Godfather's Pizza

1175 Broadway, Chesterton
(219) 929-1110

Recent Reviews

Robert Beilfuss

They don't have any specials and the pizza was pricey. It will be a while before I go back.

Jordan Bowlin

It was just alright. Pepperoni was a little odd. Not much sauce - I'm a sauce person. Cheese was really good though!

Francis janiewski

We are hooked on pizza from Godfathers. We drove 18 miles for a jumbo golden crust meat pizza. Love the leftovers too.

Michelle Sconce

I am glad my husband said see if there is a Godfathers pizza near us. Yes like 35miles away. It was well worth the drive. We have been looking forward to the golden crust, we got the jumbo meat pizza, leftovers for 2 days. Very good pizza and excellent help making it. Thanks

Candice Walsh

Family had our hearts set for a dine-in pizza restaurant..drive 20 mins just to eat there to find out its a gas station! Very upset

adam whitten

Love the deluxe Taco pizza! Always hot...like I pick it up and the box has steam venting out of it. The Staff is always super friendly! Love this pizza so much better then papa johns soggy pizza, and no where near as greasy as the hut! Dominoes makes good bread knots... try a taco today yall it's the best!

Jennifer Williams

If I could give less than 1 star I would. Horrible service!!!

Brandon Sykes

Ordered a jumbo pizza, breadsticks, and jalapeño poppers.Keep in mind this is a "gas station" food joint.And they don't tell you that or show pictures of the location. Had I known that I would have never ordered food from here.Person I talked to on the phone either didn't speak good English, or couldn't hear me when I asked a couple simple questions.The pizza is literally a slightly better little Ceasars but they charge 3x the price.Breadsticks are OK but the marinara has an extremely heavy lime taste to it and it's terrible.The jalapeño poppers were disgusting, dry, and powdery. Couldn't take more than a bite.I won't be going back.

belle luna

Great pizza, pretty fast on orders. Horrible w/ curbside, just go inside instead, it will save you the fustration.

Lauren Ferber

Pepperoni calzone was delicious, as well as the cinnamon dessert pizza ?

Ms. Cack

Delicious.

Caroline Firkell

First time having their pizza and it was very good! We had been only ordering from Venice pizza fir about two years before they closed and thought we would give Godfathers a shot. Their Hot Stuff pizza is so good and spicy!! The kids were very pleased with their plain cheese. Only issue would be the salad was very meager, especially the shredded lettuce which was the salads base. However, I wouldn’t hesitate to order from them again ( pizza that is :) ). Also, they’re better than another local place up the road which is pricier and less tasty.

Chrissy Gallam

We ordered delivery. The food quality was terrible and the employee was rude. The corndogs were burnt on the outside and actually COLD on the inside. The pizzas were warm, but not hot. The pizza crust was clearly premade and they just slapped on toppings and rewarmed it. After eating it, my husband and I both had a stomach ache. It also left a weird tangy bitter taste in my mouth.It was absolutely the worst pizza I've ever had. I would have much rather just put in a frozen pizza if I would have known.

PAT MEADOWS

Pricey but the quality is well worth it!

Jasen Vaughan

It's good

Load More