Papa Johns Pizza

10574 E 96th St, Fishers
(317) 841-7272

Recent Reviews

Grace Waltermann

Matt stephens was a really kind worker and he was so nice to me and my friends and we really appreciate him! The service was excellent and they were very helpful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael G

My order was delivered within 35 minutes, good quality product, didn't forget extra sauces or sides plus driver was kind. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lauren W

Are all the pizzas now thin crust? I ordered an epic crust pizza and the pizza was thin as a thin crust pizza...It was made

Food: 1

Alexandra Cruz

This place is amazing at night I don't know why nobody comes to order during these times. The people in the night shift very chill they're also super friendly as well we even had a little conversation as we waited for the pizza to get ready. They really are a nice and friendly staff. The place is also very clean so there's no complaint to anything dirty and their pizza still good will definitely love to come back and order in person

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Esteban Marroquin

I came in at night and the staff were so nice and would totally come

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Colton Thomas

For deliveries, tip good and your food will be hot. Only problem I have are the bread sticks. You will either receive the perfect bread stick or something that has gone through the oven twice. Very rarely do I receive good bread sticks. Almost every time they have been through the oven twice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mert Ozbahcivan

I didn’t understand about badly reviews, they are making really good pizza, I used work papa jhons before, it was not even close this taste, good jobs guys.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Naaman Davis

This location makes absolute trash pizza. This was my 3 and final time trying. They have zero care for the product they produce. This time the pizza was overcooked and dry; very little sauce or toppings. I wish I would have thought to take a picture to share. Anyway you have been warned. Stay away from this location.

Food: 1

Dakota Sanders

Will never order from this store again multiple times they've either forgot my drink or my pizza will come like it had been tossed around the whole delivery drive to me and I've let it slide because they've always given a credit or replaced my food buy this time they wouldn't do that so save yourself the time and order from a different location

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mars Harr

Pizza was timely cooked; and well presented. Great job!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sheldon Cooper

Cuts corners and rushes too much. 2 years ago, they did a wonderful job with my stuffed crust pizza order.However, this time when I order stuffed crust, I did not get stuffed crust. I got 2 pizzas that was reheated in 10 minutes despite me telling them not to rush,when I clicked the 10% tip button it tipped 20% instead, and overall the experience disappointed me.I'm going for sister branches of Papa Johns instead. Stay away from this Papa John's location like the plague, or at minimum, check your order before leaving.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: The Driest Pizza Ever

Jim Kassebaum

The quality of the pizzas has improved, generous

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Parmesan Crusted Papadias

Carmen DeFusco

Waited over two hours for our pizza to be delivered. Cold and rubbery when delivered by DoorDash—we ordered through the Papa John’s app…

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Brothers First

If I can give a negative star I would. This was our favorite pizza spot for 3 reasons. Its close to our home and we were getting 50% military discount and my kids and grandkids love it, all 20 of them. So we ordered some pizzas using a online coupon for $7.99 ea. When we arrived, not only did they rudely refuse to honor the coupon, they now are saying that the military discount is now 25% instead of 50%. When we asked to speak to the manager, we were told he didn't have time to speak to us. I have 4 kids and 20 grandkids so We spend alot of money with these guys when we get together. NO MORE! I will drive out my area for pizza from now on rather than spend another cent with Papa John's. We can't say for sure that it was our race that caused the disrespect, but they do have a history! Just Saying.

Andrea White

Agree with other reviews. This used to be our go to place to order. The last two times we ordered, delivery was estimated 2 hrs out. 2.5 hours later, still no pizza. Tonight I called and waited on hold for a manager 25 minutes just to find out the status of our order. We had time to drive to the store, while waiting on hold, only to be told our order had been sitting there for 1.5 hours and had not been sent out for delivery. Very disappointed. I understand busy, but communicating is key.

Load More