I'm from Chicago home of the deep dish pizza, and by far this is the best pizza i have ever had... they said they make their own sausage! The thin was amazing too! A must try! 10 out of 10stars
Daniel O.
Carry out or delivery. We have it delivered and each time it's hot and fresh out of the oven an absolutely delicious!! The delivery guy is a nice guy as well! I can't say anything about the ambiance of the place since we've always had it delivered, but definitely recommend the delicious pizza!
Jbkvgirl V.
I love their deep dish. It's always consistently good. Their sausage and crust is always delicious. I wish they would offer green peppers as a topping - and not a mixture of yellow and red and green only. Also- their thin crust is a bit pricey. However, their deep dish is the best in CP, and it is worth every penny.
Google user
This is the best tasting pizza in Northwest Indiana. I have tried them all and the Pizza Cellar is now our favorite. We had a deep dish and thin crust, both were outstanding. This is not your fast food, mediocre, “it’s not bad” quality pizzeria. All the ingredients were high quality, and you can immediately taste the difference. Seriously good pizza for serious pizza lovers.
Jason J.
Great pizza at a great price! Always received our order promptly and always a kind and courteous person on the other side of the line when we order. High recommend!
Raven
Best anywhere. Hands down. Anyone else in town is a far second place.
Sophia Arezanti
Old school gourmet food that you can get delivered or taken out, friendly customer service, five star hidden gem! Must try??
Dan B.
Fantastic pizza and great service! Wish I could rate it higher.
Mike T.
Can't give it any stars but had to give one because it won't let ya give zero stars! I'm only giving this place the one star because they were closed at 9pm on Monday April 3rd when they should of been open from what there hours say there open to 10! Not so!! Very disappointed no sign no morning about emergency they just weren't there I even drove up there thinking maybe they got busy and nope got there 9:10pm and nobody there and all light were shut off! Damn first time going to try ur pizza and this makes me not ever wanna try it now! If ur open till 10pm be open at 9pm and not be gone would be a great start but it is what it is
Jake Warzyniak
Best deep dish around. Make sure you add the homemade sausage to your deep dish, worth every dollar. Owner is always friendly and makes sure everything is good.
would not recommend this place; burned pizza and no apology! and expensive -- definitely not worth it.
Timothy McKinney
If You Like Deep Dish Pizza ? Pizza Cellar has The Best!
kaylee myers
Whoever I talked to on the phone was so kind, and the delivery man was also so nice! Highly recommend
Robert H.
I've never heard of this place before I thought I would try something different because I'm tired of spending $40 for a large pizza from many of the places around here I looked around, did some searching and found the reviews here. I ordered the beef combo sandwich, and it was the best I have ever had. I would definitely recommend this place!!!
Phil Schroeder
Not the cheapest, especially if you like lots of toppings, but I'm pretty sure this is the best pizza I've ever had.
I'm from Chicago home of the deep dish pizza, and by far this is the best pizza i have ever had... they said they make their own sausage! The thin was amazing too! A must try! 10 out of 10stars
Carry out or delivery. We have it delivered and each time it's hot and fresh out of the oven an absolutely delicious!! The delivery guy is a nice guy as well! I can't say anything about the ambiance of the place since we've always had it delivered, but definitely recommend the delicious pizza!
I love their deep dish. It's always consistently good. Their sausage and crust is always delicious. I wish they would offer green peppers as a topping - and not a mixture of yellow and red and green only. Also- their thin crust is a bit pricey. However, their deep dish is the best in CP, and it is worth every penny.
This is the best tasting pizza in Northwest Indiana. I have tried them all and the Pizza Cellar is now our favorite. We had a deep dish and thin crust, both were outstanding. This is not your fast food, mediocre, “it’s not bad” quality pizzeria. All the ingredients were high quality, and you can immediately taste the difference. Seriously good pizza for serious pizza lovers.
Great pizza at a great price! Always received our order promptly and always a kind and courteous person on the other side of the line when we order. High recommend!
Best anywhere. Hands down. Anyone else in town is a far second place.
Old school gourmet food that you can get delivered or taken out, friendly customer service, five star hidden gem! Must try??
Fantastic pizza and great service! Wish I could rate it higher.
Can't give it any stars but had to give one because it won't let ya give zero stars! I'm only giving this place the one star because they were closed at 9pm on Monday April 3rd when they should of been open from what there hours say there open to 10! Not so!! Very disappointed no sign no morning about emergency they just weren't there I even drove up there thinking maybe they got busy and nope got there 9:10pm and nobody there and all light were shut off! Damn first time going to try ur pizza and this makes me not ever wanna try it now! If ur open till 10pm be open at 9pm and not be gone would be a great start but it is what it is
Best deep dish around. Make sure you add the homemade sausage to your deep dish, worth every dollar. Owner is always friendly and makes sure everything is good.
Restaurantji Recommends
would not recommend this place; burned pizza and no apology! and expensive -- definitely not worth it.
If You Like Deep Dish Pizza ? Pizza Cellar has The Best!
Whoever I talked to on the phone was so kind, and the delivery man was also so nice! Highly recommend
I've never heard of this place before I thought I would try something different because I'm tired of spending $40 for a large pizza from many of the places around here I looked around, did some searching and found the reviews here. I ordered the beef combo sandwich, and it was the best I have ever had. I would definitely recommend this place!!!
Not the cheapest, especially if you like lots of toppings, but I'm pretty sure this is the best pizza I've ever had.