Alexanders On The Water

369 W Jackson St, Cicero
(317) 984-8173

Recent Reviews

Jacob B.

The ice cream here is delicious. Which is almost enough to distract you from the incompetent service that will keep you from getting it in any reasonable timeframe. Block off half an hour for the 3-car drive-thru line. Maybe pick up dinner to keep you occupied in the line. Picked a day there's no line? They might tell you, as they did today, "they're closing (3 hours) early and no can't take your cash or serve another scoop." Unreal.

Nathan Traylor

Great ice cream and staff. Prices and flavors are also fantastic.

Aaron K.

Our order was not what we wanted. They gave us soft serve ice cream instead of a hard scoop. I told the girl at the window that it wasn't what we wanted. She told me that the hard ice cream cost more . I told her that I'd pay the difference. She told me that they wouldn't remake it because it was made they way that the ticket was put in by the cashier. She said that I'd have to pay for a whole new ice cream. At that point, I gave up, threw it in the trash and we left. Terrible customer service. I left feedback with the business through my emailed receipt, but no response. . .

Christy Hardaway

Staff very friendly. Nice peaceful place to visit. Chocolate Shake was soooo good.

Mike Maddox

Great little ice cream shop. Nice to know you can still get a decent soft serve cone for under $5.00. Thank you

t kincaid

Enjoyed ice cream with our youngest granddaughter and our dog Dobby.

Jim Irwin

Great tasting tenderloins and ice cream!

Nicole Butler

Sign said open but they claimed they were closed and would not serve. Served the person in front and we had to walk away with 2 screaming kids. Thanks!

Phil Stevens

The vanilla, rainbow sherbet, and mint chocolate chip were good but the soft serve was less good.

Emily Johnson

The ice cream is always good, the wait times have gotten pretty long in recent times. Tonight was crazy, but that's summer on Morse!

Dustin B

Was a great little stop for the family to grab a cone on a hot day!! Service was good and seating area was clean.

glen warren

I got a chocolate dipped cone and it was not dipped right and the chocolate tasted bad and they wouldn't change it

John Fleck

Delicious choices and awesome atmosphere. Very popular so you may have trouble finding a parking spot or have to wait a bit in line but it's definitely worth it!

Adam Rowe

Great place for the best ice cream in the area

Terry Jean Nichols

I loved my breaded pork sandwich. I can't get this sandwich in WV.

Load More