Which Wich Carmel Shops

1430 W Carmel Dr Suite 140, Carmel
(317) 580-9424

Recent Reviews

Emma Fitzgerald

Normally, I love their sandwiches. Today, I was eating my sandwich and found mold on the bread!

Ms. Culver

Wasn't very please. Ordered a Ruben and they didn't tell me until after i paid that they were out of the cheese for it. They asked if i wanted to substitute a different kind i said yes, however when i got my sandwich there was none. Paid over $14 for a regular sandwich and regular ( small) fry. Never did get my drink. They were out of cups? I don't think i will ever be returning. Sad lunch

Gunny E.

I ordered two large and one regular sandwich this evening through Door Dash. They did not deliver the regular one (for my daughter with COVID +). I contacted the DD delivery guy, and he said I needed to call the store. When I called the store, they told me that they had forgotten to put it in the bag, and I could either come and pick or credit my account. I told them they needed to deliver it since I paid DD for the convenience, but that was not the option. NO STARS for the Which Wich or DoorDash!

Kelly Hennessy

I came in needing 10 sandwiches and they didn’t bat an eye. They were more than willing to help (even though I’m sure they’re short staffed like everywhere else), they rocked it! I was very thankful for accommodating my large order and great service!

Steven Malander

Place was clean and staff was friendly. Got a large Sammie. When I opened it up there was like 4 inches of plain bread. No cheese, meat, onions just bread. I think the large is 10.5 inches....That Sammie is too expensive for a 6.5.

S G

Sandwich barely had any meat, took cilantro straight out of Meijer bag to put on the sandwich, didn’t bother with washing it. I would go to Subway, Jimmy John’s or Penn Station.

Nishanth Onkar

Good sandwich options. There is even a vegan option (black bean sandwich). The ordering process is smooth and a little different. You have to pick the sandwich bag and circle the options that you need on the sandwich and give it at the counter. It's much quicker as people who take time to decide can take all the time they need instead of holding up the line at the cashier. The fries were good. It is slightly on the expensive side though. I wish they had shade umbrellas for their outdoor seating. It gets too hot and sunny, so I couldn't use the outdoor seating.

Collin Barham

I and a coworker have been weekly customers of this Which Wich for the past year and a half, even though the pandemic when it was open. We have never been disappointed! The manager a d the staff always treat is great and interact with us as we come in.

Andrew McCurry

I always enjoy a sandwich from here. They are pretty fast and friendly. I'm not a huge fan of the redo of the menu, but it's not affected the food quality.

Asani

I'm just gonna give the lone employee who was working in the store the benefit of the doubt and assume he was having a bad day.However, I did not appreciate the way he acted towards me and my mother. He was pretty rude, he was throwing down some objects, he slammed stuff around, and generally acted like he didn't want to be there or serve us our food.He put my stuff on the counter pretty rudely and barely called out my name. When I asked him at full volume twice if my order was done he just looked down and acted like he didn't hear me.I have not tried the food yet so this rating is solely for my in-restauarant experience

Kimberly Gehbauer

This is the first location out of many that I have been to that was lacking on quality. My husband and I both got similar sandwiches. Mine was perfect, but my husband's was 95% lettuce. I recommend this place to him because he's never tried it before, and it failed.

Troy Tinsley

Slow to receive food. Out of several things. Didn’t seem like much focus on quality. Havent got my food yet but service and environment poor. Also just found out theyMissed an order. Stuff out on the tables. Just not ready for customers

Rick McHaffey

Listed as closes at 9pm, not holiday not special hours. Get there 8pm and they are closed, no sign, no notes, we drove all across town to get there because they had the hours listed. Everything around it open, just a big F YOU to their customers. They really don't care about you.

Ray Gao

I ordered 3 whole wheat sandwiches from this place yesterday, cashier was nice and food looked fine except almost disappeared dressing. This led really dry tasting and bad feeling, I couldn’t feel any creamy juicy flavor at all except salty roast beef and pickles, which made me sick. The maker was a young girl who should’ve been trained well before hands on. Shop should consider the quality, not quantity.

Sarah Heck

I ordered the lettucewich ultimate BLT and was disappointed in the quality of the lettuce wrap. It was completely wilted. When attempting to call the store to address the issue no one answered the phone. I attempted five different times with no response.

Load More