We popped in the other night while we were in the area and am glad we did...their Key Lime Pie is amazing! I am fairly picky with KLP and usually only eat it when I am in Florida, as I have not found another good one in Indy, but this one is not to be missed. They had lots of other amazing dessert choice to try as well! They do have homemade pasta (I do believe to take home) and also pizza. We will definitely be back to try the pizza, too; only reason we didn't is we had already eaten dinner.
Theresa J.
We went for a college send off dessert mid week. What a lovely place. Great food, great service and cute atmosphere. We had, cheesecake, cannoli, chocolate mousse, a gluten free almond cookie with cherry thumbprint filling, Italian Hot chocolate and a cappuccino. All were excellent. Not sure how this was our visit trip here but it won't be the last.
Linda L.
Gelato + espresso = affogato. And Stacco house makes it all deliciously. Service is outstanding as well. My daughter loved the chocolate gelato as well. At $2.50 for a little scoop, it was perfect. Also, The entrees are also delicious. I had the eggplant and it hit the spot. I need to come back and check out the cookies, crème brûlée, croissants, panna cotta... lasagna.
lucy t.
If you want the Best Cherry Amaretto cookies look no further. This small boutique Italian bakery has cases filled with amazing cookies and cakes. We bought eight of the Cherry Amaretto a lemon curd amaretto also amazing if you prefer lemon curd that curls your toes!They serve homemade meatballs and lasagna too. My visit was all about the sweet! Case of gelato appealing.. Next visit for sure. Worth a detour off 65 on your way to Nashville!
Jan L.
Tonight I picked up Meatball Sandwiches for us for dinner. Stacco has by far the BEST meatball Sammy in the city! It's beyond delicious, covered with delicious cheese and sauce on a magnificent long roll. They wrap it tightly in foil for travel, which kept it hot homeward bound. I cannot recommend this sandwich more!
Lin LiAnn W.
Definitely worth a try. The meatball sandwich was delicious. The lemon thumbprint cookie and butter cookie with jam were really good. Everything else was okay but kind of bland. Several sweets options including very reasonably priced gelato which we did not get but saw several people walk out with a scoop or two. I'd like to try their pizza and gelato next time I'm up in Carmel but I will probably skip the cookies and pasta.
Jenn L.
I happened upon this tiny gem while lookin for a sweet treat for a sick friend. One of the staff members were friendly sky, the other bummed me out. She made me feel Like I was putting her out. BUT...the tests were really good. If you find yourself in Carmel, check 'em out and hope the guy is there to help ya!
Andrea P.
Stop here!! The dessert selection is amazing! I've only been here for dessert but have heard the food selection is pretty darn good as well. I love tiramisu so this year for my birthday my daughter went to several different places picked up tiramisu, brought it home to have a taste test, and this place by far blew all the rest of them out of the water! I did not get any pictures but don't let that stop you from trying this place. Everything is to go, so see if you can wait until you get home before biting into that Nutella butter cookie or sticking a fork into a piece of triple chocolate cake, or cheese cake!
Laura S.
Came here tonight with my kids and we had a delightful experience! We ordered the pistachio gelato and milk chocolate gelato, cannoli, chocolate dipper and some incredible chocolate cake that I can't remember the name of. Our total was under $20 and it was DEVINE! My three year old stole my pistachio gelato and refused to give it back. I took her chocolate dipper and immediately wished I'd ordered a latte to dip it in. It's like a giant Milano cookie but better. My son said the milk chocolate gelato was the "best ice cream I've ever had." And the staff was incredibly lovely and gracious. Will definitely return!
Niki B.
This place is a slice of Italian heaven. We strolled in and were greeted by a really nice woman who walked us through their offerings. They have a gelato menu, a glass case full of baked goods and handmade desserts, a savory menu with both hot and cold options, a wine rack with Italian wines, handmade pastas to cook at home, and assorted packages of olive oils, vinegars, truffle sauces, pasta sauces, and pastas. WHAT WE GOT: + Homemade meatballs - huge, well-seasoned, covered in a great marinara + Homemade lasagna - delicious, also a big portion + Lemon curd fingerprint cookie - favorite dessert I tried, still dreaming about it + Peanut butter chocolate fingerprint cookie - also good + Cannoli - my husband's choice, looked beautiful WHAT I WANT TO TRY NEXT TIME: + Chicken parmesan sandwich + Tiramisu + Black and white cookie + Black truffle olive oil + Gelato shake + Handmade pasta (And I'll probably have to get more meatballs and lemon cookies too) They have a little window that you can slide open and order gelato from, or you can walk inside and order it at the counter. There is no seating inside, but there are two small tables out front. This place was so home-y, delicious, and special that you might even think you're in Italy for a moment. We'll be back!
We ordered our Mother’s Day meal from Stacco House getting lasagna, eggplant parmigiana, spaghetti and meatballs, focaccia, chocolate cake, cannoli and cookies. Everything was absolutely amazing - so delicious and something for everyone. The desserts were a big hit and everything was so fresh and so good. Highly recommend! Can’t wait to taste their new pizza coming soon!
Isabelle M.
Wow! I WILL be coming back here for all of my sweetooth needs. This has been on my list to try because my favorite restaurant in Carmel is Roma and I know this is their sister bakery! I easily placed my order online. I was able to do so like a week in advance which was nice. I did it advance because I was picking these up as a birthday treat. When I arrived they had everything ready to go for me which was so convenient. And yeah, I think this was the best cheesecake and cannoli I've ever had. Hands down. Absolutely delicious. I just got the plain cheesecake and it was so rich and delectable. I can't imagine what the chocolate is like, I'm sure it's amazing. The cannoli was also to die for. I'm going to try to orange and pistachio ones next time.
Vy r.
I bought like 20 desserts and some pasta and Angelina was super sweet and patient with me. I love the decor and the pasta was sooo good!! Great service!
Lynn N.
I was in the area, saw this place with good reviews, and the photos showed a wide variety of Italian desserts. Stopping by was a no-brainer. When stepping inside, the long window display of desserts greeted me. Every cookie, cake slice, and sweet. Which said hello the loudest on my first visit? Well... 5 stars - Chocolate cake slice. This was a last-minute "should I get it??". Glad I said yes! Because you gotta be able to just enjoy an indulgent dessert from time to time. Right? And this was a true treat. Just sweet enough, with a rich chocolate flavor. The frosting was just right. Not too thick. Not too thin. Super good. 5 stars - Butter cookie with jam. So I was reading a Yelp review where this cookie was mentioned. They made it sound so good I had to try it out myself. And they were right! I should have bought more. Yummmmy. I liked that it was not too sweet, had a great crisp, and the jam added a good texture element. 4 stars - Focaccia bread and Italian baguette. Great portion size to try both. I skipped on the ciabatta this time. The focaccia was herby. Just like I like it. Was a tad dry but not off putting. Next time I will try the tiramisu. And a couple more treats. Actually, five more treats. There's so many items I saw that I've never tried. Oh, and their gelato flavors looked awesome. They have at least four dairy-free vegan options. They also have hot entrees you can order too. What a hidden gem!
Fatima G.
A little spot right beside Carmel downtown serving a variety of coffees, sweet baked treats and gelato. I was craving something sweet in bite sized portions and Stacco House had everything I needed. We tried chocolate mousse, creme brûlée and a lemon cookie. All the desserts had reasonable sugar, were sized appropriately and totally hit the spot! I also bought fresh Ciabatta bread for lunch next day and it was so fresh and spongy. There's no space for dine in, you can pick your orders and they have a good variety of wines although I do not drink.
We popped in the other night while we were in the area and am glad we did...their Key Lime Pie is amazing! I am fairly picky with KLP and usually only eat it when I am in Florida, as I have not found another good one in Indy, but this one is not to be missed. They had lots of other amazing dessert choice to try as well! They do have homemade pasta (I do believe to take home) and also pizza. We will definitely be back to try the pizza, too; only reason we didn't is we had already eaten dinner.
We went for a college send off dessert mid week. What a lovely place. Great food, great service and cute atmosphere. We had, cheesecake, cannoli, chocolate mousse, a gluten free almond cookie with cherry thumbprint filling, Italian Hot chocolate and a cappuccino. All were excellent. Not sure how this was our visit trip here but it won't be the last.
Gelato + espresso = affogato. And Stacco house makes it all deliciously. Service is outstanding as well. My daughter loved the chocolate gelato as well. At $2.50 for a little scoop, it was perfect. Also, The entrees are also delicious. I had the eggplant and it hit the spot. I need to come back and check out the cookies, crème brûlée, croissants, panna cotta... lasagna.
If you want the Best Cherry Amaretto cookies look no further. This small boutique Italian bakery has cases filled with amazing cookies and cakes. We bought eight of the Cherry Amaretto a lemon curd amaretto also amazing if you prefer lemon curd that curls your toes!They serve homemade meatballs and lasagna too. My visit was all about the sweet! Case of gelato appealing.. Next visit for sure. Worth a detour off 65 on your way to Nashville!
Tonight I picked up Meatball Sandwiches for us for dinner. Stacco has by far the BEST meatball Sammy in the city! It's beyond delicious, covered with delicious cheese and sauce on a magnificent long roll. They wrap it tightly in foil for travel, which kept it hot homeward bound. I cannot recommend this sandwich more!
Definitely worth a try. The meatball sandwich was delicious. The lemon thumbprint cookie and butter cookie with jam were really good. Everything else was okay but kind of bland. Several sweets options including very reasonably priced gelato which we did not get but saw several people walk out with a scoop or two. I'd like to try their pizza and gelato next time I'm up in Carmel but I will probably skip the cookies and pasta.
I happened upon this tiny gem while lookin for a sweet treat for a sick friend. One of the staff members were friendly sky, the other bummed me out. She made me feel Like I was putting her out. BUT...the tests were really good. If you find yourself in Carmel, check 'em out and hope the guy is there to help ya!
Stop here!! The dessert selection is amazing! I've only been here for dessert but have heard the food selection is pretty darn good as well. I love tiramisu so this year for my birthday my daughter went to several different places picked up tiramisu, brought it home to have a taste test, and this place by far blew all the rest of them out of the water! I did not get any pictures but don't let that stop you from trying this place. Everything is to go, so see if you can wait until you get home before biting into that Nutella butter cookie or sticking a fork into a piece of triple chocolate cake, or cheese cake!
Came here tonight with my kids and we had a delightful experience! We ordered the pistachio gelato and milk chocolate gelato, cannoli, chocolate dipper and some incredible chocolate cake that I can't remember the name of. Our total was under $20 and it was DEVINE! My three year old stole my pistachio gelato and refused to give it back. I took her chocolate dipper and immediately wished I'd ordered a latte to dip it in. It's like a giant Milano cookie but better. My son said the milk chocolate gelato was the "best ice cream I've ever had." And the staff was incredibly lovely and gracious. Will definitely return!
This place is a slice of Italian heaven. We strolled in and were greeted by a really nice woman who walked us through their offerings. They have a gelato menu, a glass case full of baked goods and handmade desserts, a savory menu with both hot and cold options, a wine rack with Italian wines, handmade pastas to cook at home, and assorted packages of olive oils, vinegars, truffle sauces, pasta sauces, and pastas. WHAT WE GOT: + Homemade meatballs - huge, well-seasoned, covered in a great marinara + Homemade lasagna - delicious, also a big portion + Lemon curd fingerprint cookie - favorite dessert I tried, still dreaming about it + Peanut butter chocolate fingerprint cookie - also good + Cannoli - my husband's choice, looked beautiful WHAT I WANT TO TRY NEXT TIME: + Chicken parmesan sandwich + Tiramisu + Black and white cookie + Black truffle olive oil + Gelato shake + Handmade pasta (And I'll probably have to get more meatballs and lemon cookies too) They have a little window that you can slide open and order gelato from, or you can walk inside and order it at the counter. There is no seating inside, but there are two small tables out front. This place was so home-y, delicious, and special that you might even think you're in Italy for a moment. We'll be back!
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered our Mother’s Day meal from Stacco House getting lasagna, eggplant parmigiana, spaghetti and meatballs, focaccia, chocolate cake, cannoli and cookies. Everything was absolutely amazing - so delicious and something for everyone. The desserts were a big hit and everything was so fresh and so good. Highly recommend! Can’t wait to taste their new pizza coming soon!
Wow! I WILL be coming back here for all of my sweetooth needs. This has been on my list to try because my favorite restaurant in Carmel is Roma and I know this is their sister bakery! I easily placed my order online. I was able to do so like a week in advance which was nice. I did it advance because I was picking these up as a birthday treat. When I arrived they had everything ready to go for me which was so convenient. And yeah, I think this was the best cheesecake and cannoli I've ever had. Hands down. Absolutely delicious. I just got the plain cheesecake and it was so rich and delectable. I can't imagine what the chocolate is like, I'm sure it's amazing. The cannoli was also to die for. I'm going to try to orange and pistachio ones next time.
I bought like 20 desserts and some pasta and Angelina was super sweet and patient with me. I love the decor and the pasta was sooo good!! Great service!
I was in the area, saw this place with good reviews, and the photos showed a wide variety of Italian desserts. Stopping by was a no-brainer. When stepping inside, the long window display of desserts greeted me. Every cookie, cake slice, and sweet. Which said hello the loudest on my first visit? Well... 5 stars - Chocolate cake slice. This was a last-minute "should I get it??". Glad I said yes! Because you gotta be able to just enjoy an indulgent dessert from time to time. Right? And this was a true treat. Just sweet enough, with a rich chocolate flavor. The frosting was just right. Not too thick. Not too thin. Super good. 5 stars - Butter cookie with jam. So I was reading a Yelp review where this cookie was mentioned. They made it sound so good I had to try it out myself. And they were right! I should have bought more. Yummmmy. I liked that it was not too sweet, had a great crisp, and the jam added a good texture element. 4 stars - Focaccia bread and Italian baguette. Great portion size to try both. I skipped on the ciabatta this time. The focaccia was herby. Just like I like it. Was a tad dry but not off putting. Next time I will try the tiramisu. And a couple more treats. Actually, five more treats. There's so many items I saw that I've never tried. Oh, and their gelato flavors looked awesome. They have at least four dairy-free vegan options. They also have hot entrees you can order too. What a hidden gem!
A little spot right beside Carmel downtown serving a variety of coffees, sweet baked treats and gelato. I was craving something sweet in bite sized portions and Stacco House had everything I needed. We tried chocolate mousse, creme brûlée and a lemon cookie. All the desserts had reasonable sugar, were sized appropriately and totally hit the spot! I also bought fresh Ciabatta bread for lunch next day and it was so fresh and spongy. There's no space for dine in, you can pick your orders and they have a good variety of wines although I do not drink.