La Herradura Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill

4610 Bellemeade Ave, Evansville
(812) 402-0355

Recent Reviews

Revive SIS&R

This was sooooooo good. I will return while in the area. The steak Faijita was seasoned to perfection. The soft drink was in a very large glass....No refill needed. The food topped my list for Mexican!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Fajitas, Steak

Torrey Mathie

Added specific instructions to have no tomatoes or red sauce, everything was covered in it. Ended up throwing all the food away. Will not order from them again.

Food: 1

Tanikia Johnson

This was my first time, and I will be returning. The food was delicious, including that cheesecake. They have a huge selection of margaritas flavors( frozen and on the rocks). Great prices, and I left feeling like a stuffed potato. Definitely recommendKid-friendliness: They have a good selection on the kids' menu. Even for the picky kids' tastebuds.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Quesadilla

Roger Patel

Not bad food but new servers under training so lots of guf

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

chanel monroe

This how you suppose to make tacos!!! Seasoned , the hot sauce is hot! It’s giving west coast in the Midwest because these mfs hit ! I usually get pork tacos but something told me to get chicken and lawwwwwddddd I couldn’t take a pic of the chicken because I ate them lol.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diane Bruner

The food is great. Staff always every time forget to put the extras in the bag

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Chicken on the Beach

Melea Pennington

Decorated very nice. Music was a little to loud. Service took forever and place was not

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Barbie

Ordered for the first time from here for carry out. Was really wanting some spinach dip so I ordered some. It's not spinach dip. It's queso cheese with a few pieces of spinach in it. Very liquidy and runny with no consistency. Was not impressed at all.

Food: 2

Jennilyn Brown

Honestly underwhelmed by this place. It was Cinco de Mayo and the employees could have cared less about being there. My chicken fajitas were burnt and no tomatoes. Flavorless. We were not given plates and had to wait a long time to find any server to let them know. Waited a long time to get the bill, and to get my change back. Used to like this place but after yesterday will never go back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Don Williams

You would think that it being Cinco De Mayo they would have staffed accordingly....especially the kitchen. Been here 90 minutes, gave our order the first 20 minutes of sitting down. Have had my drink refilled 2 times and they have refilled the chips twice alao.....at least I got full on chips and salsa.......Left with out getting food and still paid the bill for what I didn't get to eat.

hu tao

This review is about 3 weeks late- I've been here several times again and again for years, and the food used to be amazing, but it slowly got worse recently. My mother and I's food was cold and tasted bland. Terrible service too, the waiter gave us silverware, but put it on the table next to our booth and expected us to go get it ourselves. Wouldn't recommend!

David Bakken 55

Tonight we had much better service. There were a few messups but they were cleared up right away.I picked a simple dish this time, and it was good. The flan had whipped cream and drizzled chocolate on top that distracted from the appeal of the dish. I'll ask that to be left off next time.My date had the talapia and shrimp dish. She said it was wonderful. I'm thinking it may become a standard.Features: I did not notice anything special. The servers were not wearing masks. However at this time few places in town do.I applaud Google for adding this box. If / when the COVID19 issue has passed, this would be a good place to collect out of the ordinary pros and cons about the visit. For example, "They provide a special service for those who use a wheel chair" or "They discount meals for military and first responders in uniform."Vegetarian options: They have a few vegetarian dishes.Wheelchair accessibility: There is a handy wheelchair ramp with guide bars right at the front door. Unlike many that place this off to the side. I don't think they have handicap parking, but it was dark. I may have missed it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

David Schuck

I have eaten here several times over the past several years. The food, service and atmosphere have been consistently outstanding. The servers are fast and attentive to your dinning needs. If you are unsure of what you want to eat? Ask your server to make a suggestion, they will give you a few good choices and explain the details of the entry. The carnitas are one of my favorites. The chuletas are also close to my favorite. The red salsa has a good flavor. I am sure you will enjoy the dinning experience.Parking: Plenty of free parking. If you are like me and you don't want to park next to another vehicle just park off to the side. All the parking is easy in and out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chimichanga, Street Tacos

Jon SUTTON

Ordered delivery and they messed up the order. Asked for things to be specifically taken off of my kid's food and they left it on ruining her meal. When asking them to fix it they wouldn't. They also wouldn't refund it. DON'T go here if you expect correct orders or customer service. Highly suggest Casa Fiesta instead. Much better food and experience.

John Bailey

Good food. Great people! Just what I was looking for.Update: I stopped in again while in town for business... The food quality and consistency is excellent. Keep up the great work!#caramelthunderrules

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More

La Herradura Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill

4610 Bellemeade Ave, Evansville, IN 47714
(812) 402-0355