Papa's Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine

1430 N Green St i, Brownsburg
(317) 858-2469

Recent Reviews

Eric Willman

Best stuffed

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Papa

William Purcell

Fabulous!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aric Acius

We ordered take out (no dine in right now) had 2 calzones and pepperoni bread sticks, very good and on time. They even refunded us for an ordering mistake on our part online.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Billy Green

Everything we ordered was phenomenal. Italian sub, fettuccine Alfredo, spaghetti and meatballs, super fresh salad, killer breadsticks and dipping sauces. We will definitely get takeout here again.

Mackenzie Thada

New favorite Brownsburg pizza joint. I’m super picky about crust and this crust was PERFECT! Toppings seemed like better quality than the other local competitors in my opinion. Salad was fresh and carbonara pasta was delicious. We tried the bourbon wings too and the flavor was amazing though the wings were slightly tough/over cooked maybe. Didn’t stop us from devouring them though. We will keep coming back to try more things!

Ben Krieger

We drive by this exit frequently and read the reviews that looked great. So, we dutifully looked up their hours on Google to not stop at a closed place, but much to our surprise, the place is closed despite saying it was open on Google.. information that all businesses control and update in 20 seconds. If would be helpful for potential customers to have a chance to try you out... very frustrating..

Service: 1

Don Cranfill

Great food and a reasonable price. Only reason it’s not a 5 is due to curbside only.

Robby Stumph

You can’t go into the restaurant unfortunately, you have to call in for an order, we were bummed and ended up going elsewhere.

Thomas C.

Great pizza and pasta! We ordered chicken parm also and that meal was delicious. Definitely will order from here again!

C Lunde

Stopped nearby on a roadtrip through town, looking for good food that was from a family run place. This place was EXACTLY what we were looking for. Called ahead our order and parking lot picked up. Had pink sauce penne, kids spaghetti and meatball and their special sauce Amatriciana. Yum! Size portions were perfect...used the garlic bread to get every bit of that sauce.

Dennis Mungle

Great tasting pasta dishes, the calzone pizza is amazing. Grandkids enjoy the papa pizza "meat lover".

Drstock55

We drove several miles to have pizza here only to be told the dining room was closed. Maybe they should post it on their website to avoid the trip (who eats pizza in the car).

Joshua Stevens

We drove 40 minutes to this place and brought my mom brother and sister we called on the phone and asked their hours they said 4 to 9 then when we arrived he said they aren't open inside so we asked him if we could eat inside even after driving 40 minutes and he said no we begged please and he still said no can't even be nice enough let us inside ?

Brandy Wilson

Holy smokes that’s good! We had the lasagna, fettuccine Alfredo, beef ravioli and pepperoni breadsticks and regular breadsticks. Everything was good expecting Fazoli‘s and got holy moly‘s!

Dani W.

The owners are friendly. The food is always fresh everytime we go no matter what time of day it is. Highly recommend.

Load More

Papa's Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine

1430 N Green St i, Brownsburg, IN 46112
(317) 858-2469