This is a unique, old-school local pizza place. In all the best ways, Greek Tony’s reminds me of the pizza restaurants that I went to 40 years ago. How did I not know about this place! The pizza, breadsticks and salad were all delicious, and the service was fast and friendly. The restaurant decor is hockey-themed and conveys the history of the restaurant’s founder. What’s not to love?
If you like your pizza crust "bready" this is the place. Personally I don't like it, it was about an inch and a half thick. Breadsticks were super buttery and delicious though. Only complaint was that service was really slow. It wasn't busy at all and it took more than an hour for our food to come out. I think they forgot our order because when they realized 30 minutes later, they gave us a receipt with a number handwritten on it for our table number. Then when they brought it out, they brought it in to-go boxes. They apologized since they didn't realize we were dine-in. It was an interesting experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Scott Houseman
This is the best pizza in Carmel, IMHO.
Gabe Vieck
Classic pizza joint. Killer bread sticks. A real pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gregory Cox
Old school family style pizzeria. Friendly people, reasonable prices, and great food. Five stars all day long!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Craig Malmloff
Been around forever, have driven by for years and finally stopped in for kunch. Just ok. Had higher expectations. Ok food at a good price. Slice of pizza, bread sticks swimming in butter and a drink.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Karyn S.
Super casual place with GREAT gyros! My husband I I shared a gyro platter because it came with a Greek salad. That salad dressing was the best I've had in a long time. The salad was full of greens, green pepper , onion and soft feta cheese. It wasn't huge salad but just enough to share. They have the best tzatziki sauce in town. This is the ONLY place wll go when we get a craving for gyros!!
Kelsi Means
The food was very good and this place has really great potential so I just have some constructive criticism. IT was not very busy when I came in, but it took about 30 mins to receive my order of Mac n Cheese and 2 breadsticks. The people that came in before us seemed to wait quite a while for their food as well. Not great for people on their lunch break. I think the speed issue is due to too many ingredients on the menu, there is no way their kitchen can be setup more efficiently with so many ingredients. Also, the staff was fine, but there could be a touch more friendliness and a little less joking around with each other when there is a dining room full of people. I am no stickler about people having fun at work, in fact, I prefer it, it was just obviously causing delays in bringing food out. Another tip I would have is to store the handheld menus at the front, on a little stand for people to look at while in line. As someone visiting for the first time, it was confusing that the the menu wasn't posted and I had to wait until I got to the counter to look at it, and only one side of the menu is fully visible on the counter/glass thing. After I received my food, I went up to the counter to ask for a to-go box because I needed to get back to work, and multiple people from the kitchen walked past me without acknowledging me. I waited quite a while to just get a to-go box. Greek Tony's has some great recipes and it shows that they are loved, just need some minor logistical improvements.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Emily Schaefer
I cannot tell you how good this place is! Breadsticks are to die for. Pizza...is so delicious! I personally love the seafood salad. I have tried different things on the menu each time I've gone, and NEVER disappointed. Owners are as nice as they come! Wonderful staff! We will be back since my husband loved it as well!Parking: Large parking lot, easy to find a spaceKid-friendliness: Has a small area for kids to play a game or two. My kids were all about the food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Breadsticks with Cheese
For some reason it take my pizza over 40 minutes to be ready. When I got there they weren't busy but they did get busy after I sat there for 20 minutes. Everybody kept up working, were very kind and nice. I dont know if they forgot my ticket on accident or if they pizza oven was extra full. So I told him they can have it and I'll just go get something somewhere else. Probably should of asked about before the 40min mark. I might come back when there super slow, the pictures looked great.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Mike Kearns
We've lived in Carmel for over 20 years and tonight was our first time in Greek Tony's. We had the GF jerk chicken pizza. We loved it. We also had the Greek salad and it was wonderful too. We also played a game of Ms. Pacman as we waited for our pizza. We will definitely be back soon.Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick Burke
great fresh made slice! Going back again for another and maybe a sub!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bob Bridges
I haven’t been To Greek Tony’s for 22 years until this Wednesday. I now work in Carmel and I’ve been there three times this week for lunch and it’s just how I remembered: Delicious. What a delight.
Italian beef, baby!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Italian Beef
This is a unique, old-school local pizza place. In all the best ways, Greek Tony’s reminds me of the pizza restaurants that I went to 40 years ago. How did I not know about this place! The pizza, breadsticks and salad were all delicious, and the service was fast and friendly. The restaurant decor is hockey-themed and conveys the history of the restaurant’s founder. What’s not to love?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Homemade Breadsticks
If you like your pizza crust "bready" this is the place. Personally I don't like it, it was about an inch and a half thick. Breadsticks were super buttery and delicious though. Only complaint was that service was really slow. It wasn't busy at all and it took more than an hour for our food to come out. I think they forgot our order because when they realized 30 minutes later, they gave us a receipt with a number handwritten on it for our table number. Then when they brought it out, they brought it in to-go boxes. They apologized since they didn't realize we were dine-in. It was an interesting experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
This is the best pizza in Carmel, IMHO.
Classic pizza joint. Killer bread sticks. A real pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Old school family style pizzeria. Friendly people, reasonable prices, and great food. Five stars all day long!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been around forever, have driven by for years and finally stopped in for kunch. Just ok. Had higher expectations. Ok food at a good price. Slice of pizza, bread sticks swimming in butter and a drink.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Super casual place with GREAT gyros! My husband I I shared a gyro platter because it came with a Greek salad. That salad dressing was the best I've had in a long time. The salad was full of greens, green pepper , onion and soft feta cheese. It wasn't huge salad but just enough to share. They have the best tzatziki sauce in town. This is the ONLY place wll go when we get a craving for gyros!!
The food was very good and this place has really great potential so I just have some constructive criticism. IT was not very busy when I came in, but it took about 30 mins to receive my order of Mac n Cheese and 2 breadsticks. The people that came in before us seemed to wait quite a while for their food as well. Not great for people on their lunch break. I think the speed issue is due to too many ingredients on the menu, there is no way their kitchen can be setup more efficiently with so many ingredients. Also, the staff was fine, but there could be a touch more friendliness and a little less joking around with each other when there is a dining room full of people. I am no stickler about people having fun at work, in fact, I prefer it, it was just obviously causing delays in bringing food out. Another tip I would have is to store the handheld menus at the front, on a little stand for people to look at while in line. As someone visiting for the first time, it was confusing that the the menu wasn't posted and I had to wait until I got to the counter to look at it, and only one side of the menu is fully visible on the counter/glass thing. After I received my food, I went up to the counter to ask for a to-go box because I needed to get back to work, and multiple people from the kitchen walked past me without acknowledging me. I waited quite a while to just get a to-go box. Greek Tony's has some great recipes and it shows that they are loved, just need some minor logistical improvements.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
I cannot tell you how good this place is! Breadsticks are to die for. Pizza...is so delicious! I personally love the seafood salad. I have tried different things on the menu each time I've gone, and NEVER disappointed. Owners are as nice as they come! Wonderful staff! We will be back since my husband loved it as well!Parking: Large parking lot, easy to find a spaceKid-friendliness: Has a small area for kids to play a game or two. My kids were all about the food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Breadsticks with Cheese
Restaurantji Recommends
Pretty good Italian beef. Fast friendly service
For some reason it take my pizza over 40 minutes to be ready. When I got there they weren't busy but they did get busy after I sat there for 20 minutes. Everybody kept up working, were very kind and nice. I dont know if they forgot my ticket on accident or if they pizza oven was extra full. So I told him they can have it and I'll just go get something somewhere else. Probably should of asked about before the 40min mark. I might come back when there super slow, the pictures looked great.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
We've lived in Carmel for over 20 years and tonight was our first time in Greek Tony's. We had the GF jerk chicken pizza. We loved it. We also had the Greek salad and it was wonderful too. We also played a game of Ms. Pacman as we waited for our pizza. We will definitely be back soon.Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
great fresh made slice! Going back again for another and maybe a sub!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I haven’t been To Greek Tony’s for 22 years until this Wednesday. I now work in Carmel and I’ve been there three times this week for lunch and it’s just how I remembered: Delicious. What a delight.
Food: 5
Service: 5