My boyfriend and I went for a fancy date night and that is what we received. Everything was delicious and our waiter, who's name is Coy, deserves a shout out because he was so pleasant and sweet. He also paid for our desserts and brought us complementary truffles! Hopefully we get to go back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeremiah C.
Very unexpected! Prime Rib, side potatoes, and pasta were all top notch. I highly recommend if you haven't tried this or are visiting town and looking for a good streak dinner in a white table cloth setting. Staff was overly nice and they have a decent size bar for the solo traveler or date night dinner without reservations. I recommend reservations on the weekends or during peak holidays. Perfect place for celebration. Extensive wine and spirits selection.
Aravind Madasamy
The food was good but the service was better. I had Coy as my server, and his service was top class. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Chocolate Crème Brûlée
shirish mehta
Excellent food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trent R.
Since moving to Indiana my wife and I will drive by and say we need to try this place. Today was our 21st anniversary and we did try it. I had the 20 oz cowboy ribeye and the disappointment on my face was pretty obvious to my wife. She asked what was wrong and my response was... I think they cooked this at Waffle House and brought it back to me. For a place that claimed that they are known for steaks, it was the worst steak I've had in 48 years of my life. For a cowboy ribeye it was thin and just not well prepared. Nothing seemed to have flavor that we ordered. I tried my wife's lobster bisque and no flavor at all. She enjoyed her crab cakes. Only reason for 2 stars. I felt like tonight someone stole 250 from me that we will never get back. Moving forward we will continue to just drive by and not wonder what it is like anymore.
Christopher G.
Good steak house. Above average service. Pleasant atmosphere. Average pricing/value. Met expectations.
Eileen E.
Peterson's is exceptional in every aspect of an elevated dining experience. Coy was our service specialist on the evening we visited and provided us with a night we will remember forever as we celebrated our 35th anniversary. The food was phenomenal and each course was expertly prepared. We have been visiting Peterson's for many years and each time we visit, we are reminded of why it continues to be our favorite.
Penny Forcade
Love this restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Seufert
Coy is a fantastic server. The food was great and the environment was enjoyable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine H
Service was lovely. Was there to have early dinner on New Years Eve. Had one of the specials, and the snapper was delicious. Enjoyed the meal.
Excellent service and very high quality food. Even better if you go on a night when they have half-price bottles of wine. Wine selection is excellent. Desserts and after-dinner drinks make for a great finish.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Maine Lobster Bisque, Prime Rib Egg Rolls
Kelvin Johnson
Our first time there and the experience was very good. Coy our server kept us entertained and the food was great. I am only sorry that I didn't have room for dessert ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Maine Lobster Bisque, Prime Rib Egg Rolls, Lobster Fingers
Dorothy Gholson
Can’t go wrong eating here! Coi was an amazing waiter for us tonight! Thank you!!
Shannon Richardson
Our experience was absolutely amazing. We came here for our 5th anniversary. Everyone in the restaurant said happy anniversary. They gave us a complementary picture and card. Our server Sergio was amazing. If you are in the area, definitely go!Parking: Plenty of parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Au Gratin Potatoes, Lobster Fingers
Andrew Weflen (awef)
I rarely leave a negative review, but have to say we were very disappointed - heard a lot of great things from several people, so perhaps came in with too high of expectations. service was just okay - server didn’t seem interested in chatting with us or sharing much about the wines. our appetizer of shrimp with stuffed crab was delicious, but the steaks were awful, honestly worst steaks my wife and I have had at a restaurant. The filet mignon tasted like hamburger meat, and the prime rib was rather bland. We ordered the lobster macaroni and it was so fishy neither of us could eat it. The crème brulee came out completely burned on top, to the point where it tasted like ash. definitely not worth the 500 dollars spent on dinner, incredibly disappointed!
My boyfriend and I went for a fancy date night and that is what we received. Everything was delicious and our waiter, who's name is Coy, deserves a shout out because he was so pleasant and sweet. He also paid for our desserts and brought us complementary truffles! Hopefully we get to go back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very unexpected! Prime Rib, side potatoes, and pasta were all top notch. I highly recommend if you haven't tried this or are visiting town and looking for a good streak dinner in a white table cloth setting. Staff was overly nice and they have a decent size bar for the solo traveler or date night dinner without reservations. I recommend reservations on the weekends or during peak holidays. Perfect place for celebration. Extensive wine and spirits selection.
The food was good but the service was better. I had Coy as my server, and his service was top class. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Chocolate Crème Brûlée
Excellent food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Since moving to Indiana my wife and I will drive by and say we need to try this place. Today was our 21st anniversary and we did try it. I had the 20 oz cowboy ribeye and the disappointment on my face was pretty obvious to my wife. She asked what was wrong and my response was... I think they cooked this at Waffle House and brought it back to me. For a place that claimed that they are known for steaks, it was the worst steak I've had in 48 years of my life. For a cowboy ribeye it was thin and just not well prepared. Nothing seemed to have flavor that we ordered. I tried my wife's lobster bisque and no flavor at all. She enjoyed her crab cakes. Only reason for 2 stars. I felt like tonight someone stole 250 from me that we will never get back. Moving forward we will continue to just drive by and not wonder what it is like anymore.
Good steak house. Above average service. Pleasant atmosphere. Average pricing/value. Met expectations.
Peterson's is exceptional in every aspect of an elevated dining experience. Coy was our service specialist on the evening we visited and provided us with a night we will remember forever as we celebrated our 35th anniversary. The food was phenomenal and each course was expertly prepared. We have been visiting Peterson's for many years and each time we visit, we are reminded of why it continues to be our favorite.
Love this restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Coy is a fantastic server. The food was great and the environment was enjoyable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was lovely. Was there to have early dinner on New Years Eve. Had one of the specials, and the snapper was delicious. Enjoyed the meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oysters Rockefeller
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent service and very high quality food. Even better if you go on a night when they have half-price bottles of wine. Wine selection is excellent. Desserts and after-dinner drinks make for a great finish.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Maine Lobster Bisque, Prime Rib Egg Rolls
Our first time there and the experience was very good. Coy our server kept us entertained and the food was great. I am only sorry that I didn't have room for dessert ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Maine Lobster Bisque, Prime Rib Egg Rolls, Lobster Fingers
Can’t go wrong eating here! Coi was an amazing waiter for us tonight! Thank you!!
Our experience was absolutely amazing. We came here for our 5th anniversary. Everyone in the restaurant said happy anniversary. They gave us a complementary picture and card. Our server Sergio was amazing. If you are in the area, definitely go!Parking: Plenty of parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Au Gratin Potatoes, Lobster Fingers
I rarely leave a negative review, but have to say we were very disappointed - heard a lot of great things from several people, so perhaps came in with too high of expectations. service was just okay - server didn’t seem interested in chatting with us or sharing much about the wines. our appetizer of shrimp with stuffed crab was delicious, but the steaks were awful, honestly worst steaks my wife and I have had at a restaurant. The filet mignon tasted like hamburger meat, and the prime rib was rather bland. We ordered the lobster macaroni and it was so fishy neither of us could eat it. The crème brulee came out completely burned on top, to the point where it tasted like ash. definitely not worth the 500 dollars spent on dinner, incredibly disappointed!