Papa Johns Pizza

2520 Eastbrook Plz, Columbus
(812) 376-9999

Recent Reviews

Amy Mankin

First time at this one . Food was great and love the drive thru pick-up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

erik hoover

Online ordering has always worked well for me at this papa johns location. The issue is, I always add the "well done" option. I picked up my pizza today and it was not well done. Cheese was white as the box. This has been a constant issue of my orders not well done.Also the new place...the parking lot is a disaster. And the drive thru is a joke. No one wants to figure out how to handle and place a pizza in a car, thru a window. It didn't work well for the competitor in town..why would you do it???

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Sara Co

Well it's settled. I will not order delivery ever again. No door dash, pizza delivery from website, uber eats ect. When someone gives you a good tip because it's snowing outside and you cant even make sure all their order is there, that's just ridiculous. FYI I am a nice person but if you forget people's things when it took me 3 hours to get my food... (Tried to order through door dash and Uber eats so had to go through website after snow day, being made to wait until my order was canceled) hopefully you won't run into a VERY crazy person that is tired and hungry and tells you what's on their mind! I gave the driver a good tip which is another reason I'm upset. You won't be getting my money when you can't do something so simple and make sure an order is there. Customer service is so bad these days. I've worked food many times. Made sure it was a habit, customers got drinks first, their utensils, sauces ect, then their order. No drama. When there is no work ethic, it shows*Lol I just got finished reading the reviews and you guys are trash! So I'm taking 2 stars off after again I was nice and gave you 3. One person said not to bother getting a drink because you won't get it, which was my case. That was THREE years ago! The owner doesn't care about his customers obviously. So no delivery from now on for us but also will choose a different pizza restaurant. Toddles! No $50+orders from us!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Ken Imel

New location in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

G Rhoades

The food has always been spot on without an inch of missing detail. Pizza is ready when you come to pick it up, and they'll always greet you with a smile.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread, Cinnamon Pull Aparts

Matthew Schoettmer

We were redirected to this location from Greensburg. when we called to ask for it to be put in Greensburg the middle aged cashier women told us “they were to busy, and they do not feel like doing it”. Then when we drive 49 minutes to get this pizza she continues to say in the store, “you didn’t have to rush here, the pizza would still be here”. Being very rude.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

E Aaron

Tasty, plenty of cheese and toppings. Crust perfect size, perfect amount tomato sauce. Best chain pizza in my opinion.

Geneva Dailey

The app did not let me know when my food was ready as it says you can track your order. Worse I didn't get all of my order.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks

Todd Edwards

The last 4 times the order was wrong upon arrival. They are incompetent at this location and I'm done ordering from them.

Atmosphere: 1

Brian Ziegler

The pizza is always fast always hot. No complaints.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza, Cheese Bread

Kenneth Higgins

Love the ability to save up your Reward Points to Get PAPA DOUGH!! Also use PROMO CODE:25OFFPJ for 25% off your total on Reg. items!! I just Recently ordered 2 of there BEST items..being the Parmesan chicken bites w/ extra sauce & it came to only $10.78 but I had earned $10 in PAPA DOUGH so I chose to use it & I only paid $.78!! Yeah that's right... $.78 CENTS!! GOTTA LOVE THIS PLACE!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza, Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks, Cheese Bread

Malachi Scott

We ordered the chicken alfredo pizza and they didn't put the chicken on it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Jon White

Papa John's used to be very good pizza it went downhill I don't know why New Management maybeVegetarian options: Papa John's has a vegetarian option Pizza

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Dylan Montgomery

I ordered 2 things of chicken alfrado an I got toppings in a bowl it had mushrooms an all kinda stuff in it and I can't eat mushrooms so I called and asked if I could get a refund an they were rude an hung up on me I spent 40 dollars an didn't even get to eat an that was all the money I had messed up

Nenad Konjevic

The staff was really nice and courteous I am definitely going back.

Load More