Unpredictable hours they open and close whenever they feel like it. No consistent hours whatsoever I do not know how they’re going to stay in business please do not write an owner response. I have a severe condition and I could end up in the hospital. Thank you!
Ann Koofer
A gem for sweets. The buttercream on the Neopolitan cupcake was smooth, creamy & not too sweet. The cake was moist. Will be back again for more. Worth the trip.
Evan Smith
Was a little confused by their website initially. I would just recommend going in or calling. The staff was super helpful with the questions I had, and it was super easy to place an order. I left with a bunch of cheesecakes that were probably some of the best I’ve ever had. Additionally it was way cheaper than I anticipated.It’s really dangerous to my waistline and wallet with how good the sweets are, but I’d highly recommend supporting this small business.
Catherine Bumgarner
Walked in to get a special treat for my son for some great news we had just found out. There wasn't a soul in the place. Was told "Will be with you in a sec". The girl then proceeded to go grab a cupcake. Put it in a box. Go grab a cookie. Put it in a bag. Go grab another cookie. Put it in a bag. Phones not ringing, no one around, no one waiting on an order. After about 5 mins of witnessing this I politely gave her some advice about the service industry. You ALWAYS take care of the person that is right in front of you first, that grub hub or online order can wait. I also have never seen a person move that slow in my life. 2.27.23 5:15pm
Jenni N
Fantastic to work with - kind, patient & open to ideas while planning - final product was absolutely DELICIOUS - piñata sprinkle theme, a very happy birthday girl & boy - & guests!! Will be back and highly recommend!!
Louise “prettyblk” Sandifer
Good cupcakes. I like the icing best. Brown butter caramel & sweet potato. My gf cupcake was decent.
Tina Q.
We stopped in for cupcakes for my daughter's birthday dinner. These were the best cupcakes I have ever had. We like to shop small whoever possible and tried something new, we will definitely go back again.
Sarah W.
Cute little bakery for when you get that random craving for something sweet. I had the red velvet cup cake and it was the bomb. Couldn't stop eating it. They are a little bit bigger than a regular cupcake but smaller than the ones you can get at the flying cupcake. It's the perfect size. It's sweet but not overboard. The personal size of the pecan pie was good and not underwhelming. Wish they did have a couple of more things in stock when I had stopped by. Cheesecakes we're alright. All in all, you should give them a try, especially for the red velvet cupcake.
Buster L.
Killer cupcakes, however, the price-point is quite "salty" for those cupcakes. Friendly cashier. Helpful.
Miranda M.
My wedding cake turned out perfect. It was so beautiful and tasted amazing, couldn't be any happier.
BEST BAKERY EVER! Now I may be biased given I had worked there 2 years ago, but they make the best baked goods. Came in on Friday morning, service was excellent and the girl at the front counter told me a really cool fun fact. I bought 18 cupcakes and an apple pie to take to work for some departing coworkers. Was able to get gluten free cupcakes for my allergy coworkers. And all together was a great price! 11/10 would recommend.Everyone at my job said these were the best cupcakes that had ever had and are super excited to check out Sweeties for more treats. Special shout out to DaShell for letting me know about gluten free cupcakes and the best ones to get! Super thankful to Tiffany for having a great business. Please support this black owned business.
Chelsea Overstreet
I ordered a cake for our son's 10th birthday. The customer service with cake design was excellent and the cake was so delicious.
T B
Great on the taste and moistness. BUT, over priced. Literally plastic flowers instead of piping on top. Candy paper covered full bottom and it was printed and applied unevenly on bottom tier. 2nd tier was pretty but $400 for a cake is extreme, even for Fishers. I would not have argued if I was buying skills. But printed bottom and Plastic flowers on top...
Milton Flournoy
Love this bakery. My go to for birthday and events especially since they have gluten free options.
Debra V.
Perfect small, but shareable, sized cheesecakes. Quite a few varieties and other treats. The cheesecake is out of this world creamy. Yum!
Unpredictable hours they open and close whenever they feel like it. No consistent hours whatsoever I do not know how they’re going to stay in business please do not write an owner response. I have a severe condition and I could end up in the hospital. Thank you!
A gem for sweets. The buttercream on the Neopolitan cupcake was smooth, creamy & not too sweet. The cake was moist. Will be back again for more. Worth the trip.
Was a little confused by their website initially. I would just recommend going in or calling. The staff was super helpful with the questions I had, and it was super easy to place an order. I left with a bunch of cheesecakes that were probably some of the best I’ve ever had. Additionally it was way cheaper than I anticipated.It’s really dangerous to my waistline and wallet with how good the sweets are, but I’d highly recommend supporting this small business.
Walked in to get a special treat for my son for some great news we had just found out. There wasn't a soul in the place. Was told "Will be with you in a sec". The girl then proceeded to go grab a cupcake. Put it in a box. Go grab a cookie. Put it in a bag. Go grab another cookie. Put it in a bag. Phones not ringing, no one around, no one waiting on an order. After about 5 mins of witnessing this I politely gave her some advice about the service industry. You ALWAYS take care of the person that is right in front of you first, that grub hub or online order can wait. I also have never seen a person move that slow in my life. 2.27.23 5:15pm
Fantastic to work with - kind, patient & open to ideas while planning - final product was absolutely DELICIOUS - piñata sprinkle theme, a very happy birthday girl & boy - & guests!! Will be back and highly recommend!!
Good cupcakes. I like the icing best. Brown butter caramel & sweet potato. My gf cupcake was decent.
We stopped in for cupcakes for my daughter's birthday dinner. These were the best cupcakes I have ever had. We like to shop small whoever possible and tried something new, we will definitely go back again.
Cute little bakery for when you get that random craving for something sweet. I had the red velvet cup cake and it was the bomb. Couldn't stop eating it. They are a little bit bigger than a regular cupcake but smaller than the ones you can get at the flying cupcake. It's the perfect size. It's sweet but not overboard. The personal size of the pecan pie was good and not underwhelming. Wish they did have a couple of more things in stock when I had stopped by. Cheesecakes we're alright. All in all, you should give them a try, especially for the red velvet cupcake.
Killer cupcakes, however, the price-point is quite "salty" for those cupcakes. Friendly cashier. Helpful.
My wedding cake turned out perfect. It was so beautiful and tasted amazing, couldn't be any happier.
Restaurantji Recommends
BEST BAKERY EVER! Now I may be biased given I had worked there 2 years ago, but they make the best baked goods. Came in on Friday morning, service was excellent and the girl at the front counter told me a really cool fun fact. I bought 18 cupcakes and an apple pie to take to work for some departing coworkers. Was able to get gluten free cupcakes for my allergy coworkers. And all together was a great price! 11/10 would recommend.Everyone at my job said these were the best cupcakes that had ever had and are super excited to check out Sweeties for more treats. Special shout out to DaShell for letting me know about gluten free cupcakes and the best ones to get! Super thankful to Tiffany for having a great business. Please support this black owned business.
I ordered a cake for our son's 10th birthday. The customer service with cake design was excellent and the cake was so delicious.
Great on the taste and moistness. BUT, over priced. Literally plastic flowers instead of piping on top. Candy paper covered full bottom and it was printed and applied unevenly on bottom tier. 2nd tier was pretty but $400 for a cake is extreme, even for Fishers. I would not have argued if I was buying skills. But printed bottom and Plastic flowers on top...
Love this bakery. My go to for birthday and events especially since they have gluten free options.
Perfect small, but shareable, sized cheesecakes. Quite a few varieties and other treats. The cheesecake is out of this world creamy. Yum!