Nick's Eatery

10660 Randolph St, Crown Point
(219) 663-1988

Recent Reviews

Ed F

I will never go back to that place again the smallest sandwiches I’ve ever seen way overpriced

VR Red

The food is wonderful and we love that they have a lot of GF options!

Rick Wachowski

Great food! Very covid safety conscious with drive up window! Got the BLT club and was very impressed! Fantastic garlic dressing!

Joan Kieffer-Martinez

Just had the chicken and beef pot pies last night. My daughter in law picked up and they were great and really homemade. Well worth the price. They are all homemade and have become so popular it would be smart to order early in the day for a dinner time pickup. Everything I’ve had has always been good. We appreciate and need more restaurants of this type in our area.

Bill Clauser

The chicken pot pie is possibly the greatest thing I've ever eaten!!!

Jacob W.

This place is overpriced, and I feel like I was scammed. I paid 30 bucks for 2 salads with lousy presentation! The lady on the phone didn't seem to understand what I wanted and recommended the wrong order to me. I should've sticked with what I was going to go with; as, the meal looks very lazily put together, olives were un-pitted, tomato was in giant chunks and the oil and herb mix wasn't even mixed in properly!! It was just all thrown on top of each other! On top of that, the "salad" lacked in greens! Overall, I wouldn't recommend this, it was very lackluster and was thrown together with little to no effort! I've tried the gyro special too, and it was horrible, extra soggy. The tzatziki is very hit-or-miss dependent on whose making it.

Thomas Zaleske

The worse gyros I ever had served to me. I continue to try but they just can't make anything but a hamburger. Covid may be a saving grace for this place

Paul Stanko

Nick's has been my family's go to carry out during this entire COVID-19 mess. I have known Nick since he was a deli chef at a local supermarket and then had his own restaurant attached to said supermarket. Ever since he opened this Eatery, he has provided the most extensive menu around for carry out, and he has expanded his menu ever since. I have never had a bad experience with anything from Nick's. I usually get his sandwiches or wraps, and have had almost everything on his menu (I like variety). His portions are HUGE, so a carry out Chicken Salad Croissant (one of my favorites) will easily provide lunch for my wife and me, or two lunches for me. I especially LOVE his Mac and Cheese side (I have started ordering bacon added to it, which is AWESOME).COVID has put a lot of restaurants out of business nationwide, but fortunately Nick has adapted well to the new world, and together with his family, who are taking your carry out orders when you call, has kept his place open and thriving. I order from Nick's several times a week, and you should too! The food is always good, and they treat you like family.

Gary Galindo

I really hate to review a local business this way. I had seen a lot of positive reviews all throughout the pandemic. I don't think we will ever try them again.We've never eaten here. But we saw great reviews and $5 gyro sign posted as we drive by. We decided to have them for dinner that night. We called to ask about the $5 gyro sign. The young lady who answered didn't know if they were still doing that. She put us on hold to come back and say yes they are. Ok glad we established that. We asked did they have a bigger gyro meal like a plate or platter (Another local place has a plate - see Nicky's review)? Again she didn't know. We asked did it come with fries then or was there menu online anywhere. Again she didn't know. We said we'll just head up there. So we should have taken that all as signs.We arrived shortly after 5...we saw 6 vehicles in the parking lot. And didn't realize that due to covid they weren't doing walk in carry out orders. It was either phone ahead or drive through only. We pull around to view the menu. We pull up to order and I explain we want 5 gyros and a chicken ceasar wrap thingy. We ordered fries as well for all items. They ask us to pull ahead in a parking spot. We now have joined the other cars waiting. Others order and join us as well. Occasionally you'll see someone bring out an order. But it seems to be every 5-10 minutes. And cars are just piling up in the parking spots. Karen's are getting out of their vehicle's and literally pacing along side them. If someone comes out with food and it's not theirs they immediately ask these flustered girls, who are on the firing line, where their food is? I'm not kidding their were 2 just pacing back and forth out of their cars. If they could have gone in yes they would have asked to speak to a manager!55 minutes later we get our food. The girl continually apologizes for nothing of her doing I'm sure. She's just getting pelted with anger. We're not happy but we've been in retail as district managers before...we get it. Take our food and leave.Gyros were gross. I tried putting on a brave face but no. The meat was burned all along the edges. And like legit burned and crispy. Also it was super greasy. You could see grease pooling on pieces that were just sitting there. We bought gyro meat in a bag 1 time at Costco. When you cooked it in a pan it would burn the edges and got super greasy and it was gross. This reminded me of that. The fries were ok. They reminded me of frozen food fry quality. And the chicken wrap was ok. The ceaser was really strong tasting. Not for everyone.At $48 this was way over priced and a horrible 1st time experience. We can spend way less in better quality and more food in other options in and around town.

Barbara Wagner

We have been customers at Nicks since he opened. We have just had a bad experience with them, we ordered 2 orders of their chips and the container they were in melted through the bottom and on the top. Of course we couldn’t eat them. I called thinking we could refund, or another batch the next time we came in, the answer was absolutely not, nothing they can do for us. They just lost us as customers!

Thomas Z.

I continue to self flagellate myself hoping that if I put months between visits the food would get better here. Today a basic order, a gyros sandwich. Where to begin...A soggy pita. Not even a modicum of crust. Like it came straight out of a bag. I have eaten hundreds of gyros and never have I received one without a grilled toasting.. The meat...limp, like it never met the heat of coils from a rotisserie spit. An ample drowning of the sandwich in a sauce that resembled something found in a fraternity toilet after a hard night of drinking. A ground up combination of tomatoes and onions that would embarass anyone if served to guests. And to top it off, Italian peppers tossed in like an afterthought. I don't think even a year between visits could promise a better experience. My advice, hit McDonald's or Taco smell, at least they don't try to be something they aren't, good food.

Rebecca Krankvich

I ordered the chicken avocado wrap today and I was not pleased at all. The cheese smelled sour, nothing was chopped small, practically had a whole head of lettuce on my wrap, which was brown. I’m afraid I’m going get food poisoning. I don’t know if it has new staff but the food has definitely changed for the worse.

Trinity K.

So many delicious options! Super friendly, family vibe. Best lemon rice soup ever. I always leave satisfied.

Jan furman

Order 1 /12 hours ahead of picking up your order if you're going to get your food there. My family and I were not told there were 30 orders ahead of us when we came to the drive-up and placed our order. We came 6:00 pm left with the order 7:30 pm only after giving the restaurant employee notice they had 10 minutes to get the food out to my car or refund my card. The fries were cold.

Steph Loach

I called ahead to order my food. Came around the time they said it would be ready. They said to pull into a parking space and they would bring my food out when it was ready. I sat in the parking lot for 40 MINUTUES!!!! There was no explanation as for why it took so long. There were others that were waiting even longer.

Load More