had ordered. She was charged an 8 dollar tip that she didn't intend but that was likely her mistake. She was also charged a convenience fee for carrying out which is something that seems to be catching on and I take great issue with. Haven't consumers been nickeled and dimed enough? The restaurant got my review and offered a refund but my Mom has almost certainly forgotten about it by now so I won't bother. The man who handed me the pizza was friendly and the pie, as expected, was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Beef Sandwich with Mozzarella Cheese Auju Sauce Mild Peppers on Side French Fries Side, Stuffed Pizza, Italian Beef
jay corley
Always look forward to my wife and I getting a lunch here. She gets the “Chief” Italian beef, I’ll get a thin crust pizza. Both amazing. Staff is courteous and polite. If you haven’t tried Rosati’s, do it!
Dustin Joiner
Quick, friendly and well-sized portions. Have always had a good experience with Rosati's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edward
I'm Italian-American, born and raised in Brooklyn, NY, so I'm very picky about restaurant Italian food. Rosati's makes some good food. I enjoyed their calzone and the meatball sub. The meatballs surprised me, being quite tasty. Also had the pistachio cannoli. Excellent. I'd have any of these items again. What disappointed me was the zeppole. Nothing like the zeppole I carried around in a brown paper bag at the San Gennaro Feasts in Little Italy. Half of them were much too chewy, displeasingly chewy. The other half were hollow. Squeeze them and your finger made a hole into it with nothing there. Oh, there were plenty of them which excited me -- until I tried eating them. Sadly, most were trashed.Also off-putting was the $6.00 delivery charge.
Food: 4
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Cannoli
Amy Kinzer
The wings were not great, but always love the pizza!!
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Pepperoni Pizza
Angelica
This place is a hit or miss. The big slice that you can get for $5 is not really ever hot. If you order the “giant” wings, don’t. They’re quite small and the Parmesan sauce (if you get that sauce on the wings) flavorless. It’s very faint and it barely covers up the wing fully. This is a place you go if you’re really hard up on cash and need a quick bite. I wouldn’t recommend bringing a family or friends there. The staff always seem dead. I do enjoy the cookies they sell. I get the sugar cookies. Unfortunately, recently went in there and it tasted sorta old. This is a hit or miss restaurant. Don’t take any chances if you wanted to eat here regularly.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Natalie B
The sausage has a strange aftertaste but some in the group liked it, and the crust was pretty good. However, the sauce is flavorless and watery, and the overall taste is reminiscent of school lunches. The cheese is quality, and the service was good. Time was great and price not too shabby (25 for 18 inches). But the pizza itself leaves a lot to be desired. Not like the Chicago pizza I know.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
Steve Heimburger
One of the best Calzones I've ever had. The beer wasn't as cold as it could be but it's not a bar. Will definitely be back.
Ordered pizzas for carry out after seeing a tongue-in-cheek billboard in town about a cross-town pizzeria. Clever advertising brought us in and we were pleasantly surprised! Will definitely order from Rosati’s again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer JJS PIZZARIA & SUGAR MOUNTAIN
ITALIAN BEEF WITH MOZZARELLA CHEESE FRIES. YUMMY YUMMY THE BEST
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nick Moon
Great, filling pizza! Prices are good for the quality received.
Food: 5
Drew Tschirki
We’ve been a few times, once for my bday bc I love deep dish pizza, and once to try it again. The pizza is very tasty, and cheesy. The regular thin style pizza was also very good. The second time we went I got some of the jumbo slices and my kid got some pasta. She loved the pasta though it’s truly not anything to rave about, and the jumbo slices are as you’d expect ready to eat pizza to be: tasty enough, but not oven fresh. Which is fine but I won’t get it again; I’ll order fresh and wait instead.
Sohyeon Kim
Friendly staff, picked up right on time, and good taste.
I've been to other Rosati's and enjoyed everything. Today was not the case. The place a on the dirty side and seem to lack leadership. They didn't have drinks that were advertised. We just ordered an appetizer (that was good) and left. Ill try Rosati's again, just not this location.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Great food, clean, but staff was rude.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Wings, Pepperoni Pizza
I'm editing this review as I didn't like how it rubbed me when I read it later. I picked up a pizza my mother had ordered. She was charged an 8 dollar tip that she didn't intend but that was likely her mistake. She was also charged a convenience fee for carrying out which is something that seems to be catching on and I take great issue with. Haven't consumers been nickeled and dimed enough? The restaurant got my review and offered a refund but my Mom has almost certainly forgotten about it by now so I won't bother. The man who handed me the pizza was friendly and the pie, as expected, was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Beef Sandwich with Mozzarella Cheese Auju Sauce Mild Peppers on Side French Fries Side, Stuffed Pizza, Italian Beef
Always look forward to my wife and I getting a lunch here. She gets the “Chief” Italian beef, I’ll get a thin crust pizza. Both amazing. Staff is courteous and polite. If you haven’t tried Rosati’s, do it!
Quick, friendly and well-sized portions. Have always had a good experience with Rosati's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm Italian-American, born and raised in Brooklyn, NY, so I'm very picky about restaurant Italian food. Rosati's makes some good food. I enjoyed their calzone and the meatball sub. The meatballs surprised me, being quite tasty. Also had the pistachio cannoli. Excellent. I'd have any of these items again. What disappointed me was the zeppole. Nothing like the zeppole I carried around in a brown paper bag at the San Gennaro Feasts in Little Italy. Half of them were much too chewy, displeasingly chewy. The other half were hollow. Squeeze them and your finger made a hole into it with nothing there. Oh, there were plenty of them which excited me -- until I tried eating them. Sadly, most were trashed.Also off-putting was the $6.00 delivery charge.
Food: 4
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Cannoli
The wings were not great, but always love the pizza!!
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Pepperoni Pizza
This place is a hit or miss. The big slice that you can get for $5 is not really ever hot. If you order the “giant” wings, don’t. They’re quite small and the Parmesan sauce (if you get that sauce on the wings) flavorless. It’s very faint and it barely covers up the wing fully. This is a place you go if you’re really hard up on cash and need a quick bite. I wouldn’t recommend bringing a family or friends there. The staff always seem dead. I do enjoy the cookies they sell. I get the sugar cookies. Unfortunately, recently went in there and it tasted sorta old. This is a hit or miss restaurant. Don’t take any chances if you wanted to eat here regularly.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
The sausage has a strange aftertaste but some in the group liked it, and the crust was pretty good. However, the sauce is flavorless and watery, and the overall taste is reminiscent of school lunches. The cheese is quality, and the service was good. Time was great and price not too shabby (25 for 18 inches). But the pizza itself leaves a lot to be desired. Not like the Chicago pizza I know.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
One of the best Calzones I've ever had. The beer wasn't as cold as it could be but it's not a bar. Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered pizzas for carry out after seeing a tongue-in-cheek billboard in town about a cross-town pizzeria. Clever advertising brought us in and we were pleasantly surprised! Will definitely order from Rosati’s again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
ITALIAN BEEF WITH MOZZARELLA CHEESE FRIES. YUMMY YUMMY THE BEST
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great, filling pizza! Prices are good for the quality received.
Food: 5
We’ve been a few times, once for my bday bc I love deep dish pizza, and once to try it again. The pizza is very tasty, and cheesy. The regular thin style pizza was also very good. The second time we went I got some of the jumbo slices and my kid got some pasta. She loved the pasta though it’s truly not anything to rave about, and the jumbo slices are as you’d expect ready to eat pizza to be: tasty enough, but not oven fresh. Which is fine but I won’t get it again; I’ll order fresh and wait instead.
Friendly staff, picked up right on time, and good taste.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5