Recommended dishes: Combo 1, Large One Topping Pizza, Stuffed Pizza, Combo Meal 1
DeeDee L.
This is a hidden gem in the old mall with very friendly staff and amazing and huge pizzas!!! It was very clean as well. We ordered a large pizza and it was easily 20 inches. We dined in and took the rest home to enjoy tomorrow. We will definitely be back.
Niki Vera
Great customer service and food.
Eric Rudicel
Best pizza and bread sticks in Columbus for 25 years and running. Thanks for the great pizza guys !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Combo
Charles Grissom
I have always loved this pizza place. The slices are nice and big and are very delicious ?. Bread sticks are good and the have all the toppings you could desire. Although the mall has changed and I hadn't been in a while I will be stopping in soon to grab me some of that good piazza.
We had a slice of the stuffed meat pizza here. The meat was decent, and sauce good. To much bread, though. Would not get this pizza again. Pepperoni bread sticks were good, though. The guys behind the counter were nice and the price good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
connor columbia
Good NY style pizza. Large Foldable slices. Pepperoni breadsticks also very tasty with cheese sauce to dip. Friendly staff and fast service.
Dͩrͬ. Z
By far, this beats Zwanzig’s, Buccetto’s, Greek’s, Noble Roman’s and all the major chains in Columbus (Domino’s, Chicago, Marco’s, etc.)
Paul Wildridge
Family deal is a steal! The service is the best of any place I have been! Been going to this place since 2003 and Love this place!
Joshua Voss
Great memories from college. I always appreciate their interaction with myself and other customers.I miss those days. Thanks for the memories!
Their Hawaiian pizza and bread sticks… AMAZING!!! I absolutely recommend eating here, it’s totally worth it!
Jocelyn Diaz
Their Hawaiian pizza and bread sticks… AMAZING!!! I absolutely recommend eating here, it’s totally worth it!
Giorno Giovanna
Thick crust deep dish cheesy very good ham sausage and hotpeppers cheesy
T.D. McCarty
So glad I finally tried this place. After trying all the pizza in Columbus, as you can tell from the reviews, this place takes the crown. They even put the pepperonis under the cheese per request. Fantastic service and ingredients.
Keith W.
Well I hate to say that I've lived in Columbus for 32 years and had never eaten here until today! I've become friends with an Italian couple from New York and asked them this "you guys are from New York and Italian, so what's the closest to New York pizza in Columbus Indiana?" Without hesitation they both replied Carlos Pizza! I had to ask where it was. So today my wife and I tried it. Absolutely outstanding!! Pizza, salads, and pepperoni breadsticks were absolutely delicious. Plus one of the cheaper lunches in town. If you like Pizza and breadsticks you have to try this place. Definitely 5 stars
Good food and great staff!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Combo 1, Large One Topping Pizza, Stuffed Pizza, Combo Meal 1
This is a hidden gem in the old mall with very friendly staff and amazing and huge pizzas!!! It was very clean as well. We ordered a large pizza and it was easily 20 inches. We dined in and took the rest home to enjoy tomorrow. We will definitely be back.
Great customer service and food.
Best pizza and bread sticks in Columbus for 25 years and running. Thanks for the great pizza guys !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Combo
I have always loved this pizza place. The slices are nice and big and are very delicious ?. Bread sticks are good and the have all the toppings you could desire. Although the mall has changed and I hadn't been in a while I will be stopping in soon to grab me some of that good piazza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza, Pepperoni Breadsticks
We had a slice of the stuffed meat pizza here. The meat was decent, and sauce good. To much bread, though. Would not get this pizza again. Pepperoni bread sticks were good, though. The guys behind the counter were nice and the price good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Good NY style pizza. Large Foldable slices. Pepperoni breadsticks also very tasty with cheese sauce to dip. Friendly staff and fast service.
By far, this beats Zwanzig’s, Buccetto’s, Greek’s, Noble Roman’s and all the major chains in Columbus (Domino’s, Chicago, Marco’s, etc.)
Family deal is a steal! The service is the best of any place I have been! Been going to this place since 2003 and Love this place!
Great memories from college. I always appreciate their interaction with myself and other customers.I miss those days. Thanks for the memories!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Their Hawaiian pizza and bread sticks… AMAZING!!! I absolutely recommend eating here, it’s totally worth it!
Their Hawaiian pizza and bread sticks… AMAZING!!! I absolutely recommend eating here, it’s totally worth it!
Thick crust deep dish cheesy very good ham sausage and hotpeppers cheesy
So glad I finally tried this place. After trying all the pizza in Columbus, as you can tell from the reviews, this place takes the crown. They even put the pepperonis under the cheese per request. Fantastic service and ingredients.
Well I hate to say that I've lived in Columbus for 32 years and had never eaten here until today! I've become friends with an Italian couple from New York and asked them this "you guys are from New York and Italian, so what's the closest to New York pizza in Columbus Indiana?" Without hesitation they both replied Carlos Pizza! I had to ask where it was. So today my wife and I tried it. Absolutely outstanding!! Pizza, salads, and pepperoni breadsticks were absolutely delicious. Plus one of the cheaper lunches in town. If you like Pizza and breadsticks you have to try this place. Definitely 5 stars