Wow. Had gift certificates, I was told I couldn't use them on a "special" order" what? It's a gift certificate given as a gift. Two pepperoni, one cheese pizza. Special? Pizza wasn't that great either. Go somewhere else. We had trouble seeing what was the pepperoni and what was the cheese pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
John H.
Super fast and affordable. My go to is the Sicilian pizza. So good! Their hoagies are good too (and really cheap). Service is always fast. Highly recommend over the chain pizza places. Shop local peeps.
Em La
Pizza is delicious. Wings are an atrocity.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Matthew Becker
The pizza from classic pizza is solid, and it's really nice having a variety of different pizza options here in Batesville as someone who doesn't always want the same flavor profile in pizza. I'm not sure if it's something they always offer, but they do a 2 large 1 toping pizza deal for something like $25. It's a solid deal, though I hadn't seen it until I arrived for pick up. Though the deal is not listed on their website anywhere that I could find, hence why I didn't realize it was offered. If this is a regular thing, I would suggest that it be added to the website somewhere. Otherwise keep up the good work.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Sausage Pizza
Dill “DyLAN” Pickle
The pizza is great and prices are too, spend less here than any chain restaurant and you get homemade quality. I couldn’t recommend them enough, friendly people too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Wrot
Loved it! It's pizza-flavored pizza!I was raised in NJ on the highest quality pizzas from both Philly and true NY style pizzas. This tastes like them!The crust is EXCELLENT. The cheese is absolutely right. The sauce is perfect. A large is actually large (16", true). I can't believe it! Why isn't this the busiest place in Batesville!?If I had one critique, it's that they put the pepperoni under the cheese by default. I'm sure they'd put on top if requested, but even so, it was delicious as the pep oils blended with the sauce and cheese. Nom nom! (And the pepperoni is excellent, btw!)Chicken topping leaves a bit to be desired. Go with pep instead.We were quoted $17.95 for one large, or $24 for 2 (Large traditional crust). I think the single should be less so as to sell more individually, but the 2 for $24 deal is a no brainer (with 1 topping each included).One final note: We indicated we were in a rush when we ordered on the phone. When the pizzas were done, before we even went inside, the manager came out to the parking lot looking for us! "John? Your pizzas are ready." THAT is just awesome.Go buy this pizza and be happier about your life!John
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Benjamin Summers
Don't judge it by the building. The food is great. Had the pizza pie. I recommend the place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
New Horizons
Oh my goodness that was the best pizza ever! Amazing staff,Clean restaurant, amazing hot food. As a full-time RVer we travel and try so many restaurants. And this restaurant is top notch.Parking: So easy to find in Batesville, IndianaWheelchair accessibility: As a Handicapped person the Accessibleility is right on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Sausage Pizza
Mike Kreusch
Great luck finding this placeTucked away behind a golf course in a residential neighborhoodCleanGreat pricesGreat foodGreat serviceFound it heading east from Chicago to watch tennis in CincinnatiWant to make this an annual traditionStop here on the wayGo to Wagner’s Chicken on the way home
Hand made still that what got me really good pizza
Jim Gouvan
Tried the ham and cheese for lunch after I read the review on it being so good. It was a good sandwich.The only issue I had wasn’t food related it was more health and cleanliness. One employee had a long bushy beard that was not covered that was preparing the food. I was worried about getting hair in my food. Another had a white apron on that looked so filthy dirty that the floor had to be cleaner. Although the food was good I doubt a return is going to happen.The staff was very nice and the place was nice but I do notice health standards more than anything when I visit a place. Not the worst I have seen but could improve. Just observations.
SIXEIGHTNATE 6-8N8 (6-8 N8)
Great pizza as always! Bravo!
tom bigbee
The steak hoagies are consistently killer. In fact I'm going to order one for supper today.Parking: Tekulve AveBatesville, IN
Will go
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow. Had gift certificates, I was told I couldn't use them on a "special" order" what? It's a gift certificate given as a gift. Two pepperoni, one cheese pizza. Special? Pizza wasn't that great either. Go somewhere else. We had trouble seeing what was the pepperoni and what was the cheese pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Super fast and affordable. My go to is the Sicilian pizza. So good! Their hoagies are good too (and really cheap). Service is always fast. Highly recommend over the chain pizza places. Shop local peeps.
Pizza is delicious. Wings are an atrocity.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
The pizza from classic pizza is solid, and it's really nice having a variety of different pizza options here in Batesville as someone who doesn't always want the same flavor profile in pizza. I'm not sure if it's something they always offer, but they do a 2 large 1 toping pizza deal for something like $25. It's a solid deal, though I hadn't seen it until I arrived for pick up. Though the deal is not listed on their website anywhere that I could find, hence why I didn't realize it was offered. If this is a regular thing, I would suggest that it be added to the website somewhere. Otherwise keep up the good work.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Sausage Pizza
The pizza is great and prices are too, spend less here than any chain restaurant and you get homemade quality. I couldn’t recommend them enough, friendly people too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved it! It's pizza-flavored pizza!I was raised in NJ on the highest quality pizzas from both Philly and true NY style pizzas. This tastes like them!The crust is EXCELLENT. The cheese is absolutely right. The sauce is perfect. A large is actually large (16", true). I can't believe it! Why isn't this the busiest place in Batesville!?If I had one critique, it's that they put the pepperoni under the cheese by default. I'm sure they'd put on top if requested, but even so, it was delicious as the pep oils blended with the sauce and cheese. Nom nom! (And the pepperoni is excellent, btw!)Chicken topping leaves a bit to be desired. Go with pep instead.We were quoted $17.95 for one large, or $24 for 2 (Large traditional crust). I think the single should be less so as to sell more individually, but the 2 for $24 deal is a no brainer (with 1 topping each included).One final note: We indicated we were in a rush when we ordered on the phone. When the pizzas were done, before we even went inside, the manager came out to the parking lot looking for us! "John? Your pizzas are ready." THAT is just awesome.Go buy this pizza and be happier about your life!John
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Don't judge it by the building. The food is great. Had the pizza pie. I recommend the place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Oh my goodness that was the best pizza ever! Amazing staff,Clean restaurant, amazing hot food. As a full-time RVer we travel and try so many restaurants. And this restaurant is top notch.Parking: So easy to find in Batesville, IndianaWheelchair accessibility: As a Handicapped person the Accessibleility is right on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Sausage Pizza
Great luck finding this placeTucked away behind a golf course in a residential neighborhoodCleanGreat pricesGreat foodGreat serviceFound it heading east from Chicago to watch tennis in CincinnatiWant to make this an annual traditionStop here on the wayGo to Wagner’s Chicken on the way home
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Hand made still that what got me really good pizza
Tried the ham and cheese for lunch after I read the review on it being so good. It was a good sandwich.The only issue I had wasn’t food related it was more health and cleanliness. One employee had a long bushy beard that was not covered that was preparing the food. I was worried about getting hair in my food. Another had a white apron on that looked so filthy dirty that the floor had to be cleaner. Although the food was good I doubt a return is going to happen.The staff was very nice and the place was nice but I do notice health standards more than anything when I visit a place. Not the worst I have seen but could improve. Just observations.
Great pizza as always! Bravo!
The steak hoagies are consistently killer. In fact I'm going to order one for supper today.Parking: Tekulve AveBatesville, IN
Great food like always!