They are closing it was a low one because you are closed. Hopefully you can reopen later in the year
JASON PUTMAN
Friendly service and great treats!
Super Woman
Very detailed oriented staff! Very knowledgeable and friendly staff! I must say I enjoyed my forst visit and sure will revisit and put in orders! Thank you staff and Management! You girls Rock ♡☆ btw Happy New Year! We will ne coming for them macaroons! ♡☆☆☆☆☆
Ali Anderson
This was our first order, and we were so impressed! We knew the decorating would be great, based on the photos we’d seen of their other work. The taste of the cakes was also amazing! We will definitely be using Sweet Betty’s Bakery for our future cake orders!
Allison Tracy Shepherd
We loved our holiday cookies for classrooms! They were beautiful and yummy!
Amy Gardner
Absolute best coconut pie in the entire world, and hands down best service. I wanted two pies for Thanksgiving but covid had them struggling to meet demand so for a short time they limited their menu and my pies were no exception. But out of the blue I got an email over a month later from someone there who remembered I wanted the pies. She offered to make them for pick up the day before our dinner. This level of customer service is unheard of these days. I'm proud to be a customer of such a well operated establishment.
Courtney Hostetler
Ordered a Key lime pie for thanksgiving- it was very delicious! Picked up in store, the shop is super cute - Also bought some buckeyes while we were there. Will come back again next time we need a pie!
Dezarae Sandleben
they made us a beautiful birthday cake! it tasted great too.
Ray Terry
This bakery made my daughters bday so special . I called around and all other bakers were booked but this one and even though we had never tried it she said she could make the cake that we wanted . We msged back and fourth on msgr to work out the details.They came through and the cake was awesome and very tasty . This is where my future business is going to .
Shelby Renee Graber
Their cake is delicious and I showed them a picture of the cake I wanted for my sisters shower and they gave me exactly what I wanted we all loved it!
I wasn't able to make it to pick up my cookies before they closed and the owner offered to meet me later or the next day! Was so thoughtful of her and I'll be a customer forever! The cookies and cupcakes were out of this world too!!!! Talk about THE BEST customer service!
Rachel B
Sweet Betty's makes amazing cookies! I especially love their sugar cookies, chocolate chip with some kind of nut cookies and snickers cookies. There are a few others off the top of my head I'm forgetting because, shamefully, I haven't been there in awhile. She also home makes her caramels and the chocolate covered ones are scrumptious---my favorite. The shop definitely has one of the best ambiances of shops in Evansville (a real retro-ish, milkshake scoop shoppe feel that you see on television, you almost expect her to have ice cream in her cold cases) and the owner gives it that home made feel by offering to sell you milk with your baked goods---which i never decline.I really wish I liked her cupcakes more, as they're one of my favorite baked goods, but believe me *pats my tummy* I don't need it. Although I do like the sugar cookie cupcake very much!
Amber Brock
Ordered a mermaid cake for my little girl. Andrea was so helpful and even got the cake done early when my plans suddenly changed. The cake was beautiful and yummy. Highly recommended this bakery.
Suzie Spanner
Love Love Love all their goodies!!! Super friendly staff.
Ashleigh Kormelink
Sweet Betty’s is a magical place, where high standards are always met and exceeded. It’s the cutest storefront. I have always been impressed with their holiday items. Also, these wonderful humans make sure everything is perfect. Their fondant is always smooth, and the icing on cakes is not sloppy. My most recent purchase was for Easter goodies. I have included the chick and bunny butt picture because they are so stinking adorable and look how detailed they are! Love it!
They are closing it was a low one because you are closed. Hopefully you can reopen later in the year
Friendly service and great treats!
Very detailed oriented staff! Very knowledgeable and friendly staff! I must say I enjoyed my forst visit and sure will revisit and put in orders! Thank you staff and Management! You girls Rock ♡☆ btw Happy New Year! We will ne coming for them macaroons! ♡☆☆☆☆☆
This was our first order, and we were so impressed! We knew the decorating would be great, based on the photos we’d seen of their other work. The taste of the cakes was also amazing! We will definitely be using Sweet Betty’s Bakery for our future cake orders!
We loved our holiday cookies for classrooms! They were beautiful and yummy!
Absolute best coconut pie in the entire world, and hands down best service. I wanted two pies for Thanksgiving but covid had them struggling to meet demand so for a short time they limited their menu and my pies were no exception. But out of the blue I got an email over a month later from someone there who remembered I wanted the pies. She offered to make them for pick up the day before our dinner. This level of customer service is unheard of these days. I'm proud to be a customer of such a well operated establishment.
Ordered a Key lime pie for thanksgiving- it was very delicious! Picked up in store, the shop is super cute - Also bought some buckeyes while we were there. Will come back again next time we need a pie!
they made us a beautiful birthday cake! it tasted great too.
This bakery made my daughters bday so special . I called around and all other bakers were booked but this one and even though we had never tried it she said she could make the cake that we wanted . We msged back and fourth on msgr to work out the details.They came through and the cake was awesome and very tasty . This is where my future business is going to .
Their cake is delicious and I showed them a picture of the cake I wanted for my sisters shower and they gave me exactly what I wanted we all loved it!
Restaurantji Recommends
I wasn't able to make it to pick up my cookies before they closed and the owner offered to meet me later or the next day! Was so thoughtful of her and I'll be a customer forever! The cookies and cupcakes were out of this world too!!!! Talk about THE BEST customer service!
Sweet Betty's makes amazing cookies! I especially love their sugar cookies, chocolate chip with some kind of nut cookies and snickers cookies. There are a few others off the top of my head I'm forgetting because, shamefully, I haven't been there in awhile. She also home makes her caramels and the chocolate covered ones are scrumptious---my favorite. The shop definitely has one of the best ambiances of shops in Evansville (a real retro-ish, milkshake scoop shoppe feel that you see on television, you almost expect her to have ice cream in her cold cases) and the owner gives it that home made feel by offering to sell you milk with your baked goods---which i never decline.I really wish I liked her cupcakes more, as they're one of my favorite baked goods, but believe me *pats my tummy* I don't need it. Although I do like the sugar cookie cupcake very much!
Ordered a mermaid cake for my little girl. Andrea was so helpful and even got the cake done early when my plans suddenly changed. The cake was beautiful and yummy. Highly recommended this bakery.
Love Love Love all their goodies!!! Super friendly staff.
Sweet Betty’s is a magical place, where high standards are always met and exceeded. It’s the cutest storefront. I have always been impressed with their holiday items. Also, these wonderful humans make sure everything is perfect. Their fondant is always smooth, and the icing on cakes is not sloppy. My most recent purchase was for Easter goodies. I have included the chick and bunny butt picture because they are so stinking adorable and look how detailed they are! Love it!